Observatoire academic ethics
Menu

Salman Rushdie is also a victim of "Islamo-complacency"

Illustration for the article "Salman Rushdie is also a victim of 'Islamo-complacency'"

Salman Rushdie is also a victim of "Islamo-complacency"

Renee Fregosi

Philosopher and political scientist. Member of Dhimmi Watch. Latest published work: Fifty Shades of Dictatorship. Authoritarian Temptations and Controls in France and Elsewhere. Éditions de l'Aube, 2022

Table of contents

Illustration for the article "Salman Rushdie is also a victim of 'Islamo-complacency'"

Salman Rushdie is also a victim of "Islamo-complacency"

[by Renée Fregosi, excerpted with her permission from Penser Salman Rushdie , Coordinated by Daniel Salvatore Schiffer, Éditions de l'Aube Released on November 10, 2022]

The designated emblematic enemy of Islamism

In 1989, the injunction made to the "true believers" to kill Salman Rushdie and all his accomplices illustrated in the clearest possible terms what was going on in the global neo-Islamist offensive. Since 1979, the signs of the rise of Muslim fundamentalism had multiplied, but it was above all the terrorist attacks (whose sponsors were not always clearly identified) that struck people's minds, and democracies did not seem to understand the global polymorphic phenomenon that was developing. While that same year, 1989, was marked in France by the affair of the veiled schoolgirls of Creil, euphemistically called the "headscarf affair", reactions to oppose what was called at the time "the rise of Muslim fundamentalism" were dramatically lacking, and support for Salman Rushdie was very few. 

Today, the Islamist jihadist offensive, "Salafist-Brotherhood" in nature, is undeniable. The murderous attack against Salman Rushdie, who belatedly responded to the initial Islamist call to kill "infidels" outside the "lands of Islam," is now part of a long litany of attacks and assassinations perpetrated for this reason throughout the world in the name of "Allah the Most Great." The French think tank Fondapol has recorded "48,035 Islamist attacks worldwide between 1979 and May 2021, resulting in the deaths of at least 210,138 people," and their increase is exponential: "1979-2000: 2,194 attacks and 6,817 deaths; 2001-2012: 8,265 attacks and 38,186 deaths." 2013-May 2021: 37,576 attacks and 165,135 deaths » [1] .

Through the individuals massacred by Islamists, it is free thought and bodily autonomy that are targeted—issues raised, of course, by The Satanic Verses . Parodying "holy scriptures," mocking the puritanical hypocrisy of a debauched prophet, or simply posing eternal metaphysical and existential questions without absolute answers—all these are unacceptable statements for a militant orthodoxy that rejects humor as much as doubt and criticism. Beyond the West, its humanism, and its universalism, it is emancipatory culture in general that is the target. From the extermination of the Algerian intelligentsia by the GIA to the children murdered in their schools in Pakistan, from the Buddhas of Bamiyan to the precious manuscripts of the mosque of Timbuktu, from the Pardo Museum in Tunis to the monuments of Palmyra, it is the awakening of consciences to free inquiry and free choice that is condemned, as are all the pleasures of the senses: images, music, dance, even the beauty of landscapes, and those of sex in all its emotions, of course.

Because, as is often recalled, Muslims are the "first" victims of Islamism, which is undeniable from the point of view of numbers: "The Middle East and North Africa, South Asia and sub-Saharan Africa have concentrated 95,7% of Islamist attacks between 1979 and May 2021" [2] . The globalized Islamist offensive has two aspects, the first of which consists of the re-Islamization of the so-called Muslim world, originally advocated by Hassan al-Banna in the 20s. Against the incomplete modernity imposed by Western colonialism and then Kemalism and Arab nationalisms, neo-Islamists inspired in particular by Sayyid Qutb, Ayatollah Khomeini or Youssef al-Qaradawi reactivate a rigorous traditional Islam and fuel a new mystique of conquest conceived both as a reconquest, including territorial reconquest, of the historical spaces of the various caliphates (including Israel of course) and as a planetary expansion through the diffusion of the great principles of Sharia. Specialists like Gilles Kepel [3] or Michaël Prazan [4] have perfectly explained this totalitarian logic which therefore also targets the West.

The second objective of the Islamist offensive is thus the Islamization of Europe, and particularly of France, a former colonial power and a land of significant Muslim immigration. The aim here is not to convert the entire population to Islam, but to influence public opinion in general and the decision-makers in particular, in order to gain acceptance of the core principles of fundamentalism: the recognition of blasphemy and apostasy as crimes, the separation of the sexes, communitarianism leading to distinct rights for individuals, the veiling of women's bodies, the prohibition of mixed marriages without prior conversion to Islam, the systematic adoption of dietary restrictions in school cafeterias, and so on. To achieve this, Islamists employ a combination of methods: the manipulation of segments of the immigrant population, the actions of their useful idiots [5] , persuasion through institutional infiltration, and the strategy of creating tension through violence.

In France, we regularly witness a succession of assassinations and attacks against Jewish people, considered by Islamists to be the ancestral enemy of Muslims, as well as against journalists, teachers, and people free to enjoy life's pleasures in the streets and cafes. There has also been a rise in the desecration of Jewish and Christian places of worship and cemeteries. Furthermore, we see daily the gradual, widespread dissemination of the Muslim Brotherhood's ideology. Yet, a large number of political leaders still persist in denying or downplaying it, and the attempted assassination of Salman Rushdie did not elicit widespread and unequivocal support from all democrats. Certainly, in France, "the political class condemns" [6] , but many elected officials and representatives of civil society still evade the issue, preferring to speak of "fanaticism," "obscurantism," and a "permanent threat" [7] rather than clearly identifying the Islamist enemy.

The Useful Idiots of Islamism

Since the spectacular Al Qaeda attack on the Twin Towers in 2001, when jihad was manifesting itself to the world in all its scope, a certain left has clearly made itself the useful idiot of Islamism: continuing its long-standing blind support for "the Palestinian cause", the left of the political and intellectual left systematically defends the demands of political Islam without worrying about their anti-democratic, anti-republican, sexist and anti-Semitic character, nor even their terrorist violence. 

Jean Baudrillard [8] or Jacques Derrida [9] have practically justified the attacks of September 11, 2001, and Noam Chomsky [10] , those of January 2015 in Paris. It was out of the question for them to defend Salman Rushdie, whom they would have readily labeled a traitor in the same way that Boualem Sansal, Kamel Daoud, or Zineb el Rhazoui are today insulted and called “native auxiliaries” [11] of “neo-colonial” reactionaries. For intellectuals “of Muslim origin” are assigned to the Muslim religion and are vilified when they proclaim their atheism or even their opposition to fundamentalist versions of Islam. While they are in mortal danger, accused by Islamists of blasphemy and apostasy, their criticisms of Islamism or their simple demand for freedom of conception of Islam are considered by this left as manifestations of "Islamophobia" and racism.

Islamo-leftism, as defined by Pierre-André Taguieff [12] ( ), equates Islamism with Islam, Islam with North African and African immigrant populations, and immigrants with the new "wretched of the earth." In this, the far left plays right into the hands of the Islamists themselves, who are fighting against Western societies. Echoing the logic of minority "vanguards" who achieved "connection with the people" by infiltrating mass nationalist movements, this left now readily views Islamist movements as a Trojan horse for its own anti-capitalist strategy. For them, Islamism is an "objective" ally against the despised West, in a self-hatred reminiscent of that which animated the bourgeois Marxists of yesterday, redeeming their fault of despised social belonging by going to convert the proletarian masses up to the "workbench" of the factories.

We are also familiar with the Islamo-clientelism of both the right and the left, which, in order to garner votes from French citizens of immigrant origin, advocates "no waves" and "nothing to do with Islam," and immediately labels Islamist assassins as "lone wolves" and "unbalanced." Céline Pina [13] has described this well. Less frequently denounced is another form of Islamo-complacency that is just as culpable: Islamo-negligence, which minimizes the danger posed by Islamists. Islamism is presented as a secondary, even negligible, phenomenon compared to the threat of the far right. A variation of this type of position involves the invention of the "identity trap." By placing them on equal footing, and accusing them of mutually supporting each other, the two threats are presented as antagonistic and symmetrical, and the supposed danger that the far right would represent in this "balanced" vision inevitably parallels the very real Islamist assaults.

Yet it is Islamism that calls for “revenge” for Salman Rushdie’s alleged offenses to Islam and attempts to assassinate him. It is Islamism that kills, persecutes and terrorizes non-conforming Muslims, Jews, Christians, Yezidis, apostates, atheists, free thinkers and all vectors of freedom of expression. Not so much the neo-Nazi groups when there are any left. The constant threat to the existence of the State of Israel and to the lives of Israelis is Muslim extremism with its rockets, its knife murderers and the search for nuclear weapons. Not so much the Nazi allies of yesterday’s Arab nationalism. The enemy on the front line against secularism today is Islamism. Not so much the far-right that has become populist and has even made it its new mascot.

As for the argument of "playing into the hands of the extreme right" by refusing to denounce Islamist atrocities or by using the rhetoric of social and colonial excuses, it is all the more fallacious since the true allies of the extreme right, heir to Nazi anti-Semitism and retrograde and misogynistic Pétainism, are precisely the Islamists. Rather than opposing each other, were not the Islamists and the most reactionary fringe of the Catholic right united in the fight against same-sex marriage? Could it not be that the return within "liberated" Western societies of a certain prudish and oppressive conservatism, particularly for women, is largely due to the convergence between the pressure exerted by Islamism and old traditionalist and fundamentalist religious currents which are therefore regaining strength? Their common "reaction" is, it is true, encouraged by the delirious extremism of militant wokeism, itself paradoxically very puritanical. 

"Islamo-Nazism" is also a historical constant, from the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem proposing to Hitler the formation of a Muslim SS division, to the former Nazis, some of whom converted to Islam, warmly welcomed after 1947 by the Arab regimes in the Middle East to fight against the young State of Israel. The Islamist-extreme right alliance continues today in Latin America, for example, where Hezbollah is just as linked to former supporters of the dictatorships of the 70s as to the Castro regimes of Cuba or Venezuela. It is also the same anti-Semitism that drives the Holocaust deniers nostalgic for Nazism that Dieudonné willingly invited to his rallies-shows, also denouncing the famous "Islamophobia". 

But within the left and political ecology, there is a commitment to the burkini in municipalities or to the veil at university, within sports associations there is an attempt to impose the hijab on playing fields and in women's athletics, within humanitarian associations promoting "living together" there is acquiescence to the practices of a fundamentalist Islam, and even at the heart of associations defending secularism there is a dismantling of secular principles in the name of an "open" secularism based on "religious freedom" and no longer on freedom of conscience. School of course, but also other public services and the state apparatus are part of the stakes of Islamist entryism. We see it at work at the Fondation de l'islam de France which, under the cover of secularism, trivializes the expansion of Islam in France.

Faced with these realities, how can left-wingers, defenders of democracy, secularism, and public and individual liberties, fail to consider Islamism the most immediate threat? Certainly, the anti-Islamist commitment of "left-wing intellectuals" like Jacques Julliard and Georges Bensoussan, as well as a few very small minority figures like Manuel Valls, now out of the picture, should be acknowledged. But despite large segments of the disillusioned former Socialist electorate, who have taken refuge in abstention or even switched to the National Rally, the leaders of this "zombie left" [14] ( , as well as many secular activists who have not updated their analyses, persist in not taking a resolute stand against the Islamist offensive.

"The new Socialist Party", breaking in 1971 with the line of the defunct SFIO, had never been very keen to defend secular principles. And it showed itself to be particularly reluctant to fight against the new enemies of secularism that are the Islamists when they clearly began to test the republican defenses from 1989. Finally, the calamitous candidate of the PS in the 2017 presidential election was a perfect representative of Islamo-leftism. But it is also the clientelist Islamo-complacency and especially the guilt-inducing Islamo-neglect of the various sectors of the democratic left, which weakens the fight against Islamism. Thus, the convoluted or watered-down expressions of the partisan and journalistic institutional left after the attempted assassination of Salman Rushdie were as scandalous as they were sadly predictable.

The language of Islamism and dhimmitude

The use of the expression "controversial work" by Agence France-Presse [15] ) and its unquestioning repetition by numerous French media outlets and political figures is entirely symptomatic of an Islamo-compliantness that could be likened to the submission of Dhimmis. To avoid angering Islamists, it is advisable to show a certain disapproval of any questioning of the Muslim religion, however poetic, metaphorical, or even supposed. For Westerners now also live under the threat and in fear of jihadist reprisals. But if they believe they can avoid them by systematically showing complacency towards Islamic fundamentalism, they have completely misunderstood the conquering logic of this politico-religious movement: whatever is done to appease them, the fighters of "the true faith" try to advance and impose their domination on the minds and bodies of all.

For Islamist ideology infiltrates in numerous ways and also conditions individuals without their knowledge. Like the "language of the Third Reich" [16] , the vocabulary of Islamism spreads throughout the general population. Reporting the words of Ramin Parham, a former Iranian far-left activist who was once fascinated by the Khomeini revolution and later sought refuge in France, Michaël Prazan notes that the death sentence of Salman Rushdie "brought the word 'fatwa' into the vocabulary and dictionaries" and constitutes a "prodigious means of communicating at minimal cost." "This fatwa is disseminated by Western media, technology, and culture, propagating the terror embodied by Iran: a terror that has since been internalized and will gradually permeate even the most secretive corners of every editorial board in the Western world." From then on, each newspaper will ask itself the question of the consequences before writing anything that touches on Islam and its laws” [17] Here we touch on an essential point of dhimmitude: the transformation of an imposition into voluntary servitude.

Dhimmitude is the subordinate status of populations under Muslim domination, oppressed because of their gender or their non-membership of "the community of believers", that is, Muslims. Women, considered inferior and impure by divine will, are subject to men and must obey them under penalty of punishment up to and including death by stoning. Jews and Christians living in "Islamic lands" are tolerated there only if they accept their humiliating condition and the taxes that go with it, and even then they are always under threat of sporadic mistreatment or brutal expulsion for no other reason than the mood of Muslims. The imposition of dhimmitude is not a reaction to any aggression but an injunction from conquering Islam and its system is once again relevant in the global neo-Islamist offensive.

So, retreating from the secular principles that are the foundation of the French Republic, as well as from the secularized morals generally adopted by all Western societies (individuals freed from religious influence in their life choices), does not constitute a modus vivendi that is "reasonably accommodating" with Islam. It is completely illusory and therefore unreasonable to believe that integrating the prohibitions of rigorous Islam into our societies and a fortiori into our law, would promote a moderation of Islamism: on the contrary, interpreted as a sign of weakness, Islamists push their demands further and increase their influence. Not only is it not appropriate to play tricks on Islamism, but we must also valiantly foil all its traps.

The normalization of women's veiling is certainly emblematic of the progress of Islamism in so-called "Muslim" countries as well as in the West. But it is undoubtedly the most visible part of the offensive, the red herring, so to speak, that Islamists wave to conceal the extent of their all-out offensive. Pressure to have blasphemy condemned in the positive laws of various states, whether supposedly secular or not, as required by Sharia law, is another essential goal of Islamists. They have achieved their aim in so-called Muslim countries even when these countries present themselves as secular. This is also the case with the Palestinian Authority of the PLO when it imprisons and tortures the young Waleed Al-Husseini accused of being a blasphemer [18] , or in Egypt with General al-Sisi who persecute young people, democrats and Christians for blasphemy [19] .

Some Anglo-Saxon countries that have retained the crime of blasphemy in their laws, although it has fallen into disuse, find themselves today weakened by Islamist pressure to condemn any expression that they consider to be detrimental to Islam or its prophet Mohammed. This Anglo-Saxon tradition has undoubtedly also worked against Salman Rushdie. But in France, where the torture of the Chevalier de la Barre in 1766 had a strong impact on the defenders of the Enlightenment, the abolition of the crime of blasphemy was one of the issues of the Revolution of 1789 and since then a marker of the Republic. It is therefore all the more shocking to note the weakness of the camp of supporters of Salman Rushdie accused of blasphemy by the Islamist assassins.

Against the totalitarianism of the third type that is Islamism, the mobilization must be general, and massive must be the support for all the targets of the jihadists like Salman Rushdie. The secular and democratic left must come out of its reserve and no longer fear being assimilated to certain anti-Islamists who would not be acceptable because of their political affiliation or their supposed anti-Arab or anti-Muslim tropism. Salman Rushdie is a symbol of resistance to Islamism and the fight against dhimmitude. He must be defended as such without pusillanimity, without euphemism or "controversy", whether we appreciate his literary style or not!

Share this article

Facebook X LinkedIn

Author

Right of reply and contributions
Would you like to respond? Submit an opinion piece proposal →

You might also like:

Back to school 2026: the ongoing monitoring

The start of the academic year is traditionally a time for announcements: new courses, new seminars, calls for proposals, conferences, and research programs outline the direction of the coming year. At the Observatory, we consider it our mission to document this academic news, make it accessible, and preserve a record of it. Saclay, Sorbonne, Nanterre, Sciences Po—it's all covered...

Defending video games is a philosophical imperative in the face of a perverse state.

A state that presents itself as a protector while treating parents as incapable minors, and children as subjects to be removed from reality, builds a society where no one is accountable for transmission.
What you have left to read
0 %

Maybe you should subscribe?

Otherwise, it's okay! You can close this window and continue reading.

    Register: