Observatoire academic ethics
Menu

Convergence of struggles

Illustration for the article "Convergence of Struggles"

Convergence of struggles

Jacques-Robert

Professor Emeritus of Cancerology, University of Bordeaux
Ms. Panot has succeeded in converging a strange struggle she has waged against public health and anti-Semitism! We expect her to use Israel, and therefore all Jews no doubt, to justify the fight against the high cost of living, against the loss of biodiversity, and who knows what else? 

Table of contents

This article has no sections.

Illustration for the article "Convergence of Struggles"

Convergence of struggles

Against stupidity, the gods themselves struggle in vain.[1]

A worthy representative of that "detestable, violent, conspiratorial, passionately anti-Semitic [2] " party, La France Insoumise, Ms. Panot has managed to combine a strange struggle she has waged against public health with the anti-Semitism of her party: who would have thought of that! We now await her to invoke Israel, and therefore all Jews no doubt, to justify the fight against the high cost of living, against the loss of biodiversity, against the falling leaves in autumn, and who knows what else?

Why then did she oppose Pink October, this month dedicated to raising awareness about breast cancer? This annual initiative is not just about organized screening; it's a reminder to take care of oneself, not to hesitate to consult a general practitioner or specialist as soon as one has any doubt, not to fear a diagnosis, and to lead a healthy life. It is no coincidence that breast cancer mortality in France decreased between 1990 and 2023 by 30% in the 25-45 age group and by 37% in those over 45, even though the incidence increased by 45% and 35% respectively during the same period [3] . While care and treatments have certainly improved over the past 35 years, the early diagnosis of curable tumors largely explains both the increase in incidence and the decrease in mortality. The more aware women are, the earlier they become concerned and seek medical help, the greater the chances of recovery.

One objection to Breast Cancer Awareness Month is that raising women's awareness of their health masks the environmental causes of cancer [4] . Is there anything more foolish than Ms. Cadier-Loriaud's "health capitalism"? No link has ever been shown between breast cancer and the environment. And it's not for lack of trying to connect the two at all costs; lobbies are busy doing just that, like the Ramazzini "Institute" in Italy, a major source of biased articles reporting on scientifically flawed research. On the other hand, the links between breast cancer and the number of children, duration of breastfeeding, and exposure to estrogen have been known for a long time but are carefully kept quiet. For me, women have the most sacred right: the right to be informed, not the right to be used to defend political positions.

Because, of course, attacking Pink October is attacking the public authorities, the deep state, the "system" in general: the proof is that the Minister of Health supports it and wears its emblem. It is indeed the responsibility of the public authorities to protect women, and they do so tirelessly by informing them, through Public Health France and other communication tools, about the dangers of tobacco, alcohol, poor nutrition, obesity, lack of physical activity… These are well-known carcinogenic factors that explain 40% of cancers. In a major review on the dangers that constitute a threat to global health in the next 75 years, a commission of 63 experts established by the renowned British medical journal The Lancet [5] did not see fit to include pesticides, much to the dismay I imagine of the "planet" journalists of an evening daily.

Having asked the question, "Why oppose Breast Cancer Awareness Month?", I won't ask, "How can one be antisemitic?" Historians, philosophers, and sociologists have answered that question better than I could, but I would like to understand the link between public health and antisemitism. I don't know if Ms. Panot attacked public health at the same time to indulge in the passionate antisemitism of La France Insoumise (LFI), or if, conversely, it was by attacking public health that she took the opportunity to slip in some nauseating remarks against Israel, which, however, has nothing to do with Breast Cancer Awareness Month… She needed to find a link, and I'm presenting it to you for what it's worth. It was the Conspiracy Watch website that uncovered and debunked it [6]. , which justifies the label of "conspiracy theorist" applied by Raphaël Enthoven to LFI…

In short, the chemical and pharmaceutical company ICI (Imperial Chemical Industries) comprised, in the 1980s, a pharmaceutical laboratory, which it later spun off to become AstraZeneca, and an agricultural chemicals division, which became Syngenta. Both are now completely independent, and accusing the latter of producing pesticides (and therefore cancers!) so that the former can sell the drug that treats them, tamoxifen, is pure fantasy. And what about the Jews in all this? Ah, yes, a Syngenta subsidiary, Adama, is headquartered in Israel! The fact that it was bought fifteen years ago by a Chinese state-owned company is irrelevant: as long as you can slip in the word "Israel," even in a flimsy argument, it wins votes for Mr. Mélenchon—it's all to his advantage!

One of my colleagues, a research director at the CNRS, seems to belong to the LFI movement [7] . He once reproached me for having called him an "activist." I replied that it wasn't an insult and that I did indeed advocate for scientific integrity, against antisemitism, and that I had a few other commitments. He nobly replied that he, on the other hand, was an activist for "public health." In fact, the object of his struggle is the banning of pesticides in agriculture: the link is tenuous, but why not? Since so many people believe it, it must be true! And I realized that, for once, our struggles converged: his against the attacks LFI was waging against public health, and mine against the ignominy of this political party's passionate antisemitism.

Share this article

Facebook X LinkedIn

Author

Right of reply and contributions
Would you like to respond? Submit an opinion piece proposal →

You might also like:

Timeline of a disaster: how gender entered French higher education policy

At the turn of the 21st century, gender policy in higher education did not yet take the familiar form it would assume fifteen years later in French universities. Feminist research, policies promoting equality between women and men, and debates on the place of women in scientific careers all predated it. But the turn of the century saw the systematization, in several countries, of another approach: it was no longer simply a matter of helping individuals or correcting inequalities on an ad hoc basis, but of transforming the institutions that produced or reproduced them.

At the University of Grenoble, it's Equality Month!

The "month of equality" organised by the University of Grenoble-Alpes replaces academic debate with ideological awareness-raising actions that take the place of intellectual reflection.
What you have left to read
0 %

Maybe you should subscribe?

Otherwise, it's okay! You can close this window and continue reading.

    Register: