Observatoire academic ethics
Menu

Inclusion: The obstacle course for trans athletes

Inclusion: The obstacle course for trans athletes

Collective

Observers' Tribune

Table of contents

Inclusion: The obstacle course for trans athletes

Read More Discrimination Article reserved for subscribers LGBT +dossier Due to a lack of legislation common to all world federations, the presence of trans women is unequal depending on the sport. A discriminatory and politicized situation that affects many athletes less than a year before the Paris Olympic Games. By Romain Métairie and Sascha Garcia Published on May 18, 2023 at 7:49 PM On May 1st, cyclist Austin Killips, 27, won the Tour of the Gila after five days of racing in the mountains of New Mexico. Although the competition was relatively low-profile, it was a double victory for the American: for the first time in cycling history, a transgender rider won an international women's stage race. The symbolism is powerful, and the cyclist was within the rules. Austin Killips is a woman. She has completed her transition and her testosterone level meets the requirements set by the UCI, the international cycling federation, to compete in the women's category. Despite this, some in the peloton are still fuming. Austin Killips finds herself accused of "killing women's cycling." A familiar refrain. And a complex one, since the debate surrounding transgender athletes, particularly women assigned male at birth, touches on issues of bioethics, human rights, gender identity, and fairness in sports. And in the absence of an international scientific consensus on the matter, accusations of "cheating" resurface with each notable performance, as detractors denounce a supposed biological advantage of trans athletes over their cisgender competitors – whose gender identity aligns with the sex assigned at birth. In recent months, these stances have resurfaced.

Discrimination

Subscribers article

LGBT+ dossier

In the absence of common legislation for all world federations, the presence of trans women is unequal depending on the discipline. A discriminatory and politicized situation that many athletes are victims of just under a year before the Paris Olympic Games.

by Romain Métairie and Sascha Garcia

published on May 18, 2023 at 19:49 p.m.

On May 1, 27-year-old cyclist Austin Killips won the Tour de Gila after five days of racing in the mountains of New Mexico. Although the competition was relatively confidential, it was a double victory for the American: for the first time in the history of cycling, a transgender rider won an international women's stage race. The symbolism was strong and the cyclist was within the rules. Austin Killips is a woman. She had completed her transition and had a testosterone level that met the UCI, the international cycling federation, requirements to compete in the women's category.

Despite everything, part of the peloton is still fuming. Austin Killips finds herself accused of "killing women's cycling." A familiar refrain . And a complex one, since the debate surrounding transgender athletes, particularly women assigned male at birth, touches on issues of bioethics, human rights, gender identity, and fairness in sport. And in the absence of an international scientific consensus on the matter, accusations of "cheating" resurface with every notable performance, as detractors denounce a supposed biological advantage of trans athletes over their cisgender competitors—whose gender identity aligns with the sex assigned at birth.

In recent months, these postures have re

 

"This post is a summary of information from our information monitoring"

Author

[side_notes]

Right of reply and contributions
Would you like to respond? Submit an opinion piece proposal →

You might also like:

Eulogy of Mr. Aurélien Taché, benefactor of the French language – An admiring account of a work that will be groundbreaking, if not groundbreaking.

There are books that revolutionize thought. Others that revitalize the sciences. Still others that change the course of history. And then there are books that allow their author to appear on television. Let us not disregard this last category: it now constitutes a considerable part of our intellectual life. Mr. Aurélien Taché has just published a book with Fayard entitled *French, an African Language*. This is a discovery for which we cannot praise him enough. We have known for some time that French is spoken in Senegal, Ivory Coast, Congo, and a few other countries. African writers had even dared to use it to compose literary works. But it took a French politician to finally reveal to us the significance of this fact.

The Forbidden Book: Ferghane Azihari Against Islam

Ferghane Azihari's latest essay offers a critique of Islam, which he portrays as inherently hostile to modernity, freedom, and progress. Despite its publishing success, Vincent Tournier has noted a silence or reluctance in the media to discuss these ideas.
What you have left to read
0 %

Maybe you should subscribe?

Otherwise, it's okay! You can close this window and continue reading.

    Register: