Observatoire academic ethics
Menu

Hide this word that I cannot see!

Illustration for the article "Hide that word from me!"

Hide this word that I cannot see!

Jacques-Robert

Professor Emeritus of Cancerology, University of Bordeaux
Tribalism? How awful! The editor, Samir Shah, made amends in April 2021 for allowing this article to be published, which he retracted and republished under a different title! And the new article replaced tribalism with silo

Table of contents

This article has no sections.

Illustration for the article "Hide that word from me!"

Hide this word that I cannot see!

[Text originally published in Innovations et Thérapeutiques en Oncologie 2023; 9: 7-12. doi: 10.1684/ito.2023.0356]

The sin of sins—the most unforgivable sin of all: anachronism [1] Febvre L. The Problem of Unbelief in the 16th Century . Rabelais' Religion . Albin Michel, 1968, p. 15 Lucien Febvre

Using appropriate vocabulary is essential for being understood. One must know how to find the right word, the correct expression, the best formula. But sometimes we witness a distortion of these basic principles of communication. There are words forbidden because they are offensive – or more precisely, because they are now considered to have been offensive in the past . But words only become insults when they are used with offensive intent ! Other words are forbidden because they are too explicit and must be euphemized. Most languages ​​have thus eliminated from their vocabulary words designating certain parts of the human body or its ejaculate, for reasons of propriety: the word " breast" was thus considered inappropriate in the 17th century . [2] According to Vaugelas ( Remarks on the French Language , 1647), who condemns this euphemism, it is because one can speak of " veal breast" ; I won't elaborate on others, which have remained so: everyone knows them! I don't frequent school playgrounds, but as far as forbidden words are concerned, I think today's children could give us points, as evidenced by this lovely drawing by Yves Calarnou in La Croix …

Some words, however, were used precisely with offensive intent, particularly towards certain groups of people, in a period close to our own: it is necessary to maintain their elimination, if not from dictionaries, then at least from common usage. Some words have even returned after having been replaced in this way: in the first half of the 20th century, the practice arose of no longer speaking of Jews , but of Israelites ; it was the Jews themselves who rehabilitated this word to designate them. There is, of course, no question of rehabilitating the word N-word , which carries too much contempt for the peoples of sub-Saharan Africa to be admitted into language today. Biology has taught us that there are no human races , and anthropology that there are no primitive peoples : but in this case, it is no longer the words that must be condemned and banished, but the ideas they convey.

There are far more innocuous words that some would like to ban for reasons they believe to be similar, and in which they find a derogatory, even offensive, meaning. Take the word racism . Le Monde once replaced it with racialism [3] Robert J. The alternative current in medicine. Innov Ther Oncol 2021; 7: 171-4. , a neologism that does not exist in our language. This was to avoid accusing anthroposophy of racism—what a terrible thing for such a noble movement of thought! By softening the term, the newspaper's editors believed they were restoring a certain dignity to its followers. A wasted effort for those who know what anthroposophy is. Along the same lines, a leader of what was then called the National Front replaced the word nationalists in her speeches to refer to her supporters with the less loaded word nationals . Some words have been banned by a famous board game, such as the word "Jesuitical ," considered offensive to the Jesuits (who are, however, used to being denigrated!). And to stay within the realm of board games, what about Belote, where the King trumps the Queen, as a journalist from Le Point points out here ? Fortunately, the Jack of trumps prevails over them, which is reassuring in terms of class struggle.

Another word has just been banished from scientific (sociological, to be precise) language: the word 'tribalism'. A very interesting article in the Journal of Hospital Medicine [4] Kanjee Z, Bilello L. Tribalism: The good, the bad, and the future. J Hosp Med 2021; 16: 227. Retracted and republished in: J Hosp Med 2021; 16: 357. had used it to describe the herd mentality of medical institutions walled off within their own community. Tribalism? How awful! The editor-in-chief, Samir Shah, made amends in April 2021 for allowing the publication of this article, which he retracted and republished under a different title! And the new article replaced tribalism with silo … Go figure… Wheat producers will appreciate this, because the primary meaning of silo, in both English and French, is precisely what is used to store grain.

Tribalism! Can you believe it! A swear word like few others… Compared to that, shit, f***, whore, dirty c*** are still considered good manners! Tribalism… The absolute horror! And it wasn't even about the shitty people, the N…, it was about the mentality of doctors who behave like sheep and close ranks when attacked, as if they belonged to some… I don't dare finish my words: my readers, I'm sure, will guess (they're wicked enough for that!). And Samir Shah even tweeted: “ We erred in publishing an article that used 'tribalism' to refer to silos [5] 'silo' here meaning 'compartmentalization' in medicine. We thank readers for educating us .” Educate, educate, they said… What a bunch of hypocrites! In French, this translates, in Claire Bretécher's language: "Kick my ass, please!" [6] Bretécher C. Les frustrateds , vol. 2, p. 66. Published by the author, 1972. All rights reserved.

Let us try to unpack the meaning of tribe and tribalism. Tribes represent a particular organization of society within a nation-like community. Everyone has heard of the twelve tribes of Israel; Cleisthenes' democratic reform in 508 BC redistributed the Athenian population into ten tribes; that of ancient Rome was divided into three tribes, the Luceres , the Ramnes , and the Titienses ; and many ancient peoples were thus subdivided. The word is in no way pejorative and simply serves to designate the components of a population. This is how many human groups have referred to themselves to this day in most of North Africa, the Sahara, and the Middle East. [7] Julien CA, "What is a North African Tribe?" in: Homage to Lucien Febvre , Armand Colin, 1953 [7] . And since the feeling of chauvinism is universal, everyone considered their tribe to be the best (or the oldest, or the most honorable). The word is used by zoologists who have inserted a 'tribe' subdivision between 'family' and 'genus'. Anthropologists have taken up the term to talk about the subdivisions of certain populations they were studying. Certainly, for decades, anthropology had an evolutionary view of cultures, thinking that some cultures were more 'primitive' than others, considered more 'advanced': a concept forged by Lewis Morgan [8] Deliège R. Une histoire de l'anthropologie. Écoles, auteurs, théories . Éditions du Seuil, 2006, pp. 23-50. and popularized by Friedrich Engels, from whom anthropology got rid more than 80 years ago under the influence, in particular, of Claude Lévi-Strauss; We now know that no culture is 'primitive' compared to another…

As for the word tribalism , which is the subject here, it is simply a derivative of the word tribe , designating that latent chauvinism that stems from belonging to a group, whether that group is based on age, geography, politics, religion, not to mention a love of opera or Vire sausage [9] . Yes, there is a brotherhood called the Friendly Association of Lovers of Authentic Andouillette … This feeling is universal; one can deplore it or accept it. One can see manifestations of tribal behavior by attending a meeting of a political party or a pétanque club, a football match, the Bayreuth Festival, or the annual outing of the Elders of the canton of Gleux-les-Lure. And I almost forgot the Jets tribe and the Sharks tribe , recently brought back into fashion by Steven Spielberg… So, why ostracize the word tribalism? I would like to show here that our self-appointed experts are mistaken and that they are the ones reverting to the abandoned evolutionary conception of anthropology. If they eliminate the word "tribalism ," it is because they give it a pejorative meaning: they therefore assume that cultures where society is organized into tribes are inferior to those where it is not… Which is unacceptable, I completely agree. The racism is in their minds, not in the word!

If we start removing words that are inconvenient, we'll have to rewrite a lot of things! For those fossils who still read poetry, I refer you to these two lines from "Le Bateau ivre" (The Drunken Boat) evoking the cruel fate of the haulers:

Screaming Red Indians had targeted them
Having nailed them naked to the colored posts.

Redskins is inappropriate; likewise, American Indians, for that matter… one must speak of Native Americans or, if one wishes to speak in French, of Americans by birth , as I once read in the writings of an incompetent translator [10] And then the derogatory idea that they were loud and that they assaulted and tortured the haulers must be eliminated: if they did so, it was surely due to social constraints imposed by the colonizers. Finally, fortunately, Rimbaud spoke of colored posts, and not of the doldrums [11] , which is to his credit.

And now we're seeing scientific articles republished, retrospectively removing the words that cause offense. It's astounding to see scientists lending themselves to this charade. What a strange initiative it is for the editor-in-chief of the British Medical Journal ( see here ) to revisit old articles, to soften them, to attach a defamatory label to them, and even to consider deleting them, because they convey words or ideas deemed offensive today, even though they were accepted when the articles were published. We cannot judge the cultural choices of the past by the standards of the cultural choices of the present: we must accept them; we must not fall into the trap of anachronism by committing a historical misinterpretation, as I mentioned in the quote from Lucien Febvre that serves as my epigraph. History cannot be rewritten. Man can change the future [12] , but he cannot change the past. We cannot make this past not have happened.

If we can remove the words that bother us and which, I repeat, were not necessarily considered derogatory at the time they were used, we can also remove books: the idea is not new, and the Nazis put it into practice. Fahrenheit 451: this is the temperature at which paper spontaneously ignites, according to Ray Bradbury; 1984, this is the date on which George Orwell's novel takes place: do you think that this date is behind us? Oh, no! It is a date that is always before us, and towards which we are marching happily as if towards an asymptote... After words and books, we must also remove people. Does that remind you of anything? For me, it makes me think furiously of the iconographic removal of politicians who have ceased to please; the Soviets were past masters in this rewriting of history:

Let's erase words, let's erase books, let's erase people… Those who try to rewrite history are dictators: they replace a word that might stir up unhealthy thoughts, they burn a book deemed subversive, they remove a disgraced minister from a photograph, they erase a genocide by claiming it never happened. Of course, we can regret the past, we can plead guilty to collective crimes committed by our ancestors: domination and intolerance towards women and minorities, colonization, slavery—the list goes on. But we cannot erase them: hiding them is pointless. Retouching the photo above was pointless: the original version is still available. This is what the editors of the British Medical Journal seem to regret when they write: “ Even when publications decide to correct or remove content, the original version will remain in print editions and in other locations online through third parties such as indexers and libraries.” "Erase, gentlemen, erase, something will always remain! Yes, but... for how long? As long as there is paper?"

Share this article

Facebook X LinkedIn

Author

Right of reply and contributions
Would you like to respond? Submit an opinion piece proposal →

You might also like:

Science, the Besieged Citadel

"Science, the Besieged Citadel" by Jacques Robert denounces the abuses affecting science and reason: the pervasive influence of ideology on critical analysis, numerous unpunished frauds, and the impostures of pseudoscience, with potentially serious consequences for society as a whole and the credibility of scientists. A review by Claudio Rubiliani.

Things seen in Bordeaux…

Our friend Vincent Tournier spent a few days in Bordeaux… He shares some anecdotes with us. It is generally in the details of daily life that the ideological obsessions of a society are revealed.
What you have left to read
0 %

Maybe you should subscribe?

Otherwise, it's okay! You can close this window and continue reading.

    Register: