Observatoire academic ethics
Menu

Victim inversion: who is threatening whom?

Illustration for the article "Victim Reversal: Who is threatening whom?"

Victim inversion: who is threatening whom?

Jacques-Robert

Professor Emeritus of Cancerology, University of Bordeaux
An article in Le Monde reverses the roles by portraying so-called progressive academics as victims while imposing their ideological vision on campuses. Through several examples (Grenoble, Lyon II, student blockades, etc.), Jacques Robert denounces institutional complacency in the face of ideologies and the growing disregard for academic freedom.

Table of contents

This article has no sections.

Illustration for the article "Victim Reversal: Who is threatening whom?"

Victim inversion: who is threatening whom?

Never short of ideas to restart a slightly seized machine, Le Monde has just published yet another article defending wokeism[1]Does this mean that our valiant progressive academics are tired of their platforms which all say the same thing (and which ultimately give us good publicity?[2]) ? In any case, two journalists were entrusted with the task of putting coins into the slapping machine, just to keep their hand in.

The originality of this new paper is that it surprisingly reverses the roles of good and bad, executioner and victim, outraged and outraged. Because here's the scoop: on campus, progressive academics are living a real ordeal. You thought that reactionaries and other conservatives had the greatest difficulty expressing themselves, that they were forced to monitor their words and even the content of their courses.[3] to avoid the risk of being threatened or even chased[4] by various categories of students and sometimes teachers who are followers of gender theory, the Palestinian cause and the great evening of racialized people? Well! No way: in reality, they are the ones who make the law, according to the Monde !

Such blatant bad faith in the presentation of the situation is laughable. It's also amusing to read that a certain Baudot, quoted in the article, considered those who protest against the rise of Wokism in universities to be " academics on the decline, seeking media recognition they lack in academia ." When this Baudot, whom the journalists at Le Monde have unearthed, is as well-known and respected in his academic discipline as the three coordinators and twenty or so contributors to * Face à l'obscurantisme woke* (Facing Woke Obscurantism) , we'll talk again. A quick count on Amazon: Pierre-Nicolas Baudot, zero books; Pierre Vermeren: about fifteen; Xavier-Laurent Salvador: five; Emmanuelle Hénin: also five. The same is true for most of the contributors. [5] like Nathalie Heinich, Guylain Chevrier, Nicolas Weill-Parot, Pierre-André Taguieff and many others.

We still laugh, but with a saddened laugh, when we read in the article that Donald Trump supposedly set the tone for our actions. Clearly, the left still refuses to consider that, among the reasons for his election, there might have been weariness with the excesses of a fringe of the Democrats [6] on wokism. Yet, every time Kamala Harris began a speech by stating her "pronouns," she lost 500,000 votes. The National Institutes of Health funded research on transgender mice by giving them cross-fertilized hormones [7] . The University of Michigan paid [8] 1100 nonfaculty employees to work on DEI ( Diversity, Equity, Inclusion ). It was easy to appeal to voters' biases to get elected, and any other Ubu would have been elected under those circumstances.

The Le Monde article is 14,000 characters long, including spaces. Every sentence deserves commentary, so dishonest or biased are the claims. Here are a few examples.

The most baffling passage is the "Grenoble affair" from five years ago, revisited by Le Monde ; the journalists outright hold a professor at the Institute of Political Studies (IEP), publicly vilified for "Islamophobia," responsible for the media amplification of this attack. Just imagine: not only did he dare to alert a television channel, but the dreaded "far-right sphere" also dared to seize upon the affair. And now, a director of the IEP is rejoicing that "the controversy is dying down" and that the students are being acquitted… A word to the wise for students: you can vilify, threaten, and denounce professors who don't share your views on public notice boards, you risk nothing! The university hierarchy will support you. As for the professors, they will emerge "exhausted" from this affair, not by your threats, but by the mistreated professor who dared to protest and alert public opinion. To force the IEP to back down, the region had to suspend its funding, which led the IEP to make a "republican" commitment that was clearly not a given.

Now here is a professor at the University of Lyon II, Fabrice Balanche, who is banned from classes by a horde of excited students who assume he has this or that opinion on the geopolitics of the Middle East, of which he is a great specialist. The president of the university, instead of supporting him, agrees with the students.[9]. So here is another matter that undoubtedly "tires" his colleagues, who would like to remain quietly in their little comfort without looking at what is happening next door. This is how tyrannies are born: through disinterest, through passivity, through the conformism of those who should be carrying the banner of freedom high and strong, that is to say, intellectuals, first and foremost academics.

I completely agree with Francis Dupuis-Déri's point of view: " It's political agitation, aimed at a specific electorate ." Indeed, we saw that clearly when pro-Palestinian activists blockaded Sciences Po and several other universities. Ah, but not at all! He means that it's the students who want to work who are destabilizing these brave pacifist activists who are spreading fear among Jewish students, for example, those who were excluded from their WhatsApp group because of a Jewish-sounding name [10] . As for the students or teachers who supposedly "go into exile" to pursue their research abroad, particularly in Canada, we doubt their existence. Proof? In any case, if they apply to the University of Ottawa, they risk being disappointed since, there, a position has been opened "to qualified black people from Africa or the African diaspora [11] ".

Share this article

Facebook X LinkedIn

Author

Right of reply and contributions
Would you like to respond? Submit an opinion piece proposal →

You might also like:

Science and ideology: where is the boundary today?

From October 8 to 10, 2026, the Observatory of University Ethics is organizing a symposium at the Sorbonne and the Condorcet Campus dedicated to the boundaries between science and ideology. Free admission.

Science and Ideology Symposium, October 8-10, 2026

What you have left to read
0 %

Maybe you should subscribe?

Otherwise, it's okay! You can close this window and continue reading.

    Register: