Wokeism was born on American campuses. It has spread to England and the European continent. Will its cradle become its tomb? The time has come for a counter-offensive. And in the Anglo-Saxon world, resistance is being organized. This book chronicles it.
How to counter the woke wave? How to respond to its excesses? Gender theory, racialism, decolonialism, transactivism: the diversity system is imposed everywhere. The woke sees only victims and executioners around it and, to repair the world, works to pulverize it.
So strong minds refuse to give in to pressure and defend equal rights. Philosophers, academics, doctors, lawyers or ordinary citizens are working to thwart the advent of an Orwellian world. Faced with the violence of their adversaries, they risk their careers and their reputations, but defend their convictions in the midst of the din. Sylvie Perez went to meet them.
The result of a long investigative work, this book documents the responses emerging from all strata of society. By circumvention or by shock, by seriousness or by humor, the fight for freedom of expression is engaged. And the cultural battle rages.
Journalist, Sylvie Perez has worked in the written press and on the radio. She has published several essays, novels and books of interviews, and translated Agatha Christie's theatrical work from English..
Here are some good sheets.
THE WORLD UPRIGHT
Anglo-Saxon neo-progressivism is one step ahead. Its inventions arrive here with a time delay. What is happening here, most often, happened there a little earlier. So that observing the evolution of this movement in the Anglosphere is a way of reading the future. However, where it was conceived and implemented, wokeism is today the target of critical minds who unmask its slogans and document its dead ends. The advances of the anti-woke laboratory are plotted by contrarian minds from all philosophical, political, religious or ethnic horizons. They are concerned with containing this muddled ideology that shakes and weakens the very foundations of institutions; they have in common only the categorical refusal of post-truth and are busy thwarting the advent of an Orwellian world. The question transcends political families and mobilizes a new category of politically non-binary swordsmen. Wokism, instigator of fluidity and trans-identity, will also have engendered trans-politics!
From London, a pivotal point for wokism between America and France, I was able to observe the development of response strategies and the ongoing resurgence. While wokism is a seismic movement that began in the 1980s, its most extravagant effects have appeared in the last ten years. As Simon Leys wrote [1] Orwell or the Horror of Politics , Simon Leys, p. 32 : “ History has already shown on several occasions that it does not take much to plunge millions of people into the hell of 1984: all it takes is a handful of organized and determined thugs. These draw most of their strength from the silence and blindness of honest people. ”
Optimistic and determined, the dissidents of wokeism have developed the tools of resistance. Among them, a few tech geniuses exasperated by the political correctness of Silicon Valley, a few feminists who love men, a few daredevil comedians who laugh at everything, a few lawyers attached to the fundamental principles of law, a few artists who turn away from progressive realism and are busy creating rather than educating the people, a few PhD students who want to save the university, a few diehards who decode politically correct newspeak, a few absolutists of freedom of expression who are not fooled by sermons against 'hate speech', a few representatives of the black community unwilling to serve as puppets for anti-racist associations, a few transgender people who have no need to deny biology in order to exist, a whole world that prefers to stay alive rather than waste its efforts on self-censorship and denouncing the wrong-thinking.
Already, excellent works have appeared in France, which document the effects of wokeness. This one chronicles the response, developed by the promoters of a society that rehabilitates irony and bad spirit, values human genius, diversity of opinions, invention, research, knowledge, merit, a society where we can breathe again. A society, in other words.
(...)
THE PAST IS NOT WHAT IT WAS
The History Reclaimed association was founded in August 2021 to counter the woke instrumentalization of history, which reduces the Western past to three sacrileges: colonialism, imperialism, and racism. Observing that this Manichean vision is becoming the accepted wisdom, historians are engaging in the culture wars. The History Reclaimed website is open to them to restore complex truths, introduce nuance, and bring a historical perspective to the historical debate.
Wokism has focused on the history of the triangular trade and the horrific episode of the slave trade. The aim is to redress the past through financial compensation for the descendants of slaves. Robert Tombs, a history professor at Cambridge and founder of History Reclaimed , doubts the validity of this approach. According to him, the research project funded by Cambridge University regarding its links to slavery and the need to consider reparations is more of a public relations exercise than an academic project: " If the question is, 'Did the university benefit from slavery?', the answer is obviously yes. All European institutions benefited, directly or indirectly, from the revenues of slave-based industries (sugar, cotton, tobacco) ," he told me . "What characterizes Cambridge is its actions against slavery." In 1785, the university's vice-chancellor proposed this topic of study: "Can men be enslaved against their will?" The student Thomas Clarkson (1760-1846) received a prize for his essay, after which he tirelessly campaigned for the abolition of slavery. In 1789, a young Tory MP, William Wilberforce, also a Cambridge graduate, led a campaign in the House of Commons against the slave trade, which ultimately led to its abolition. So, while the university received money from industrialists who had built their fortunes on the slave trade, it was also very active in the fight against slavery. However, since this research program was conducted under the guise of "initiatives on racial equality," the objective was self-flagellation, allowing the university to proclaim, "Look how virtuous we are." It would be a good idea to offer scholarships for African students, not as a form of redress, but because we no longer have any African students. It's a shame.
Understanding the present in light of the past rather than judging the past in light of the present. (…) Robert Tombs's association sets out to defuse the woke landmines on the battlefield that history has become. The site presents itself as a digital scholarly journal, publishes contributions from historians, offers a podcast, access to reliable historical sources, reading lists, a history book prize, and debates on trending topics.
(...)
HEALTH SCANDAL
What could two unassuming psychotherapists possibly do in the face of such a powerful social movement? I met Marcus and Sue Evans on February 3, 2020, to discuss the cases that had propelled them into the British media spotlight. The Evans couple found themselves embroiled in a daring legal battle. Marcus Evans had resigned the previous year from the board of the Tavistock & Portman NHS Trust in London, home to the GIDS (Gender Identity Development Service), the world's largest clinic of its kind for minors. Sue Evans, for her part, filed a lawsuit against the same Tavistock , accusing it of subjecting children to experimental hormone treatments. (…)
As in the US, gender dysphoria has spread to the UK. The number of children consulting at the GIDS (Gender Dysphoria and Disorder) rose from 77 in 2009 to 5000 in 2021, an increase of 6400%. And the figure doubled in just two years, between 2019 (2500) and 2021 (5000). “ The social contagion is worrying, particularly among girls, who now represent 76% of patients ,” Marcus Evans told me. “ This situation is unprecedented. Yet no serious research is being undertaken on this subject. ” (…)
Sue Evans worked at the GIDS between 2003 and 2014. Noticing that children were being hastily referred for hormone treatments, she raised her concerns with management. Despite an internal investigation, nothing changed. " We saw young people being prescribed hormones after only three or four psychotherapy sessions," Sue Evans told me . "I even treated patients for two years for eating disorders. I could never have cured them in four sessions! Transgender issues are similar. The patient is very determined in their narrative. They have identified the problem (I wasn't born in the right body) and the solution (I need to change sex). A patient suffering from anorexia is convinced they are too fat. Agreeing with them won't help." The affirmative approach advocated by transgender associations consists of immediately accepting the patient's narrative and sending them to an endocrinologist. This makes no sense. Psychotherapy aims to adapt the mind to the body, not to modify the body to conform to the patient's idea of it. Transgender activists want to remove gender dysphoria from the realm of psychology.
To treat gender dysphoria, the Evans couple advocates exploratory therapy, rather than affirmative therapy. “ We listen to the patient, we ask them about their gender identity issues, but also about their family and school environment; we try to understand their suffering together. In 90% of cases, without hormonal treatment, the patient eventually reconciles with their body ,” Marcus Evans explains . “Puberty is a complex and anxiety-inducing stage. A whole range of problems are at play during adolescence, a time of sociological, psychological, and physiological metamorphosis. Young people need to be allowed to go through this phase as naturally as possible, at least until the age of 25, when they become more at peace and accept their bodies and their sexuality. Activists say that puberty blockers are ‘just a pause.’ But there’s no ‘pause’ button in a child’s development! By interrupting their development, you remove them from their age group.” While his peers are changing, the child on hormone blockers retains his childlike appearance. You are depriving him of a normal social life. This is by no means a neutral act.
Puberty blockers are not approved for treating gender dysphoria, neither in the United States according to the Food and Drug Administration's classification , nor in the United Kingdom, where the National Institute for Care and Health Excellence (NICE), in 2020, after reviewing published studies on the subject, concluded that there was insufficient evidence to support hormonal treatment for gender dysphoria. There is insufficient long-term data to assess the benefits and risks of this off-label use. [2] Puberty blockers are indicated in rare cases of precocious puberty, but are in no way intended for young people whose physiological development is normal. Prescribing puberty blockers to transgender children is an off-label and experimental use of synthetic hormones. And the side effects observed so far are alarming: impaired brain development and intelligence quotient, osteoporosis, decreased libido, sterility when treatment is started at a very young age.
(...)
LOST IN TRANS-NATION
Even the most renowned gender doctors are concerned about trans-affirmative fundamentalism. Among them is Dr. Marci Bowers, herself a transwoman, a world-renowned obstetrician-gynecologist specializing in vaginoplasties (she has performed over two thousand). She operated on the famous Jazz Jennings (the little American boy who felt like a girl and whose transition was televised in real time). Dr. Bowers has not hidden the complications she encountered when constructing Jazz Jennings' vagina, due to the fact that her patient, who was put on puberty blockers at a young age, had small genitals with little tissue. Dr. Bowers recommends caution in administering puberty blockers because they compromise sexual pleasure and fertility in adulthood.
Erica Anderson, also a trans woman, is a renowned pro-gender-affirmation psychologist in California, and Laura Edwards-Leeper is the co-founder of the first gender clinic in the United States, located in Boston. In late November 2021, Anderson and Edwards-Leeper co-authored an article in the Washington Post . They expressed their concern about the exponential increase in young women being referred for hormone therapy before even having access to proper psychological care. “ The influx of patients to psychologists and gender clinics, combined with a political climate that views each individual’s care as a test of society’s tolerance, is putting practitioners on a slippery and dangerous path. (…) The pressure from activists within medical staff and psychology departments, who, in concert with certain LGBT organizations, are silencing detransitioners and sabotaging any discussion about what is happening in this field, is unacceptable.” (…) this casts doubt on the honesty of our profession and our dedication to helping trans people. ”
(...)
THE POST-WOKE ERA
Wokeism is an ideology conceived on the left and fought from all political sides. In France, the charge is carried by the republican, universalist and secularist left and, with the same vigor, by conservatives and by the proponents of liberalism, all attached to a common world. The Anglo-Saxons, strong in their experience of wokeism, have developed a modus operandi to curb a neo-progressive influence gone mad. In their country, the counter-offensive is entering its third phase. After having identified the current phenomenon, it was necessary to understand it, in order to finally combat it. Thus now appear real anti-woke policies that unravel the diversity system with its anti-democratic commissions and surveillance entities. After the theoretical sequence, we approach the practical: solving the problem.
None of the three steps—identifying, understanding, and developing the tools for the counter-offensive—was a walk in the park. It was important to remember this. Because those who yesterday asserted that wokism doesn't exist will tomorrow claim they were the first to fight it. A reversal of fortune is emerging. The New York Times , the American media giant and mouthpiece of wokism, is beginning to have doubts, after having pilloried those who questioned it before. Yes, of course, wokism must be eradicated, the matter is settled, they tell you. But it took someone crying wolf for this issue to gain traction. They came out of the woodwork when the battle was fierce, risking their reputation, if not their position. Following a tried-and-tested pattern, opposition to wokism, first ridiculed, then violently attacked, will be perceived as self-evident…
If the contrarians hold firm, tolerating being slandered in the mainstream press, it is because once the transgression is committed, there is no possible return to polite society. Wokism demands penance but does not grant forgiveness. From then on, the dissidents, freed from all caution (they have nothing more to lose), listen only to their hearts and move forward, gathering reinforcements, "so much so that seeing them walk with such a face, the most terrified regain courage"... The ranks are swelling.
(...)
Unconscious prejudices, white guilt, safe spaces , trigger warnings , phobias of all kinds—workism speaks only of trauma. Diversity coaching organizes group therapy sessions where everyone is required to verbalize their negative thoughts. The culture of offense glorifies the easily offended. Descendants experience, by extension, the past humiliations suffered by their ancestors because of their race or sexual orientation. Everything is psychology, everything is felt . It's the reign of the mad, the empire of suffering. In a strange presentism, we deny the past and renounce all intellectual heritage, but we hold our ancestors omniresponsible for all the scourges of the moment. Under the guise of compassion, the great emancipators have allowed an unbreathable atmosphere to take hold. It's high time to shed this shell of resentment; to enjoy the world that has been bequeathed to us. The rebuilders are at work. The post-woke era is upon us. Race wars, sex wars, and gender wars will then be nothing more than a bad memory.
Ending Wokeism
de Sylvie Perez
368 pages – Oct. 2023
Editions du Cerf
