by Charles COUTEL
Following the article of March 03, 2021 in the newspaper Le Monde entitled " Mysterious modification of a job description at the University of Paris-Créteil " , we have explored the chronological details of this case which concerns the recruitment of a lecturer in educational sciences and philosophy for the INSPE of Créteil, therefore in the training of teachers.
Following up on our previous article published on the website of the observatory of decolonialism entitled " On the great danger of decolonial pedagogy in teacher training ", we obtained the two job descriptions which we submit to the readers and whose teaching profile and research profile we will detail.
In the first version of this job description, the future researcher is expected to anchor his or her research in the cross-study of the variables of sex, gender, social class and race of the children in the school; in the second version, the research profile is modified and reoriented towards the study of "male-female" inequalities; in the third version, the research criteria have returned to their original requirements, thus reaffirming the requirement for studies of race, sex, sexuality and gender among children in the school of the Republic (sic). The implicit reference to decolonialism is materialized here in the classification of "racialized" children (sic) understood as descendants of colonized people treated unequally and according to their "race" in the school of the Republic. It is hard to believe it. And yet. A careful reading of these two job descriptions confirms the decolonial drift that is infiltrating the INSPE, a high place for teacher training and protection of the children of the Republic, whose children we categorically refuse to be confined in statistical boxes under the term "racialized", recalling the worst hours of history.
This is why this recruitment seems to be of unprecedented gravity, which we explain.
On the “teaching” profile
If this drift concerns the candidate's research profile, it's important to understand that the "teaching" profile is linked to the training and teaching of everything related to the first competency listed in the professional competency framework for teaching and education professions—namely, " Sharing the values of the Republic ." This teacher-researcher, alongside their research work, which we will detail below, would have the mission of training others in the values and principles of the Republic. How can a researcher, willing to conduct research on children based on their race and sex (sic), research that is anti-humanist and anti-republican, claim to teach and train teachers in the values and principles of a Republic that recognizes neither race nor affiliation? Is there a devious decolonial strategy at play that exploits republican laws to destabilize and dismantle them within the University? We remain unconvinced.
Still within the teaching profile, the recruited individual would be responsible for providing continuing professional development for primary school teachers within the district, focusing on secularism, the issue of authority, etc. How can a teacher-researcher, convinced that discrimination based on race and gender exists in schools, possibly lead this type of training for experienced teachers whose practical challenges, particularly regarding authority, are so far removed from those that concern decolonial thinkers? Is this an attempt to contradict the voices of teachers who have been attesting for years to their difficulties in applying the principle of secularism, fostering a positive school climate, and addressing issues related to religion within institutions? Even worse, just a few months after the horrific murder of history teacher Samuel Paty, we are concerned about a trend linked to the portrayal of teachers as supposedly racist and perpetuating discrimination in schools. The third part of the job description confirms our fears.
Finally, still within the teaching profile, and this is where our warning about decolonial pedagogy becomes relevant and serves as an example, this same researcher would be responsible for "leading Reflection Groups in the teacher training program at the Inspé (National Higher Institute for Teacher Training and Education), to promote reflection on educational ethics ." A reflection group within the framework of education and teacher training aims to allow members of the same profession to reflect and express themselves freely in order to build collective solutions that are genuinely ethical, moral, and professional. However, and this is where we uncover the activists' intentions, a reflection group promotes nothing! It imposes nothing. It does not attempt to convert its members. It offers tools and methods of self-critical analysis, allowing each individual to reflect on their own practice based on collective doubt. The promotion here reiterates the warning we issued regarding decolonial pedagogy about the idea of teachers exhibiting ambiguous, racist, or discriminatory professional practices that need to be enlightened and transformed. We find answers to our questions in the research profile.
On the “search” profile
Thus, the initial job description expects the candidate to focus on " understanding how public and social problems in education are constructed, identifying and analyzing their treatment and prevention methods, in relation to inequalities of 'race,' gender, sexuality, or class. Expectations are also high regarding the study of professional practices inherent in preventing educational inequalities ." The link between pedagogical professional practice and racial and sexual inequality (sic) in " educational practices and ideas " reveals the ideological bias associated with these decolonial working groups and this position. Concern for schools and the crisis they are experiencing is supposedly linked to practices and actions that produce gender inequalities (we remind you that we are talking about children) and racial inequalities through a racist teacher who is unaware of their own racism… An unacceptable presupposition that we denounce!
But still.
The research of the recruited individual will focus on " the formation, construction, and prevention of inequalities in education, particularly in schools, taking into account ethno-racial discrimination, issues of gender and sexuality, and social inequalities. It will articulate at least two of these social relations and strive to grasp the implications of an intersectional approach in education in order to deepen our understanding of the processes that foster the production/reproduction of inequalities and discrimination within a context of the democratization of education ." This clearly amounts to asserting that childhood sexualities should be a subject of research in schools, thus playing at being sorcerer's apprentices with children, in order to counter this school system that is becoming democratized (sic) and producing racial inequalities. The indictment of the Republic's school system, for a position that intends to promote its principles and values, is explicit. The aim is to assert that free schooling, the explosion of its educational offerings, allowing each adolescent to build a diploma-granting path, the creation of numerous baccalaureate degrees promoting certification and guidance for young people so that no one is left without a solution, in short, that all educational policies implemented in favor of youth, are merely mechanisms designed to generate racism, discrimination, etc.
We denounce a job description which conceals the integration, like a real Trojan horse, of a teacher-researcher wishing to promote the deadly ideology of decolonial pedagogy in the project not of promoting the values and principles of the Republic, but of destroying them at its base, namely the school.
Before concluding, we question both this recruitment and the intentions of the authors when writing these job descriptions, and also the legal scope of changing a job description during the official opening of the recruitment procedures for lecturers. Indeed, how can we conceive of equal treatment for all candidates, when the information and expectations of a research profile have been subject to ideological modifications during the recruitment campaign? Can we impose, should we impose, on a candidate that he convert to decolonial or intersectional work if he wishes to obtain a position at a French university? This attempt at conversion, which is akin to ideological blackmail, impacts precarious researchers, previously weakened by a drop in the number of positions offered in the competitions. This manipulation of candidates is unacceptable.
This is why, in the face of current abuses and the republican principles flouted in this recruitment procedure, we are asking that a recruitment freeze for this position be implemented, based on the two job descriptions published during this recruitment campaign.