Observatoire academic ethics
Menu

Was Researching and Teaching Better Before?

Illustration for the article "Research and Teaching: Was it better before?"

Was Researching and Teaching Better Before?

Pierre Rochette

Pierre Rochette is a geologist
Pierre Rochette takes a harsh look back at his 44-year career, denouncing the rise of a cumbersome and absurd bureaucracy that seriously hinders scientific research, academic freedom and the functioning of higher education in France.

Table of contents

Illustration for the article "Research and Teaching: Was it better before?"

Was Researching and Teaching Better Before?

Point of view of a teacher, researcher, naturalist and physicist

 

Introduction

This text is a reflection on my experiences and feelings after 44 years of research, first as a doctoral student, then as a researcher at the CNRS, and finally as a university professor, now emeritus. Having returned to the CNRS in 2023 the medal I received in 2006 [1] , and having actively participated in a petition denouncing bureaucratic obstacles to research [2] “ CNRS: new mission management system, we can't take it anymore! ” , I will not delay answering the question posed in the title any longer: yes, things were better before, and to a degree I could never have imagined.

I would like to point out that my field of research is somewhere between experimental physics, learned in the laboratory of Nobel Prize winner Louis Néel in Grenoble, and Natural Sciences, learned at the Universities of Paris and Grenoble. This field involves a lot of fieldwork, based on observation and sampling, often solitary or in pairs, in all corners of the Earth (or even the solar system), and experimental laboratory work with the dependence that this implies on investment in equipment and technical personnel.

What has changed between 1981 and 2025? I will structure my argument in three parts: bureaucracy, the research ecosystem, and the higher education ecosystem. To round things off, I will conclude with a brief reflection on iconic 19th- century naturalists.

 

An activity vampirized by an all-powerful bureaucracy

The public academic sector, involving hundreds of thousands of employees and millions of students across the country, obviously requires a complex organization that operates primarily with financial support from the State and local authorities, and with high expectations from citizens and decision-makers. Forty years ago, this management was entrusted to peers, chosen for their experience, their authority, and their ability to devote themselves to the collective. These managers were assisted by one or more management and secretarial staff to ensure the flow of mail and forms necessary for financial commitments, missions, recruitment, etc. They provided the interface with managers above them, generally still peers, and in the event of obstacles, they could intervene at the next level, even going all the way to the ministry, to argue directly. All of this already constituted a "bureaucracy" in the sense that its actors with a shred of power were more often in their offices than in the field, but we could discuss and these officials were our peers, sharing the same goal of creating and transmitting knowledge.

 

Research in the era of management

The current bureaucracy has just been brilliantly analyzed in a post full of illuminating concepts and references [3] What is bureaucracy? ” Online at RogueESR. Two particularly insightful quotes: “ there is no problem it creates for which it does not claim to be the solution.” “While the toxicity of bureaucratic layers is common knowledge, criticism of the bureaucratic phenomenon is made difficult by the fact that its victims (administrators, academics, and researchers) are also cogs in the machine.” I highly recommend reading it. What characterizes our current bureaucracy, besides its managerial jargon straight out of business schools, is that its key players often have no professional experience in scientific research and higher education (graduates of Sciences Po, HEC, ENA, or with a Master's degree in Public Administration Law, recruited directly into the civil service after graduation) or have lost all contact with these fields for decades. In 2007, the chief of staff to the Minister of Higher Education and Research was a university professor, a brilliant researcher from the École Normale Supérieure (ENS), who continued to publish scientific articles as first author. In 2024, it was an HEC graduate from Polytechnique, seemingly without any personal experience in higher education and research, but clearly an expert in the workings of the state. The contrast is not necessarily insignificant.

Our interface with the administration is no longer a human being with whom we can discuss (even) the weather, but a multitude of software programs (appearing and changing at a frenetic pace, making it illusory that we will ever learn how to use them) produced by private or public services that have no idea how our work is carried out. These programs are promoted to "save time" [4] CNRS Hebdo, September 28. A typical quote illustrating the relevance of research governance: "The CNRS has already done a great deal to simplify administrative tasks in laboratories: [...] mission management, [...]. The sole objective is to make things easier for laboratories and free up time for research." !!! "(and especially to compensate for the shortage of administrative positions) are so dysfunctional that they cost us increasing amounts of time and energy, and what's more, instead of relieving managers, they themselves have to constantly struggle to debug these bureaucratic nightmares. Today, our middle managers are much quicker to pass down directives and sanctions from higher levels than to defend our interests at the top, for fear of causing offense."

 

A bureaucracy disconnected from the field

For a concrete example, I fought for a year and a half to be reimbursed for expenses of several thousand euros during a mission in Africa where I had to pay a large sum in cash to a military escort (demanded by my security defense officer and the French embassy), fuel from illiterate street dealers, and compensation to a village chief for letting me pitch our tents in his compound and who had to sacrifice a goat from his herd to restore us. Faced with people whose only mission experience is traveling with their attaché cases to the major cities of France for meetings and juries, which is why the famous Goelett and Notilus software were designed, how can we understand each other? Christopher Columbus also suffered martyrdom at the Spanish Court, first to obtain the three caravels that allowed him to discover America, then on his return to justify the fact that he had not brought back a quantity of gold equal in weight to that of the glassware loaded on the outward journey. But his mission was titanic and fabulous compared to mine, and we would be right to believe that the reign of reason should have progressed since 1492. Columbus at least did not have to provide the RCS and VAT number of the village chiefs he met.

In our dealings with the administration we no longer talk about the realities of research and teaching, but about the market code, the rules of public accounting, auditing, the Court of Auditors, and quite quickly, if we dispute, the wrath of the Accounting Agent, the only master after Jupiter.

Where does the decision come from to give all power to these high priests, impervious to reason and who consider us slaves to their cult of regulatory purity pushed to the point of absurdity? The CEO of the CNRS wrote to me recently to assure me that he was totally powerless against them. Forty years ago, we were perhaps still in the time of the "mandarins," rightly criticized for the feudalism it underpinned, but in any case, they had the power to impose it on the administration.

 

The end of common sense

To be recruited after passing the CNRS researcher competition in 1985, I had to provide administrative proof of my resignation from my position as a trainee civil servant at the École Normale Supérieure (ENS). But according to ENS regulations, I could only be "released" if I provided proof of employment in the public service, in the form of a proper document, a document that I could not obtain from the CNRS without prior discharge from the ENS. A typical administrative impasse, linked to a contradiction between the independent procedures of two organizations, as is commonly encountered. Once the impasse was noted, common sense prevailed in a few telephone conversations: the ENS personnel department was kind enough to provide me with the necessary discharge at the cost of a (real but temporary) breach of their regulations.

One of my former non-EU doctoral students was recruited as a researcher at a prestigious national research institution in 2023. Just a month before his scheduled start date of January 1st , the human resources department realized he couldn't be hired for several months due to the accreditation process required to work in a "sensitive" laboratory. When he complained to the administration, explaining that he had already resigned from his previous position abroad, given up his apartment, and moved to France, the only solution offered was, "You can just register for unemployment." This is how the best foreign researchers are welcomed in our country.

Some will surely criticize this scathing indictment, saying, "You're exaggerating; most of the time (sometimes, I'd say) administrative procedures go smoothly." But the problem is precisely the stress generated by the inability to trust the administration 1) to handle a process without having to periodically check that it hasn't stalled, 2) to spontaneously offer a way to smooth things over, instead of the fatalistic conclusion, "I don't think it's going to be possible" and "we'll do it differently next time." Like in the song [5] Je crois que ça va pas être possible" (I don't think it's going to be possible ), we live in a state of constant insecurity and a feeling of being powerless in the face of the ordeal that each procedure represents.

 

A degraded research ecosystem

           

The foundation of a researcher's work lies in having the time and mental freedom to venture with enthusiasm into the unknown frontiers of knowledge. The researcher's "available brain time" shrinks dramatically once administrative tasks are completed, responses to the countless calls for proposals necessary to secure funding (a large portion of which will be consumed by administrative costs) are written, and the resulting stress is dealt with. Success in these calls for proposals is often contingent on a highly prescriptive approach to research topics, with a focus on applications, social demand, or market demand. For the evaluators, this often involves an emphasis on project feasibility and risk mitigation. All of this fosters a research environment that hums along and can assure decision-makers that five years before the project's completion (as is the case with the French National Research Agency - ANR), the detailed results of the research described in the project and the pompous "Data Management Plan" are already known. Personally, I don't call that research, just the production of pre-existing data. Those of us who don't give up on pursuing innovative avenues not recognized by this system finance them by diverting funds obtained from "comfortable" projects (to use Antoine Petit's term [6] What is bureaucracy? " Online at RogueESR. ). Christopher Columbus wouldn't have been funded by the French National Research Agency (ANR) if he had announced his intention to discover America, and therefore would have had to oversell a "new route" to India. Similarly, the academic publishing system makes it infinitely easier to publish articles confirming and paraphrasing the existing consensus, rather than making a groundbreaking discovery that could spark a new paradigm. With incentives to maintain a constant output of publications, to transform trials immediately, to dilute results, it is no wonder that among the millions of research articles published each year worldwide, the vast majority will receive no citations other than those of the group of researchers who authored the publication.

Field and experimental sciences are particularly hampered in the French academic system by the significant administrative obstacles placed in the way of acquiring or maintaining measuring instruments, hiring collaborators, and carrying out complex field missions abroad. In the context of international competition, French researchers are at a disadvantage, while their international counterparts operate with ease, as they can access funding without any prior oversight and with simple, effective tools.

 

A devastated higher education ecosystem

Almost 80% of a given age group has a high school diploma today. This was less than 30% forty years ago [7] . Only 32% of these high school graduates will reach the Bachelor's level, sometimes after five years of study (compared to 12% forty years ago). Since the human brain has not significantly evolved since the appearance of Homo sapiens 300,000 years ago, and even less so in the last forty years, it was predictable that the average level of the student population would drop sharply, also considering the decline in the quality of primary and secondary education, and the fact that many of the best high school graduates are leaving university. The university, which used to be the pinnacle of the education system, has become a vast dumping ground for those who haven't had the opportunity to enter the workforce, or to enter selective programs that guarantee them a job upon graduation. Teachers must turn a blind eye to the fact that the majority of those half-heartedly listening have absolutely neither the ability nor even the desire to assimilate the theoretically prescribed curriculum. The university, incapable of leading the majority of students to a decent degree, prefers, under the guise of innovative teaching methods, to create pathways in every direction or talk about "social responsibility," and above all, to orchestrate a "decreased" exit (a watered-down degree) for those who should never have entered university in the first place. The collective pressure to avoid giving grades below average is becoming increasingly intense. Students understand this perfectly well and can easily claim a "10 with room for improvement." Their lack of motivation is therefore understandable. Of course, there is always a significant proportion of students in each year group who deserve to be there, but their potential remains untapped given the general gloom. If this wastefulness stopped at the Bachelor's level (in a "secondary education" that has been predicted for a long time), but that's not the case: unwilling to take responsibility for selection, the path leading to a Master's degree is also wide open: France is by far the leading OECD country in terms of Master's degree holders in the 25-34 age group: 24% (compared to 15% in Germany, 17% in the United Kingdom, and an OECD average of 16% [8] ). Is this reasonable, when a necessarily significant proportion of these young people will ultimately find employment that is theoretically accessible with a vocational certificate (CAP), a two-year technical degree (DUT), or a two-year vocational diploma (BTS)?

When, after years of thesis and post-doctoral work, followed by a highly selective competitive exam, a young teacher finds himself facing this audience, how can he not be disillusioned? The teacher is there in theory to "train in research and for research" an audience that is most often not there for that but to console itself for not having found a place in BTS, IUT or preparatory classes. We are asked to provide professional training, when we know very little about the targeted professions. Can we call this a schizophrenia of the system? In any case, it inevitably impacts the morale and motivation of teachers. By constantly creating new diplomas, courses, etc., to absorb cohorts of high school graduates and students, even teachers are struggling to explain to students the logic of the courses they are offered.

These teachers are exhausted by the complexity of specific tools (timetable software, individual service management, grade reporting, online course interfaces, etc.) and by the incessant reformatting of models. Demotivated by the narrow possibilities for promotion or transfer, they do not even have the opportunity to recharge their batteries in research given the slump described above.

Many teachers have virtually no opportunity to share their research experience with students, absorbed as they are by low-end or zany undergraduate tutorials, such as "student personal project" or "games of the goose." They then tell themselves that the skills required to teach at university today are more a matter of a BAFA (French National Diploma of Advanced Studies) than a doctorate. The fierce competition for "interesting" courses (disciplinary or research-oriented, in Master's courses for example) means that relationships between colleagues easily turn sour and many forgo opportunities to take a breather through retraining leave or delegations, for fear of not being able to find their favorite courses upon their return.

 

Historical perspective: a short escapade to the 19th centurye century

The late 18th and 19th centuries witnessed, if not the birth , then at least the fundamental structuring of modern science. It was a golden age for science: Napoleon repeatedly expressed his regret at having chosen a military career over a scientific one and preferred spending his leisure time with his colleagues at the Academy of Sciences rather than with his generals. Throughout the century, scientists were courted by those in power and sought out to participate in their affairs. This stands in stark contrast to today, where opinion leaders are listened to more than experts by our political decision-makers.

Let's take a look at some of the most notable figures among the great naturalists of the time. Cuvier, Humboldt, Darwin, and Fabre are among the most notable, as they were the founders of vertebrate paleontology, modern geography, the theory of evolution, and entomology. The table below summarizes the key elements of their biographies, as presented by Wikipedia.

            What characterizes all four of them is the short time they spent on the benches of the University before launching into active life and exploring Nature. Cuvier was a tutor at 19, then employed as a clerk and then a "salpêtrier" during the French Revolution. At the same age, Fabre was already a teacher, while Darwin embarked on the Beagle as a naturalist at 22, for 5 years of exploration (escaping the career of doctor or pastor that his father intended for him). As the only noble and non-provincial of the four, Humboldt took more time but still became an inspector of mines at 25. He dreamed of traveling the world and after unsuccessful attempts with Bougainville and Napoleon, he embarked at 30 for the King of Spain, bound for America.

All four were self-taught individuals in a scientific field they hadn't studied and which they built themselves. It was through practice, reading, and discussions with other experts that they acquired their scientific knowledge and prepared their fundamental discoveries. Cuvier came to the National Museum of Natural History in Paris to present his personal work [9] , impressed everyone, and was offered a professorship and a seat at the Academy at the age of 27, despite having no recommendations or formal qualifications in the field. He then climbed the Parisian academic ladder at a dizzying pace.

While Humboldt and Darwin, after their sensational voyages around the world for 5 years [10] 11] , quickly established themselves within the elite of their respective capitals (Berlin and London) to remain there for the rest of their lives, Fabre, then a high school teacher in Avignon, only made a brief visit to Paris to be close to the powers that be, under the protection of a minister of Napoleon III. He burned his wings after being accused of pornography and subversion (he allegedly taught young girls the details of flower fertilization!), resigned from the civil service at 47, and retired to the South of France to live off the proceeds from the sale of his numerous textbooks. Was this already a sign of a flaw in the French system, incapable of recognizing its geniuses and where the jealousy of the mediocre reigns supreme, or simply a reflection of his class of origin, peasant rather than noble or bourgeois? Cuvier, the son of a poor soldier from the eastern reaches of France (hence his studies in Germany), rose to the top very early and never came down, perhaps thanks to the Revolution, and to an ambition that Balzac considered excessive and which led him to the title of baron.

In short, these founders of new scientific disciplines, whose works are still assiduously read in the 21st century [ 12] the English edition of G. Cuvier's major work in 2003 has already been cited 258 times; Darwin's * On the Origin of Species * is cited more than 1500 times a year; the original French edition of Humboldt's travelogue is cited 250 times, and his article on the distribution of heat on the Earth's surface is still cited in specialized articles on climate change; as for the four thousand pages of Fabre's entomological memoirs, republished by Laffont in 1989, every French-speaking entomologist, amateur or professional, has at least some excerpts in their library) , developed on the margins of the academic system. It is more than likely that these four scholars spent little time filling out forms or teaching students, caring little about profiting from their knowledge. Could they have achieved such success in today's academic world? It's doubtful. In any case, their early entry into the workforce contrasts sharply with the situation of our students, who sometimes still linger in classrooms, unsure of what to do with their lives, at the age when Darwin returned from his circumnavigation of the globe and Cuvier joined the Academy. And Fabre's example leads us to question whether one needs a master's degree to be a good teacher…

Last Name Date and place of birth Last diploma before working life Academic recognition Recognition (international
Georges Cuvier 1769 Montbeliard University of Stuttgart 1788 (19 years old) Academy of Sciences 1796 (27 years) Legion of Honor 1829 Peer of France 1832
Charles Darwin 1809 Wales Bachelor of Theology 1831 (22 years) Cambridge Royal Society 1839 (30 years) On the Origin of Species 1859 (50 years)
Jean-Henri Fabre 1823 Aveyron Teacher 1842 (19 years old) Avignon Thesis 1855 (32 years old) Paris 1869 Legion of Honor (46 years)
Alexander Von Humboldt 1769 Berlin, Germany 1794 (25 years old) Mining Engineer Göttingen Associate member of the Academy of Paris 1810 (41 years old) Chamberlain to the King of Prussia 1805 (36 years old)

Conclusions and perspectives (sic)

My feelings and those of close colleagues, as well as the many testimonies received in the context of my attempts to alert the community and the general public [13] The CNRS must stop hindering scientific research [14] “ CNRS: new mission management system, we can’t take it anymore! ” lead me to a depressing conclusion: there are no longer any happy teacher-researchers or researchers in France, apart from those who have a magic bullet to (almost) no longer teach and who twiddle their thumbs on the research side: thus they have no credits to spend, no contract workers to recruit, no distant missions, no non-EU collaborators to welcome, etc. The worst part is that it's not really a problem of insufficient resources: I've received numerous accounts, particularly from female researchers, who, after securing a million euros or more from the ERC, suffered burnout or even resigned due to administrative harassment that transforms program implementation into a constant struggle. In what other European country is receiving ERC funding more of a calamity than a blessing for the lucky recipient?

My observation was unfortunately confirmed by IPSOS, which conducted a survey in 2023 on behalf of the CNRS among fourteen thousand employees of that organization [15] . The results are appalling: only 2-3% of respondents completely agree with the statement that "management at the CNRS is efficient" or that "things have been simplified"; among eight adjectives proposed to describe the mindset of CNRS employees, the top four are "motivated, worried, tired, disillusioned," far surpassing "happy, confident, and enthusiastic." One cannot work at the CNRS without being motivated; otherwise, one resigns to earn more elsewhere, as many do, so the positive nature of the first adjective is questionable. Despite all the warning signs [16] , the exhortations of Emmanuel Macron [17] and of Gabriel Attal [18] , nothing could even give hope that research organizations would roll up their sleeves to get out of the rut.

As for teaching, I'll leave the floor to a Belgian colleague [19] and prefer not to rub salt in the wounds of those still in the profession; it would be cruel of a retiree. In this prevailing gloom, one glimmer of hope remains: freedom of thought and expression is still intact in the academic world. But for how much longer?

Share this article

Facebook X LinkedIn

Author

Right of reply and contributions
Would you like to respond? Submit an opinion piece proposal →

You might also like:

WOKISM VS TRUMPISM: A NEW WAR OF IDEAS

An interview by Pierre-Henri Tavoillot with the philosopher Manuel Maria Carrilho who analyzes wokism as an ideology stemming from the "paradigm of the unlimited", based on a boundless conception of identity and language, and marked by a censorial fanaticism deeply rooted in Western institutions.

The Forbidden Book: Ferghane Azihari Against Islam

Ferghane Azihari's latest essay offers a critique of Islam, which he portrays as inherently hostile to modernity, freedom, and progress. Despite its publishing success, Vincent Tournier has noted a silence or reluctance in the media to discuss these ideas.
What you have left to read
0 %

Maybe you should subscribe?

Otherwise, it's okay! You can close this window and continue reading.

    Register: