Observatoire academic ethics
Menu

“The Insurrection of Particularities”: Chantal Delsol Faces the Decline of the Universal – a Review by Emmanuelle Hénin

Illustration for the article “'The Insurrection of Particularities': Chantal Delsol facing the decline of the universal – a review by Emmanuelle Hénin”

“The Insurrection of Particularities”: Chantal Delsol Faces the Decline of the Universal – a Review by Emmanuelle Hénin

In "Insurrection of Particularities," Chantal Delsol analyzes the decline of the universal in favor of a wokeness marked by relativism, the dictatorship of identities, and the questioning of rationality, which substitutes emotion and ideology for debate and science. She shows how this evolution leads to a democracy dominated by minorities, an excessive egalitarianism deconstructing all hierarchy, and a performative thought where truth is replaced by militant narratives imposed through intimidation. A review by Emmanuelle Hénin.

Table of contents

This article has no sections.

“The Insurrection of Particularities”: Chantal Delsol Faces the Decline of the Universal – a Review by Emmanuelle Hénin

Chantal Delsol, Insurrection of particularities , Le Cerf, 2025, 315 p.

Chantal Delsol's latest book is remarkable for its broad perspective, as it manages to make the major issues of postmodernity intelligible by placing them within the long term of history and a global geopolitical framework. The philosopher synthesizes her previous reflections on the decline of the universal and the pathologies of Western democracy, while focusing more specifically on the new power of minorities. Not without ambiguity, "the insurrection of particularities" refers both to the resistance of national identities to new imperialisms (China, Russia) and to the identity politics that fracture Western nations. We will use it only in this second, negative sense, which merges with wokeism. This movement thrives against a backdrop of a crisis of the universal and the decline of reason, substituting nihilism, narcissism, and sectarianism for science and civic conversation. Delsol lucidly highlights "this preference for relativism which paradoxically signifies intolerant thoughts" (p. 151).

Without claiming to account for all the analyses, nor to follow the plan of the work, we would like to highlight the major concepts likely to illuminate the woke phenomenon, as it currently rots intellectual life and institutions: renunciation of the universal, decolonialism, egalitarianism, inclusion, subjectivization of morality, dictatorship of identities, redefinition of democracy, systemic thinking, radical nominalism, decline of reason.

RENUNCIATION OF THE UNIVERSAL

The West has always aimed for "the universal common," an inseparably intellectual, political, and moral project, doubly rooted in nature: science seeks the truth of natural laws, while emancipation satisfies men's moral aspiration to freedom, constituting a "universal of promise." But this universalism is today being challenged: the conviction of the equal dignity of all cultures prevents us from valuing our values ​​better than others—thus, a section of the left defends the burqa because all cultures are equal. The root cause of this abandonment is the triumph of will over nature: the postmodern individual, who only legitimizes the products of his will, can only produce the particular. The universal is the unveiling of a truth that precedes me, while the particular refers only to the one who constructs it. Because the universal is the unveiling of a truth inscribed in nature, one cannot invent or fabricate a universal order through thought. From the moment we want to find nothing, but to create everything, we are doomed to remain in the particular. Therefore, let us not be surprised that other cultures do not recognize in our societal laws the products of a universal, because they are only the constructions of a particular culture. The desire for emancipation has given birth to a new world, claiming to deconstruct all anthropological markers: filiation, the distinction of the sexes, the border between man and animal, man and machine, and soon death. "The desire for emancipation has become a desire to emancipate oneself from the principle of reality and the general human condition." (p. 16) Each culture withdraws into itself and even human rights, which we thought were universal, are rejected in many countries, because they are based on one belief among others: the belief in the dignity of the human being. The West's choices are based on Judeo-Christian culture, and when that culture fades, those choices shift. Universalism ceases to be a truth and becomes just another narrative—a myth.

DECOLONIALISM

The abandonment of universalism leads to considering Western values ​​as cultural particularities, which it would be imperialist to try to impose on other peoples or on our fellow citizens of foreign origin. Thus, secularism, although at the foundation of the values ​​of our Republic, is increasingly considered a colonialist concept, to the point that the State must deploy "secularism referents" everywhere, as the idea is no longer self-evident. We are seeing the emergence of a "provincialism of thought" and an "active tribalism," with each group wanting to overtake the others. The individual merges with his tribal group, identity is collective, and responsibility is transferred to the group.

The decolonial movement combines two branches of nihilism: 1) Western nihilism, made up of self-hatred and guilt. European culture is characterized by its ability to recognize its past mistakes, so that our capacity for criticism—which was our strength in the past—allows us today to hate ourselves. 2) the nihilism of the formerly colonized, who want to destroy the West because it has made their culture unviable by comparison.

However, decolonialism is a form of narcissism: by fueling the idea that it alone is guilty (of colonialism, of slavery), the West finds a way to unduly aggrandize itself, and it is a strategy to remain the only actor in history. This attitude amounts to infantilizing other peoples, who are not responsible for their actions.

Conversely, the Chinese do not reap the narcissistic benefits of the colonization they endured; they prefer to retaliate, favoring belligerence over victimhood. Generally speaking, Asians do not join the chorus of historical victims. Chinese universalism, based on the concept of "Tianxia" ("all that exists under heaven"), consists of deploying soft power after the humiliation of colonization—it is notably expressed in the Belt and Road Initiative. Instead of colonizing, China establishes hierarchies of civilization with peoples deemed inferior. China and Russia do not claim to impose their civilization on us, but consider it far superior to our own. Conversely, they conquer countries they consider already theirs (Taiwan, Ukraine). With the same paternalism as China, Russia conquers out of love, not hatred, like a father reuniting his children. The West reserved the right to intervene wherever human rights were violated, becoming an empire without an emperor; similarly, China and Russia reserve the right to intervene militarily at will, by virtue of their superiority. Yet neither of these empires acknowledges its responsibility for the crimes of Stalin or Mao. Document No. 9 warns against "the promotion of historical nihilism" by anyone who challenges the official version of history. In Turkey, Omar Pamuk suffered the same fate when he was brought to trial for speaking out about the Armenian genocide (under Article 301 of the Penal Code).

Thus, the defeat of Western universalism reshuffles the cards of global geopolitics: it allows empires (China, Russia) and other nations to develop, claiming their identity and power (Turkey, India).

EGALITARIANISM

Universalism is all-encompassing, and therefore unequal, since it consists of valuing certain principles or values, considered legitimate. Once the universal is abandoned, all cultures are equal in their irreducible differences. Relativism involves leveling not only cultures, but all moral hierarchies and all values. The only good is the equality of beings and behaviors. Equality, the great moral principle of the West, has produced its excess, egalitarianism, which in turn has undone all its principles, starting with the universal and rationality: the laws of all countries are equal, pseudo-scientific principles are equal to scientific ones, and so on.

This egalitarianism is particularly evident in the dispute over canons that erupted in the United States in the 1980s. The canon is a criterion of excellence that gives rise to a hierarchy of forms and beings. But from the moment any hierarchy is perceived as violence and discrimination, the canon is denounced as a myth, fabricated by power-hungry men. In reality, the canon also reveals a need for role models, and its rejection reflects the certainty of finding one's own criteria for behavior within oneself.

As a corollary to the hierarchy of authors and works, meritocracy rests on a hierarchy of talent. Criticism of meritocracy, more vehement than ever, dates back to the mid-20th century, when Michael Young, in * The Rise of the Meritocracy * (1958), coined the term and denounced the system. Indeed, meritocracy reveals natural inequality and forces each individual to confront their true worth. Inequality of opportunity, stemming from the arbitrary nature of birth, at least had the virtue of fostering the myth of natural equality. By criticizing merit, one hopes to preserve this myth, if not to realize it. Michael Sandel, in *The Tyranny of Merit* (2021), in turn describes the pressure generated by a meritocratic society. Young questions why value is placed in IQ and not in kindness, sensitivity, or courage. Delsol answers: because these values, elevated to the status of criteria, engender societies of Savonarola's moral order.

The superiority of merit is particularly challenged by identity politics, which values ​​everyone equally regardless of their merits. The presupposition of equality of talent and ability extends the belief in the ontological dignity of all, prohibiting the existence of any aristocracy of merit. Society is composed of equally brilliant individuals, engaged in ruthless competition of geniuses (because if everyone is the best, there is no longer a best). To prioritize applications, merit is replaced by affirmative action, offering the best positions to representatives of each group (race, sex, etc.). But this equalization program penalizes truly deserving people—and affirmative action has been on the wane in the United States since the Supreme Court's June 2023 decision.

INCLUSION

Egalitarianism is a Christian virtue gone mad: the equal ontological dignity of all people becomes their actual equality. Like hierarchy and canon law, the very idea of ​​a norm is rejected: there are no longer any norms, everyone is normal. "Inclusion," which has become the cardinal virtue, consists of conferring all value on the individual while removing it from groups. Practicing inclusion in schools means denying the notion of a "good student" and therefore refusing the weakest the chance to catch up. Instead of asking everyone (according to their abilities) to adapt to the environment, the environment must adapt to everyone, which is the opposite of integration. With disability studies and fat studies , disability and obesity are no longer to be treated, since they are categories invented to arbitrarily discriminate against individuals.

The utopia of inclusion envisions a society of evangelical perfection, where the unfathomable dignity of each individual eclipses all their concrete characteristics, where "every human being is regarded with the loving gaze of God." A "society of archangels." As a corollary, like Marxism, so-called inclusive thought has an urgent need to vilify and condemn. Deeply intolerant, inclusion constantly excludes all its opponents.

A SUBJECTIVE MORALITY

The paradigm shift comes from Machiavelli and Hobbes, who founded modern political thought and viewed society as the struggle of all against all—or a war between equal particularities. In natural morality, good was connection and evil was separation; in modern morality, good is equality and evil is domination. This new morality found a pioneering application in the Chinese Cultural Revolution, the first systematic expression of the struggle of all against all: Mao's regime tortured and killed men accused of belonging to evil categories (intellectuals, property owners, reactionaries). Similarly, the wokes humiliate and socially kill people accused of being white or male. The individual is accused not for what he does but for what he is, as under Nazism and Communism. Here and there we find the same Manichaeism, the same designation of the guilty, the same social ostracism. Society is still conceived as the struggle of all against all, but now the struggle is not directed against injustices or oppressions, but against Injustice or Oppression, with the idea of ​​eradicating all evil from the world. Good consists of seeking equality in the struggle against dominations. The struggle is no longer a means to reach paradise, but is confused with existence itself since there is no longer any paradise. In a desperate quest for hidden dominations (that is, invented, fantasized), all social relations are translated into terms of power and the seizure of power. In this inversion of finalism, the world is no longer the sign of God's goodness, but of an evil will, according to an apocalyptic conspiracy. The world is bad, only the self is good.

With the collapse of churches and states, identity-based collectives have taken over and dictate morality. From now on, the individual decrees and defends morality, is both the architect and beneficiary of morality. The goal of this morality is not respect for others or the community, but happiness and respect for the individual. What is moral is that which prevents the individual from suffering, brings them happiness, and satisfies their desires. In the wake of Rousseau, morality is no longer objective and universal, based on the bond between humans, but individual and subjective, based on feelings and resentment. Ultimately, morality merges with individual desire, and the imperative is addressed to others: "Be moral toward me!" Or rather: "Recognize my suffering! Recognize me as a victim!" But what glory is there in being a victim? "Victimization is the recognition of the poor, who have no assets to show for themselves." » (p. 33). According to the mechanism of resentment identified by Nietzsche, the subject finds in this posture the justification of his powerlessness and the strength to hate those who harm him: "they are bad therefore I am good." The postmodern era of the victim establishes the recognition of all individuals, of all groups who, unable to gain recognition through positive actions, claim respect and admiration in the name of their defeat and their virtue. Morality replaces force.

THE DICTATORSHIP OF IDENTITIES

The recent invention of the adjective "societal ," which is, moreover, poorly formed (we don't say "proprietal" or " identital "), and which concerns society insofar as it touches on private life (the social referring to communal life), perfectly describes the takeover by particularities. From now on, we no longer liberate people from economic exploitation, but from customs, family, institutions, or taboos. Societal issues occupy the entire media and social landscape. The class struggle is replaced by the conflict of identities. In this generalized navel-gazing, identity groups cannot build any political will, but only defend what they are. These groups splinter into ever-smaller subgroups, because everything can be categorized as an identity: groups are created for undocumented immigrants, adopted children, and suicidal individuals. Politics is reduced to taking into account a litany of identities, whereas politics is first and foremost the art of living together. Individuals no longer gather as diverse people united by a common goal, but rather as similar individuals to assert their identity. Their being is their sole reason for existence, a fascination with their own essence. The purity of this collective identity makes each person a specimen; it is according to their type that each will be judged, victimized, and sometimes, admitted or not to university.

Under the Ancien Régime, punishments differed depending on whether the offense was committed by a nobleman or a peasant; this communal justice had its defenders, such as Jean Bodin (a great 16th-century jurist ) , against the proponents of universal justice. Today, identity-based groups demand privileges, and in doing so, place themselves above the law. But to claim that behavior is moral or immoral based on the identity of the person who commits it is tantamount to denying morality itself.

The triumph of particularities and the struggle of all against all give rise to forms of anarchy, to the extent that the accumulation of subjective rights decivilizes and breaks the common. Since powers are weak, active minorities rush in and noisily occupy the place, in school curricula, associations, assemblies. Minorities take power and consider themselves the only ones justified in doing so, only minorities are justified in governing: "A legitimate state will not be the representative of the people, but the representative of minorities." Minorities demand a form of legitimate anarchy, but no order can emerge from their demands; they crack the social cement, while waiting to tear down the walls themselves.

REDEFINING DEMOCRACY

The obsession with domination is such that there must no longer be a majority, because the majority is perceived as domination. But the dictatorship of minorities is a denial of democracy, a reversal of the criteria of representation. Democracy is no longer defined as the sovereignty of the people, but as the reign of particularities. In 2021, Hungary passed a law banning the promotion of homosexuality among minors; in 2022, the European Parliament considered that Hungary was no longer a democracy, but "a hybrid regime of electoral authoritarianism." Yet, all decisions are made with the approval of a sovereign people. Democracy is now conceived as "the recognition and legitimization of all particularities." The term "electoral autocracy" implies that it is no longer elections that make democracy, but obedience to the dictates of particularities, even if they represent a tiny percentage of the population. In the XNUMXth century, a democracy was recognized by the fact that it did not impose a doxa; today, by the fact that it obeys a doxa. It was a debate around the contours of the common good; today, we are automatically excluded from it when we dare to submit militant particularities to the debate.

SYSTEMS THINKING

For Christian anthropology, the evil in the world is attributable to individuals, endowed with free will. Christian societies did not oppose institutions, but called for the reform of individuals. Conversely, modern thought begins to locate evil within institutions. Rousseau sees the origin of evil in private property: the guilty party is not the first to eat the fruit, but the first to say, "This is mine" ( Discourse on the Origin and Foundations of Inequality Among Men , 1755). "Rousseau creates the institutional devil": for the first time, evil is found within the system. Current systemic thinking reflects a weariness with individual responsibility, because it is infinitely simpler to see evil outside oneself. Systemic thinking deprives the individual of their own conscience and responsibility.

Systems thinking reflects the desperate search for purity, based on the hope of finally identifying evil and ridding the world of it. For the woke, racism would be eliminated if there were no more white people—for the Nazis, if there were no more Jews; nor bourgeoisie for the Soviets. Hannah Arendt was met with an outcry when she theorized the "banality of evil," meaning only that Nazism does not absorb all the world's evil and exonerate other humans. She had the unforgivable audacity to assert that there have been other genocides in history. Although Nazism represented a paroxysmal form of it, evil is everywhere, and it is naive to think that it will be eliminated by abolishing certain institutions.

Manichaeism is always easier: good and evil are clearly divided. From this point of view, wokeism is a form of Catharism: "after the Cathars, the communists and the woke have their chosen and their damned" (p. 39).

RADICAL NOMINALISM

Wokeism has an advantage over Marxism: the class struggle demanded a concrete result, but the results of Wokeism depend only on a performative will; "they are verbal enchantments imposed by intimidation and violence" (p. 43). The woke have their own world, which evolves according to their desire. Reality becomes performative, created by language.

The postmodern individual is a self-centered entrepreneur. This narcissistic individualism is infantile: as we become adults, we decenter ourselves, take into account our finiteness, and know we are dependent on a community. The individual has abandoned reality and wants everything to be possible. He has sunk into "radical nominalism" (JF Braunstein), where each word designates only itself, stifling reality. William of Occam's nominalism consisted of saying that concepts or universals have no real existence, because only individuals exist. Today, this nominalism ousts any idea of ​​the universal: each individual is their own species. Categories are jeopardized; we are accused of amalgamation as soon as we assign a quality to a given group, or even of conceptualizing: every concept is suspected of being an instrument of domination. Hence the ideal of universal fluidity where boundaries are abolished—especially between the sexes.

According to Arendt, Westerners deprived of transcendence did not fall back into the common world, but into themselves. The abandonment of transcendence took place in several stages: in the 19th centurye century, religions were replaced by social utopias, secular religions; after 1945, disappointed by these secular religions, the Westerner turned to the self, which became the locus of all demands. The hope for a perfect society became that of an identity perfectly in line with my desires. Like children, the postmodern individual seeks to forget the difficulty of accepting reality, to pretend to free himself from all determination – indeed, all determination is negation, because definition excludes that which is not it. On the contrary, freedom, according to postmodernists, is the possibility for life to express only itself.

DECLINE OF REASON

The chapter devoted to reason is particularly interesting: the challenge lies in understanding how the abandonment of universality and democratic values ​​leads to the decline of rationality. The Greeks were the first to formulate the idea of ​​a universal reason, to which even God is subject. For Islam, on the contrary, an arbitrary God establishes the laws of the world, and humankind must obey. In the West, the questioning of universal truth begins with questioning the compatibility between reason and God. In the 20th century , the rejection of reason arose in reaction to the unlimited powers conferred upon it by the Enlightenment.

The modern process of "de-Hellenization" begins with Leon Chestov (1866-1938), who challenged Greek rationality, going so far as to write: "Two plus two equals four, that's death"—a foreshadowing of the famous "Two plus two equals four reeks of the white patriarchy." Distrust of reason emerged in Russia, as the Russian genius preferred the exception to the system and prayer or magic to demonstration. Reason is useless because it prevents us from adopting the only truly interesting perspective on the world: a spiritual one. Influenced by Kierkegaard's existentialism, Chestov asserts that, from an existential point of view, the Earth is indeed at the center of the world. Chantal Delsol highlights the influence of this "thought from the outside" on the authors of the last century, from Cioran to Ionesco, from Camus to Blanchot, and from Foucault to Deleuze. The latter draws on Chestov's * Difference and Repetition* (1968), a hymn to particularity and specificity. For Deconstructionist thought, "knowledge is domination, understanding a lure for the purpose of enslavement." "Truth as a stable and universal essence is replaced by truth as a singular and fluid event."

The idea of ​​truth has a history. It appeared around the 6th century BC, concurrently in the Old Testament and in Greece: Parmenides and Abraham are the fathers of this idea. The God of Abraham truly exists, no longer presented as a myth among others, but as a reality. Westerners, the sons of Parmenides and Abraham, founded a universal and exclusive belief, valid for all – while the myth is valid only for a particular society.

The rise of ideologies and totalitarian regimes is part of this regime of truth, which was supposed to be a safeguard against autocracies. Yet, truth has become tyrannical: religious truth, then ideological truth, and now technocratic truth. The very notion of truth has been lost through its own excesses. The ideologies of the 20th century did great damage to the regime of truth, partly explaining its decline in the 21st century . Nazism and Stalinism define themselves by the certainty of "truth," employing a performative discourse of truth: I do not describe what happens, but what I say happens—mutatis mutandis, a performativity claimed by gender studies. Until the moment when reality catches up with the truth-makers. "Dogmatization ultimately caused the downfall of the regime of truth, shattered by its own caricatures." "Truth is sought, not held" (p. 147). Furthermore, the error lay in finding these self-evident truths elsewhere than in science: religious faith and then ideology became identified with mathematical certainty. The obsession with religious and then ideological dogmatization leaves behind nothingness. Postmodernism rejects reason and practices "misology" (Plato, Phaedo ). Yet science, born in the West because it is the offspring of the idea of ​​truth, is also the most direct expression of the truth regime, for what it grasps is the most manifest.

The criteria of science are non-obedience to the dictates of power, submission to reality, the pursuit of unanimity, and the privileging of experience. Throughout history, religious and political authorities have sought to obstruct science. Galileo had to feign ignorance to save his life; the Church invoked the "equivalence of hypotheses" (between science and theology) to avoid bowing to science. Then came Lysenko: the Party invoked relativism, the equivalence between bourgeois and proletarian science. Yet science tolerates no adjectives— mutatis mutandis : there is no more decolonial or indigenous science than there is bourgeois science. Freed from religion and ideology, postmodern societies do not, however, honor unbiased science. As Marcel Kuntz demonstrates, the scientific process is being hijacked by activist groups, such as those who vandalize GMO research to prevent it from succeeding. A journal, AFIS [ French Association for Scientific Information ], was even created to document these activist lies.

Delsol draws compelling parallels between the pre-scientific era before Kepler and Galileo and the post-scientific age of social science studies . In the pre-scientific mindset, the good and the useful take precedence over the true (Bachelard). This mindset values, whereas science disregards value, seeking truth rather than utility. The entire scientific approach rests on the belief in truth, which must be discovered—according to the etymology of the word aletheia . The scholar is humble, existing only to uncover what is beyond their power. Conversely, activist science constructs its object and places it at the service of good. As in the Middle Ages, astrology and astronomy are no longer distinguished—and, one might add, magic and spiritualism become academic disciplines.

Truth has a fatal flaw in the eyes of contemporaries: it is not inclusive. It is even exclusive since it rejects the untrue. It produces distinctions: man/woman or human/animal, fact/construction, reality/fiction, opinion/knowledge. However, the postmodern spirit detests divisions, abolishes dualisms and rejects hierarchies. "The quest for truth is aristocratic by definition, since it demands explicit qualities and since its results are divisive." (p. 169) It is a question of destroying any overhang: truth is fascist, becomes a heteronomous affirmation. As Marcuse stated in 1968, science and philosophy depend on the slave society in which they appeared – ancient Greece.

Both totalitarian regimes imposed themselves supposedly in the name of science; yet for postmodernists, it is science itself that is totalitarian. As in 1968, the question "Who is speaking?" is posed in response to scientific discourse. As soon as this question is raised, universality is lost. Science is "contextualized," its pronouncements stemming from a specific context: yesterday it was Jewish, proletarian science… and today it is male, white, Western, or decolonial, inclusive science. Objectivity does not exist; what exists are diverse discourses, emanating from diverse groups with diverse histories and values. There are no longer any universal truths, only cultural truths, therefore partial and plural. In Quebec, Indigenous knowledge demands to be placed on the same level as other forms of knowledge. However, "if science is judged according to criteria other than competence, it literally ceases to exist." “Multiplying the sources of ‘truth’ for reasons of tolerance is a moral measure that destroys science” (p. 174). Certainly, the triumphant rationality of the Enlightenment tended to eliminate any form of knowledge based on intuition, fueling the opposite excess, and it is not illegitimate to ask what place to give to extra-rational knowledge. But science studies place all forms of knowledge on the same level and call for “decolonizing science” to rehabilitate the losers of history, to devalue the Western discourse of science to make room for other discourses, such as traditional medicines. Scientific objectivity is denounced as an ideology aimed at power. It is a matter of compensating for historical inferiority through a denial of truth, in the greatest confusion of orders, where Good replaces Truth.

The exponential growth of the principle of equality has produced staggering effects: everyone is an expert, knowledge is no longer the preserve of scholars who possess experience and learning, but is everywhere, which produces a fragmentation of science. Social networks and the internet accentuate the phenomenon of the all-knowing individual. Paradoxically, only those who know are aware of their own ignorance! By a dangerous conceptual shift, we infer from the democratic equality of opinions the equality of all discourses in matters of science.

In the transition from modernity to postmodernity, we have moved from absolute trust in science to distrust, both equally extreme positions: science does not answer the question "why," nor does it say whether God exists. The entire philosophy of Deconstruction reflects a disillusionment with science, from Writing Degree Zero to The Order of Things . Meaning shatters, the link between words and things is broken. Lévi-Strauss's assertion that science and magic are two forms of knowledge contributes to relativizing and devaluing science.

We are experiencing the end of the theological presupposition, the end of a two-millennium cycle in which the world was created and ordered by a rational God and then by Reason. Indeed, faith in the possibility of science derives from medieval theology. For Whitehead, at the origin of science are two presuppositions: belief in the rationality of the world, which excludes chaos, and faith in a Creator. “We thought the world was intelligible because we thought it was created.” (p. 186). Science, as a specific mode of thought, receives a refutation once the theological presupposition is extinguished. The universal was constituted by religious dogmas, then by Nature. The ontological unity of the world began to disintegrate with modernity; and today, our “ontological agnosticism” assumes that reality is constituted by our beliefs.

From then on, the scientific spirit was no longer considered a stage in the march of universal progress, but a moment correlated with specific cultural demands. As Thomas Kuhn shows, the entire mass of scientific knowledge was produced by Europe over the last four centuries, thanks to one fundamental condition: the certainty that truth has value.

The scientific mindset used to be about loving the reality of this world. But reality is no longer loved; it must now be defended with as much force as religious beliefs once were. “Particular fictions have taken the place of science, imposing themselves not through universal reason but through intimidation and threats.” (p. 186) Amor mundi (Arendt) has been replaced by self-loathing, the driving force behind decolonial and transhumanist theories, and by the “heuristic of fear” in ecological matters: provided one fears for nature and not for culture, fear is no longer a sorrowful passion but a glorious one. We are witnessing a disaffection for the mind, where hatred of the cultural world goes hand in hand with the adoration of nature. The fear of climate catastrophe has become a religion, with its priests and dogmas.

Chantal Delsol eloquently evokes the three glaciations that Jacques Julliard spoke of: Stalinist, Maoist, and Wokeist. She concludes with a beautiful phrase: "At the height of these periods, our universities become madrasas, that is, theological schools, the exact opposite of what we call universities" (p. 193). The die is cast!

Share this article

Facebook X LinkedIn

Right of reply and contributions
Would you like to respond? Submit an opinion piece proposal →

You might also like:

Science, the Besieged Citadel

"Science, the Besieged Citadel" by Jacques Robert denounces the abuses affecting science and reason: the pervasive influence of ideology on critical analysis, numerous unpunished frauds, and the impostures of pseudoscience, with potentially serious consequences for society as a whole and the credibility of scientists. A review by Claudio Rubiliani.

Defending video games is a philosophical imperative in the face of a perverse state.

A state that presents itself as a protector while treating parents as incapable minors, and children as subjects to be removed from reality, builds a society where no one is accountable for transmission.
What you have left to read
0 %

Maybe you should subscribe?

Otherwise, it's okay! You can close this window and continue reading.

    Register: