Text published in August 2016 in brochure no. 21bis "Islamisms, Islamo-leftism, Islamophobia " , Second part: Islam, far-right, totalitarianism, from war to domination and put online the following year.
-
Is there no better symbol of submission to Muslim imperialism than the image of the Algerian people prostrating themselves five times a day towards their conqueror located in Arabia?
Why I am not a Muslim,
Ibn Warraq, ed. The Age of Man, 1999, p. 249
The aim of this text is to put forward some elements of analysis for the purpose of understanding the Islamist phenomenon. This requires shedding a number of received ideas, the fruits of a tree whose ideological roots will not be analyzed here. [1] Some elements have been put forward in "Western Confusion" (brochure no. 19, Unease in Identity , May 2012) as well as in "The Roots of Islamo-Leftism," above, p. 23 ff. However, three of them, particularly salient, deserve to be cited in this introduction in order to clarify our point.
Approaching Islamism: Three preconceived ideas
The first is to believe that the lifestyle of Western societies embodies the "ideal" of human societies – in other words, that their appeal proves that, as is often heard, "deep down everyone wants to live peacefully" with their family, their house, their dog, and, implicitly, the whole of consumer society . This touching ethnocentrism seeks to ignore the march of history as well as the complexity of the human psyche: while comfort and indifference may indeed temporarily numb the search for meaning, the need for belonging, the tendencies toward domination and hoarding, the murderous impulses, and the desire for death, they do not eliminate them.
The second, a logical implication of the first, would be that the world's disorder, its violence, its chaos, and consequently, Islamism, find their sources in the West itself, its transient imperfections, its difficulties of access, and that, therefore, only the West is capable of resolving them. This is to confuse the influence of the Western world on the course of events on the one hand, and the reactions it provokes on the other. These reactions are as diverse as the multitude of societies and cultures that must assume full responsibility for them: Islamism belongs to Islam. [2] See the general introduction "The West at the Foot of the Wall," brochure no. 21, November 2015. There, we pointed to three "explanatory" factors of Islamism, against the backdrop of a Muslim demographic peak: the de facto discrediting of the Mahometan dogma in the face of rationality; the failure of the modernizing projects of decolonization in Islamic lands; The weakening of the West's emancipatory project is interpreted as a dead end. See also "A Brief History of Islamism," below , p. 10 , as well as the Meiji era in Japan.
The third misconception, though increasingly difficult to do, seeks to reduce Islamism to terrorism, preferring to deny what we must now acknowledge as the progressive Islamization of our societies through civil means. Far removed from spectacular violence, this persistent, daily, and relentless phenomenon is a deep-seated current without a true center, a capillary movement resonating with millions of Muslims across the globe. Their driving force is well known: boundless adulation for a warlord named Muhammad, the veneration of the "Holy Quran," and an obsession with the pilgrimage to Mecca—a compulsive proselytism. For the past century, we have witnessed a resurgence of Islam, toward which a myriad of seemingly unrelated acts converge: a veil is being donned, ambiguity is being displayed, mutual aid is becoming communalized, consumption is becoming " halalized ," and liturgical practices (festivals, fasting, prayers, etc.) are expanding, becoming systematic, and hardening. Islamism is this historical current, so fascinating in its immanence that it seems to constitute the very meaning of history. It appears to mimic the forms of the European and American labor movement from the 17th to the 20th centuries, the latest wave of this current of emancipation that has so singularly revolutionized Western societies since the High Middle Ages, raising human ideals to an unparalleled level. This shows how Islamism, through the formation of counter-societies, is bound to transform in turn and in depth all the societies in which it unfolds [3] Cf. Ch. Caldwell, 2011; A revolution before our eyes: How Islam will transform France and Europe , Toucan edition, as well as the observations made by P. Manent in Situation of France ( Desclée de Brouwer, 2015)..
It is therefore a real civilizational dynamic that we are confronted with, and that we must understand. This is the objective of the few remarks that follow, which are in no way definitive.
The first part examines contemporary Islamism from the perspective of analyzing the totalitarian phenomenon: while Islamism can indeed be fully characterized as a new totalitarianism , it exhibits traits decidedly foreign to historical totalitarianism, prompting us to question both the latter and the unique characteristics of Islamism that distinguish it. This is the subject of the second part, which elucidates the notion of imperialism in the historical sense of the term in an attempt to understand, in its totalitarian aspects, this attempt to re-establish a thousand-year-old Caliphate . Finally, the eminently religious dimension of this Caliphate is explored in the third and final part, notably by tracing it back to the origins of monotheism, the breeding ground of millenarianism —this activism that seeks to put an end to history.
I – Islamism as totalitarianism
While describing Islamism as totalitarian is not new [4] Cf. the inaugural A. Del Valle, Le totalitarisme islamiste à l'assaut des démocraties , preface by Rachid Kaci, éditions des Syrtes 2002. , and is even becoming common today without raising any further questions, the implications and aporias that this raises for political thought are still left in the shadows.
Totalitarianism as the unlimited expansion of rational control
Let us first summarize, in a few lines, the characteristics of a totalitarian regime. Such a regime arises from a tabula rasa, whether provoked by prior historical shocks or actively sought through an aspiration for total war. It is from such upheaval that a power emerges which aims for the Unity of society, that is to say, its complete subjugation by the State, and the fusion of the State with the Party, its Apparatus, and its Summit. The ideology, monolithic and unquestionable, is imposed, hammered home, internalized, and seeks not consent but rather the surrender of souls, through official lies, indoctrination, conditioning, terror, and the establishment of an absurd arbitrariness that empties daily life of all meaning. It is, of course, the reign of denunciation, police forces and the deportation of entire populations, of labor camps and systematic massacres of extermination. This “ Absolute Evil ” for H. Arendt, this “ Monstrous ” for C. Castoriadis, has been identified as the reversal of a logic of Western origin against the West itself and the emancipation which its history carries.
Multiple analyses have been made of it, but those of C. Castoriadis seem to us to contain the most relevant elements and, as we shall see, bring forth fruitful unsuspected reflections [5] A remarkable synthesis of his intellectual journey can be found in "The Social Regime of Russia", 1978, in Domains of Man, The Crossroads of the Labyrinth II , Seuil 1986, reed. 1999, p. 215..
For him, the institution of totalitarianism, one of the sinister creations of the 20th century, represents the site of the boundless deployment of an ideological element of Western origin : the blind pursuit of the unlimited expansion of rational control , which emerged after the Renaissance. This tendency toward the incessant control of both people and things is found in the development of capitalist mechanisms, the techno-scientific race, and the exercise of state power. But this logic encounters, within a society of rights (the "Rights of Man" are essentially a protection against the State ), struggles (the workers' movements against the reification of labor), limits imposed by traditions, the resistance of ordinary people, and all the reflexes, mentalities, principles, and institutions that the struggles for emancipation have wrested from successive European regimes for at least four centuries. This balance of power does not exist, or no longer exists, under a totalitarian regime, which sweeps away all sources of conflict to establish a society totally under rational control – that is to say, totally delusional (North Korea embodying it to the point of caricature).
Historical convergences with Nazism
This analysis allows us to read, as a first approach, what is happening to Muslim regions and countries: the classical Islamic tradition, “ closed in on itself, inevitably dogmatic, theocentric and self-referential ” [6] H. Redissi, “Islam and modernity” in Geneviève Gobillot (ed.), World of Islam and the West, the paths of interculturality , EME, Brussels, 2010, available on our website. , has been subjected for one or two centuries to a Western influence which is causing an unprecedented existential crisis, delivering the disarmed populations, without endogenous emancipatory practices, to the unlimited madness of local despots who effectively use all the technical or institutional levers brought by the West [7] Cf. “The West at the foot of the wall”, op. cit. . Information filtering out of regions of the world dominated by state or capillary Islamism, what is known about the functioning of institutions, groups and jihadist squadrons claiming allegiance to it, what is revealed by crude or subtle propaganda methods, and the impression that emerges from confrontations with ordinary neo-Muslim mentalities converge to outline, without too much difficulty, the effective contours of a new totalitarianism.
Its formation is also concomitant with that of the other two, National Socialist and Bolshevik [8] The western branch, represented by the Muslim Brotherhood, was formed in Egypt in 1928, and the Indo-Pakistani branch, Tabligh , was created in India in 1927. , and the historical links with Nazism (and Fascism) have also been largely established; whether it be the close ties between Mussolini's and Hitler's regimes with Arab leaders such as Rashid Ali al-Gaylani, Muhammad al-Maadi, or the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem (the latter playing a significant role in the "Final Solution"), the organization of anti-Semitic pogroms, the formation of Muslim armed forces in the service of the Axis, the mass integration of Nazi officers into Arab-Muslim government services after the war, or the active support of their sympathizers for the Palestinian cause [9] Cf. Fabei S. 2005; The Beam, the Swastika and the Crescent ; Akribea and Kündel M. 2002; Jihad and Hatred of Jews. The Troubling Link Between Islamism and Nazism at the Root of International Terrorism, Toucan Publishing . The anti-Jewish Muslim hysteria, which we will see as ontological, was even largely underestimated by the Führer – we will pass over the ever-renewed successes since then in Muslim lands of Mein Kampf and the Protocols of the Elders of Zion.
But, whatever these obvious convergences, the Iranian and Saudi regimes present, like Italian fascism, the characteristics of an "incomplete" totalitarianism and in particular the absence of systematic massacres of their own populations. Several factors could explain this. The main one seems to us to reside in the specificity of their economy almost exclusively based on hydrocarbon rents; this permanent and abundant windfall requiring no particular effort could have accompanied the still semi-feudal (or even frankly slave-owning) characteristics of these regions. Thus the penetration of the capitalist mental universe would have been limited, and mainly the multiplier lever represented by the world of the factory, a totalitarian microsociety where the tendentially absolute control of the organization, the maximization of the influence of the machine, the scientific rationalization of the gestures and behaviors of workers are experimented.
Analytical Similarities with Bolshevism
Whatever the case may be with these dying regimes [10], they both seem to have lost significant popular support, reminiscent of the situation in the USSR from the 1960s and 70s onward: the millenarian impulse does not seem able to last beyond a generation. But it would be wrong to conclude that the Islamist experience is alienating populations, since we see Algeria re-Islamizing less than fifteen years after the end of the Black Decade. They seem to have triggered, in turn, a revival of Sunni Islam, and 21st-century Islamism in Nigeria, and from the Maghreb to the Philippines via Afghanistan, appears in a different light. It is with the USSR that a comparison might be most relevant, particularly from the point of view of their conditions of emergence.
Because Germany in the 1920s and 1930s was a society that was "only" disoriented and in crisis, the Nazi party inherited a functioning state and a largely literate, educated, cultured population with a strong sense of identity, allowing it to parasitize society and fully develop the delusion of a "true" totalitarianism [11] Cf. "The Destinies of Totalitarianism," 1983, in Domaines de l'homme, op. cit. The situation was quite different for the Russian Bolsheviks of the same period, whose country was literally devastated and decimated by the First World War, the collapse of the Tsarist state, and the ravages of the civil war. The regime truly had to build a state (modeled on the Party) and, similarly, attempt to establish a society from the top down, equipping it, structuring it, and above all, holding it together by creating from scratch a social bond that transcended particularities. This unique situation of exclusion from any modern heritage, which seems to have given free rein in the USSR to social logics other than "purely" totalitarian ones—we will return to this point—appears to be found in the regimes that emerged from jihadism: the Taliban in Afghanistan and Pakistan, the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria, Boko Haram , and the Caucasus Emirate of Chechnya rule over territories and populations that are ruined, if not devastated, or at least on the verge of being so, and over traditional modes of coexistence that are highly destabilized by the penetration of Western culture and the repeated failures of decolonization. These situations of deep and widespread chaos , at multiple levels, this social dismemberment, seem to be, as for Russia, one of the main springs of the establishment of totalitarian regimes, and above all self-sustaining ones , something of which some jihadist theorists seem to be fully aware [12] Cf. the principles contained in The Administration of Savagery: The Most Critical Stage to Be Passed by the Umma (Idârat at-Tawahhuch: Akhtar marhala satamurru bihâ al-Umma) published in 2004 by Abu Bakr al-Naji, and analyzed in the work of Frantz Glasman “Local Life and Competition of Political Projects in Territories Under the Control of the Opposition, Jihadists and Kurds in Syria”, October 2014, pp. 33-34. The extreme difficulty they inevitably encounter in installing viable equipment, infrastructure and institutions risks further fueling their apocalyptic perspectives, constantly materially supplied by a whole series of rents (geopolitical, geographical…), notably hydrocarbons for ISIS, “gifts from Allah”.
Time will tell whether contemporary Islamism is capable of building a classic or " pure " totalitarian regime on the Nazi model (for example, in Turkey), or whether its motivations will lead it to develop a form closer to the Bolshevik type. We are only at the beginning of its real territorial entrenchment—and this could take unprecedented forms—but already some of its intrinsic characteristics would suggest the latter.
A baroque totalitarianism
Because if contemporary Islamism can be assimilated at first to a totalitarianism, even singular, it possesses "new" particularities, in any case troubling and now familiar.
First, and although this first point still seems uncertain, it does not appear that Islamism exhibits the total , permanent , and passionate mobilization of the masses beyond reason that characterized totalitarian regimes (including Iranian one). Even in the case of the Islamic State , armed jihad remains the domain of professional groups, squadrons, battalions, or at least fanatical recruits, while the general population, not all of whom are enlisted, is assigned only a supporting role in producing and propagating the dogma. [13] Ibid . Gaining the "sympathy of the masses" seems rather pointless. Similarly, one does not observe those sinister "re-education camps"; prisoners appear to be simply eliminated en masse.
It is then, and above all, the status of rationality within Islamist currents. All historical totalitarianisms, as well as their derivatives, were hyper-rationalisms : Nazism claiming to be based on the supposed laws of Nature “revealed” by Charles Darwin, while Marxism-Leninism was founded on those of History “discovered” by Karl Marx. All genuinely and passionately believed in the efficacy of rationality, even if not immediately instrumental, and strove to try to train individuals capable, at the very least , of maintaining and operating complex technologies and societies (which ultimately relied only on a thin technocratic elite inherited from the previous period or imported – exfiltration of Nazi engineers). On the other hand, a merely semi-modern society , such as Arab-Muslim societies [14] The phrase is from H. Redissi, op. cit . and totally possessed by Islam, a religion of medieval obscurantism which loudly proclaims its naive obscurantism, will immediately find itself facing an anthropological impasse , inducing in order to perpetuate a collective schizophrenia already familiar to these circles, and exacerbating it [15] That is to say, producing in series this Nietzschean “man of resentment” which A. Meddeb opportunely pointed out (in La maladie de l'islam , 2002, Points, p. 18-20), at the origin of the totalitarian waves..
The situation is exactly the same with regard to aims: all the totalitarian regimes of the 20th century were hyper-progressivisms that heralded radiant times such as humanity had never known, an unprecedented sophistication of technology, science, knowledge, culture, and art. Islamism offers only a nostalgic return to the prophetic narrative of its "Golden Age" of domination – and seems , as has always been the case, unable to maintain itself without parasitizing or plundering surrounding societies in every way or establishing various rent-seeking situations [16] Cf. L' exception islamique, op. cit . A point already raised in the intellectual sphere by E. Renan . From this point of view, there is an economy of means, or at least a coherence, which we will see is profound: it is no longer a question of claiming to be part of the sparkling Socialism or the glorious Reich in order to better establish industrial slavery, but more serenely of promising Paradise – by creating Hell on Earth.
This crude aspect, ultimately, is amplified tenfold by the barbarity itself (torture, throat-slitting, slavery, systematic rape, pedophilia, etc.). Of course, it had been practiced by totalitarian regimes and often demanded of every new recruit, but the new element is that it is now embraced as such and, above all, staged as a propaganda tool . Brute force, direct violence, and terror become, in themselves, positive values. These are massive and now everyday occurrences that provoke perplexity, paralysis, denial in any ordinary observer—or fascination.
A Outside of the West
It is very difficult, if not impossible, to see at work in these different aspects the collective dynamics characteristic of past totalitarian regimes as they emerged in Europe and Russia. All these signs, along with others that will be discussed later, point to an outside , an elsewhere of the West , and stem from conceptions very external to a modernity, however debilitating, such as it had self-generated since the end of the religious wars [17]. These profound divergences from the Western imagination are a further factor in the misunderstanding of the situation; they often justify the appeal to psychiatric categories to understand phenomena hitherto only observed in individual psychopathies, or lead to asserting the impossibility for the jihadist enterprise to achieve its goals – or even its unreality. We also think of Olivier Roy, a brilliant Islamologist who announced more than 25 years ago the end of political Islam, for whom beheading in the Muslim world can only be inspired by the film Highlander ("The attraction of jihad, a generational nihilism that transcends the Muslim sphere", Le Monde, 26.09.14.).
In reality, as with a growing number of phenomena that have emerged since at least the end of the Second World War and that transcend inherited sociopolitical frameworks, understanding what is at stake requires moving beyond the frameworks of contemporary, strongly Western-centric thought—the totalitarian phenomenon already suggested this. This amounts to reconnecting with long-term history as conceived by all modern thinkers, and which the progressivism common to Hegelian-Marxism and liberalism has permanently frozen. We must therefore break with the certainties of an accumulation of human history moving, stumbling and asymptotically, towards a global society governed by justice and freedom, and thus leave the comfortable shores of Western ethnocentrism in order to consider the existence of other civilizations , past or future, existing or potential.
II – Totalitarianism as imperialism
Most thinkers on totalitarianism have examined it from a Western perspective: Hannah Arendt saw its genesis in the fragmented and desocialized people of mass democracies mired in their contradictions and victims of their own imperialisms; Claude Lefort detected its advent in the emergence of modern societies that did not recognize any authority external to themselves and were therefore susceptible to unlimited self-enslavement; Carl Castoriadis, as we have seen, considered this unleashing of a rational control of society as lying in the invention of merchant capitalism and, above all, industrial capitalism. Each of them rightly wanted to acknowledge the extraordinary novelty of the totalitarian phenomenon while minimizing the weight that the history of each individual culture placed on its own downfall. [18] They recognized this later. Thus C. Castoriadis belatedly admitted that Stalinism did not owe everything to Marxist-Leninist Bolshevik ideology and had to be inscribed in a heavy Tsarist past (Cf. "The Destinies of Totalitarianism", op. cit. p. 260). Or Cl. Lefort, who, after recalling that the latter was "a political system and a culture that had never made room for law" and "a despotic-bureaucratic social formation on which the communist regime was based", insists on "the connection, the interpenetration, of the patterns of institution, of the patterns of socialization, of the patterns of representation characteristic, on the one hand, of Western regimes and, on the other, of regimes which, despite their transformation, remained 'semi-Asian', and on the birth of a new political species from the grafting, one onto the other, of two previous species" ( La complication, retour sur le communisme , Fayard 1999, p. 167-177-250).
Other thinkers, without their theses being incompatible with the previous ones, insisted on the contrary on a certain historical continuity: thus K. Papaioannou saw in the USSR the expression of a Byzantine-Mongol heritage through the destruction of all intermediate social bodies as it had been carried out by Ivan IV known as the Terrible (1547-1584) [19] Sergei Eisenstein was not mistaken in making Ivan the Terrible , released in 1945 .; or K.A. Wittfogel, for whom the Stalinist empire revived an “oriental despotism” posited by K. Marx himself but unexpectedly forgotten by his descendants [20] Respectively K. Papaïoannou, The Genesis of Totalitarianism , 1958, Athens, Imago 1986 [in Greek, not translated] – an echo of which can be discerned in the opening lines of Cold Ideology , 1967 (Encyclopedia of Nuisances, 2009) – and K.A. Wittfogel, Oriental Despotism , translated by Michèle Pouteau, Payot 1977. … Similarly, for Maoist China, one easily finds in the works of an É. Balazs or a J.-F. Billeter the traditional features of a mandarin and literate bureaucracy upon which the most murderous regime the world has known was based [21] Cf. É. Balazs, “The Perpetuation of Bureaucratic Society in China” (1959), in The Celestial Bureaucracy , Gallimard 1968, and J.-F. Billeter, 2000; China Three Times Silent , Allia 2009. More generally, one thinks of the attempts of a Barrington Moore ( The Social Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy , Maspéro 1969) to root the analysis of political regimes in the political and social history of the regions considered.
The anthropological dimension
For if totalitarianism is born from a tabula rasa , it does not arise ex nihilo , from nothingness, but rather, in one way or another, from the remnants of old, traditional, heteronomous societies, all more or less despotic, tyrannical, dictatorial, and authoritarian. This is even more evident from the perspective of the individual.
Thus, it is clear that while Homo sovieticus , the individual shaped by totalitarian society, is of recent origin [22] See its evolution in post-Stalinist Russia in “A New Anthropological Type” in C. Castoriadis; Facing War. Realities , Fayard 1981, p. 242. , it draws upon much older anthropological types , individuals commonly inhabited by ethnocentrism, chauvinism, xenophobia, patriarchy, clanism, expansionism, militarism, but also fatalism, careerism, nepotism, etc. [23] Racism, for example, true racism which postulates an ontological hierarchy of races, is only the scientific rationalization of mentalities and behaviors that are almost universal in the human species, which does not prevent it from itself constituting a new phenomenon . The incorporation of totalitarian culture requires of these personalities both an exacerbation of these character traits and an erasure of the social frameworks in which they had previously expressed themselves so that they could change objects according to the needs of power (to hate today the one whom they adored yesterday – to mobilize against Eurasia , until then an unfailing ally of Oceania in 1984 ), that is to say a suspension, intended to be definitive, of ordinary decency.
To believe that one can bypass the foundational imprint, the shaping imposed by the institution of society, each time unique, on the human psyche, either to fantasize about a new man, or to create an infinitely manipulable uprooted person, is the common horizon of liberalism, cultural leftism and totalitarianism: the permanence of the anthropological type is a given that the thought of the end of the 20th century seems to have entirely evacuated but that the understanding of the world to come urgently requires us to reappropriate.
Restoration of the Caliphate
Similarly, a brief look at the history of Islam clearly shows that what Islamists claim to represent today—whether practices, projects, frameworks of thought, mental reflexes, in short, their worldview—is found to varying degrees in a Muslim heritage shared by nearly a billion people. For the past ten years, we have witnessed explicit attempts to restore the Caliphate , the only way to implement the entirety of Sharia law, that is, a return to the Arab-Muslim Empire as it reigned for nearly a millennium and a half (the fact that it fragmented rapidly from its foundation in 661 until its final collapse in 1924, the end of the Ottoman Empire, only reinforced the fantasy of a unified, unique, and universal entity encompassing the Ummah ). This imperial caliphate reference may seem ludicrous or folkloric, yet it is fundamental to the Muslim mentality. It is even consubstantial with the Muslim religion since, unlike Judaism or Christianity, as we shall see, Islam was born in, through, and for the empire.
To recap: if Islamism can be considered an imperfect, and even very baroque, totalitarianism, perhaps these particularities can be illuminated in light of a historical and cultural dimension which cannot be ignored as it is sealed by a very particular political form, the empire.
Imperial logic
Empire: what are we talking about? Let us once again leave behind Western ethnocentrism, and especially its intellectualized variant, the Marxist vulgate, which sees imperialism only as Western , and turn our attention to the world history of empires. G. Martinez-Gros's work, based on the thought of Ibn Khaldun, offers a very precise analysis of imperial typology [24] G. Martinez-Gros, 2014, A Brief History of Empires. How They Rise, How They Collapse, Seuil, which systematizes and expands upon the theses of the previous work , Ibn Khaldun and the Seven Lives of Islam, Actes Sud 2006, can be summarized in a few key points: first, the establishment of an authoritarian state with universal aspirations, ruling over multicultural populations, divided, stratified, and assigned to production, burdened by taxes and occasionally sacrificed. Second, the absolute monopoly of violence held by an army of mercenaries recruited from the peripheries of the empire, or from its potential internal margins, who gradually integrate into the imperial apparatus through this means, eventually forming a new dynasty. Finally, a geographically expansionist, conquering aim, seeking the annexation of new populations and productive territories while simultaneously enlisting new fighters. This imperial logic , this mechanism brought to light by perhaps the only classical thinker of the Arab-Muslim world comparable to a Tocqueville or a Marx, can be observed in all the great historical groups, from Assyria to the empire of Alexander, from Rome to the China of the Han and then the Tang, from the Umayyads to the Mongols, up to the empire of India.
From the end of the Roman Empire onward, Europe escaped this logic by gradually developing fiefdoms, then autonomous cities, particularly from the 11th century, forming a lastingly polycentric entity at all levels of sovereignty and gradually establishing the incredible power of the people in arms . It is in this context of the impossibility of empire [ 25] The Roman case itself would require study: originally a republic, it transformed into an empire by expanding eastward, that is, into contact with imperial lands. The comparative fate of the future Western Roman Empire and Eastern Roman Empire, resulting from a division begun with the Treaty of Brundisium in 40 AD and constantly subject to disputes, is significant. that one can identify imperial expansions such as the Carolingian Empire, the Holy Roman Empire, the Napoleonic Wars, or various colonial ventures, but none of them ever resulted in fully developed forms capable of unifying irreducible political entities into a single whole [26] Cf. Brève histoire…, op.cit. p. 187 sqq . “And Europe?”, available on the website. Cf. also the texts of Léopold Kohr. distributed over a territory that was itself surprisingly fragmented [27] D. Cosandey, 1997; Le secret de l'Occident , Flammarion 2007, p. 175 sqq ..
Ancient Imperialism under Modern Totalitarianism
Italian fascism or German Nazism, which shattered the framework of the nation-state established in Europe in 1648 by the Treaty of Westphalia, can also be considered as attempts at imperial imposition at the very heart of European modernity, and similarly Bolshevik Russia after several decades of Westernization brutally interrupted [28] On the roots of totalitarianisms in their imperial histories, see "The Shadow of Empire" in M. Gauchet, 2010; The Advent of Democracy T. III Tested by Totalitarianisms (1914-1974) , Gallimard, p. 280 ff. . O. Spengler would undoubtedly speak of historical pseudomorphosis to describe an old cultural matrix expressing itself in contemporary forms.
Totalitarianism then takes on a more precise meaning: far more than the reified expression of traditional autocratic or tyrannical traits equipped by Western rationality, it is the irruption of millennia-old imperial tendencies within a modernity that is foreign to them, but which offers previously unknown means for the deployment of power and domination. While the forms and means are Western in inspiration, the ends and the historical dynamic are imperial. Thus, Claude Lefort, examining the status of Law, a key invention of modernity, in a totalitarian regime, noted that “ there is no reason to conclude that the notion of legality is abolished or has become irrelevant. In the absence of any reference to legality, the system of domination would be unlivable. (…) Strange as it may seem, the investigating commissioners take literally prescriptions which, paradoxically, in their literal interpretation, give rise to arbitrary interpretations. The reign of violence is thus combined with that of formalism.” » [29] The complication, op.cit. p. 218. How can it be shown more clearly that totalitarianism results from the interaction between imperial despotism and the Western world, from the rise of the former in the latter?
The totalitarian phenomenon would therefore be the modern expression of a millennia -old, non-Western imperial logic.
Thus, all analysts of totalitarian systems share the same dismay at such anti-Western characteristics, even in German concentration camps where meticulous efforts were made to destroy that institution so typical of the West: individuality . And, symmetrically, equality, memory, and ultimately, History itself . Hannah Arendt: “ The Western world has, until now, even in its darkest periods, granted the slain enemy the right to be remembered: this was to acknowledge as self-evident the fact that we are all human beings (and only human beings). It is only because Achilles attended Hector’s funeral, because the most despotic governments honored the slain enemy, because the Romans allowed Christians to write their martyrologies, because the Church kept its heretics alive in the memory of humankind, that all was not lost and could never have been.” Concentration camps, by rendering death itself anonymous (…) dispossessed the individual of his own death, proving that henceforth nothing belonged to him and that he belonged to no one ” [30] The Totalitarian System, op. cit. p. 266. . Here we find the historiographical treatment of mass exterminations and great imperial massacres, almost without trace.
Post-Stalinist Russia: A Return to Empire?
The later analyses of C. Castoriadis on the evolution of the Russian regime would tend to support this thesis of an imperial logic at work in the totalitarian phenomenon. In the early 1980s [31] “The Destinies of Totalitarianism,” op. cit. , the author considered that the transformations of the Russian regime since Stalin’s death (1953) were such that a new type of society had emerged: the stratocracy ( stratos : army) . Fragmented by particularisms and nationalisms, Russian society saw the Army constitute itself as a foreign body , independent but decisive in the functioning of the bureaucracy and establishing Force, Brute Force, without any ideological justification, as the ultimate principle of all politics. Here we find typical aspects of an imperial system. Certainly, C. Castoriadis explicitly denies this [32] p. 268-269, but the arguments he puts forward—the interpenetration of the military apparatus with contemporary technology and industry, and the primacy of brute force over all other considerations—can, conversely, be interpreted as imperial elements according to G. Martinez-Gros's approach: the high professionalization of the army and the subordination of ideology to the logic of domination. See, on this last point, C. Castoriadis, 1981; Devant la Guerre. Les réalités , Fayard p. 251. A similar denial is found in Cl. Lefort: “Certainly, the Soviet regime was something other than a final imperial adventure conducted by unprecedented means on a previously unthinkable scale (although the fate of the idea of empire [emphasis added] deserves consideration), but it is rarely observed that the formation of a single world-space provided the resources to conceive (…) total control of human relations under the banner of the One.” The Complication, op. cit ., pp. 249–250 , but perhaps he would have admitted that, himself using the expression “ Russian Empire ” extensively [33], others had noted, as early as the 1930s, that Stalin surpassed his rivals by adopting an imperial logic . and of “ nationalist-imperial imaginary ”, such traits strongly resembled a transitional state, certainly confused and bastardized, of the totalitarian form towards the imperial restoration which has been taking shape more and more precisely within the very Putinist Russian Federation.
From imperial revival to Muslim totalitarianism?
This USSR, born of chaos and forced to invent itself abruptly , but only weakly Westernized, would have reconnected thirty years after its founding with the old imperial logic that had shaped its past. Thus, Stalinist Russia, but also Nazi Germany and Mussolini's Italy, would have been totalitarian regimes tending toward Empire [34]. The advent of democracy, op. cit. H. Arendt herself seems to have vaguely perceived this, but her Marxist influences would have limited her to the semi-colonial empires established belatedly by the West. Cf. G. Fargette, "Review…", below, p. 43, n. 2. The parallel with contemporary Islamism is striking, but the phenomenon seems reversed: Islamism, through the Caliphate, would be an attempt at imperial restoration tending toward totalitarianism . Does it have the means?
Probably not. First, for the reasons already mentioned in the examination of the formation of Bolshevik Russia. Second, because the Muslim world, inherently divided, seems extraordinarily fragmented today: to the eternal Sunni/Shia rivalry is added the absence of a leading state capable of legitimately establishing a civilizational center like the United States, Russia, India, China, or Brazil (neither Turkey, nor Saudi Arabia, nor Egypt, nor Pakistan, nor Indonesia have managed to assert themselves within the Sunni world). Certainly, this fragmentation has always fueled the unifying impulse; the original schism is a mimetic dynamic of radicalization, and at the sub-state level, religious and ethnic homogenization is almost everywhere complete, just as the mosaic of Muslim practices is becoming increasingly aligned with Salafist doctrine. But it is precisely this latter group that rejects modernity even more vehemently than the Muslim Brotherhood or the Wahhabi movement. The Muslim world resembles the heart of medieval Europe, with its imperial nostalgia and fragmentation, more than a true renaissance ( Nahdha ).
The final reason: the era is precisely no longer one of expanding rationality. C. Castoriadis, as always, diagnosed the exhaustion of modernity very early on, in the mid-20th century: the growing insignificance of language and customs, the extinction of socio-historical creativity, the decline of major social and political struggles, the absence of significant innovations even in techno-scientific fields, and, we might add, the decay of capitalist mechanisms in favor of the ancient, short-term pursuit of the sacred ; only the inertia of past centuries still maintains the West at the height of its power. Under these conditions, attempts at imperial establishment are no longer carried out with the power of a radiant modernity, but with the diminished means and lackluster aims of postmodern decline. In other words: with the end of modernity, the era of totalitarianism, this offshoot of imperialism that subverts and appropriates the products of rationality, would have passed. New forms of domination are thus emerging, taking up and hybridizing ancestral logics that are being reawakened, and contemporary Islamism seems to embody the most advanced point of this.
Islam and its “ imperial perfection ” [35] Cf. Brief history…, op.cit . p. 181.
Let us return to the specific examination of Islamism. The specificity of Islam in the history of empires is striking: while all the great civilizations seem to have known only one or more imperial moments (experienced certainly as foundational landmark moments ) “ Islam on the contrary had no other past or other roots than the empire. It was born almost a thousand years after the Roman and Chinese empires, from a conquest so rapid and so complete, associated with a religious transformation so profound, that it annihilated almost all memory of what preceded it, and it established itself as the undisputed model in the genesis of every future Islamic state ” [36] Ibid . p. 184 . Similarly, from the perspective of other monotheistic religions, imperial logic is foreign to Judaism and accidental for Christianity, which inherited the Roman, then Byzantine (and later Russian), Empire only through a slow infiltration of a historical form that will never be recreated. Islam, on the other hand, seems to have succeeded in articulating Bedouin and despotic logics within a single mechanism, in a cycle of renewal of the imperial form.
This analytical framework sheds light on Islamist projects and the difficulties we have encountered in categorizing them: far more than a simple far right or an imperfect totalitarianism, it would ultimately represent an imperial restoration endogenous to Islam and intrinsically Muslim. This restoration would aim to transform itself into totalitarianism, but the current era no longer has the means to do so. What remains is to appropriate, paradoxically, everything that the West has been able to invent in order to serve its will to power and spread anti-Western ideology.
Destroy the West by Western Means
Let us pause to consider this contradiction, which warrants further examination. This movement back to empire is directed against Westernization itself— it is a historical departure from the Western world, like totalitarianism, but by adopting the most instrumental innovations without grasping their fundamental mechanisms . This is glaringly obvious daily: it is the Muslim infiltrator who demands freedom , tolerance , and equality in order to impose obscurantism, supremacism, and authoritarianism in the public sphere—it is, more profoundly, the use of all useful knowledge, science, and technology without being able to understand the movement that created them. This disarming contradiction should not be considered as proof of the impossibility of the Islamization project: it is one of its driving forces, and perhaps even the main driving force, based on a psychopathological double bind which has no other outcome than manic proselytism and Jihad.
And when considering the history of totalitarianism, one cannot help but be struck by this mechanism of turning Western inventions against themselves by totalitarian movements following a line of increasing sophistication. It is Hitlerism that claims to be based on nationalism and socialism in order to destroy both, that is to say, on the one hand, the popular creation of the only territorial framework within which peoples have been able to exercise their sovereignty, and on the other hand, the invention of a horizon of equality and freedom for all. [37] Cf. G. Fargette, “A Constitutive Illusion of the European Union (Forgetting the Tenacious Permanence of Nations),” in the bulletin Le Crépuscule du XXe siècle no. 29-30, March 2015, available on our website . It is obviously Marxism-Leninism, which claimed to be the point of convergence of two or three centuries of workers' movements and emancipation, and which sabotaged them even better than fascism and Nazism combined, across the entire globe. The difference with Islamism, already pointed out, is that the latter's horizon is an exit, at least ostensibly, frank and clear from the West or, more specifically, a refusal to enter it : it no longer even claims a horizon desirable for all humanity and openly displays its religious regression , that is to say, its theocratic aim.
It is precisely the latter that probably represents the most mind-blowing dimension for a mind stuffed with progressivism, to the point of denying its consistency – wrongly. It is this religious aspect, at once the most visible and the most fundamental, and paradoxically the least understood, that we address last.
III – Imperialism, theocracy, millenarianism
It is not difficult to discern the tacitly religious dimension of the functioning of classic totalitarian regimes, despite their distance from traditional beliefs. Many have referred to a veritable secular religion, profoundly monotheistic , a secular millenarianism : a single dogma, a single community, unified territories, an absolute closure of meaning upon itself under the sign of the One . Here again, Marxism-Leninism offers the most striking example of this tendency of all totalitarian regimes toward theocracy , a theocracy of Rationality , even in the very essence of Marxist dogma, which encompassed all the dimensions of a revealed religion with its proletarian chosen people, its communist Parousia, its priests, its temples, its saints, its heresies, its apostates… To assert that Marxism is the fourth monotheism is not merely a metaphor , and is in fact the only valid explanation for its global spread and its improbable survival to this day, in diffuse and degraded but infinitely pervasive forms. Moreover, we find here the ultimate cement that fundamentally binds Islamo-leftism [38] . The formulations of the terrorist Carlos, explaining his shift from Marxism-Leninism to Islamism, are eloquent. See the article "Communism, Revolution, Islamism: The Creed of Ilich Ramirez Sanchez" by Yolène Dilas-Rocherieux, published in the journal Le Débat , no. 128, January 2004, available on our website. – we will return to this.
Reading 20th-century totalitarian regimes as attempts at imperial establishment within a European modernity that was built outside and against the logic of empire, it must also be added that they all tended to constitute themselves as theocratic imperialisms . The verticalization of the scales of sovereignty culminates at its summit in a universal singularity: God. [39] Thus, the “cult of personality,” typical of totalitarian regimes, is interpreted as a diminished form of the worship of a prophet. Cf. Zineb, Destroying Islamic Fascism: Document , Ring, 2016. Here we understand the advantage of Islamism, which, by explicitly asserting itself as such, takes up and reveals this implicit totalitarian aim and, above all, brings it to its culmination in a regime of exhausted modernity, accelerating this exhaustion and precipitating the de-Westernization of the world. To understand how Islam specifically constitutes this royal road, it is necessary to undertake a historical genealogy, necessarily fragmentary and succinct, and go back to the origins of monotheism.
The Mystical Imperialism of the Hebrews
While the idea of a single God seems to have been present in several ancient peoples—Babylonians, Assyrians, or Egyptians—it was obviously among the Hebrew people that it matured over a long period from the 13th to the 5th century BCE, reaching a unique degree of purity and constituting one of humanity's most singular creations of the mind. Yahwistic belief, through Canaanite influences, Assyrian imperial dominations, and, above all, the Babylonian exiles, ultimately gave birth to a fully developed Judaism, resolutely distinct from polytheisms, sealing the Covenant between a chosen people and their God in a sacred place: the Promised Land, the House of Israel housing the Temple in Jerusalem. [40] Cf. J. Bottéro, 1986; Naissance de Dieu. The Bible and the Historian , Gallimard 1992. For a historical approach to the history of the Hebrews based on archaeological discoveries, see The Bible Unearthed by I. Finkelstein & NA Silberman, Gallimard 2002. This radically new relationship to a single, creative, and transcendent divinity, but triply linked to a particular ethnic group, a single Law, and a defined territory, is obviously fraught with tension: “How can we conceive that almost all of creation must forever ignore the identity of its true author and master, and live in complete ignorance of his will? There must be an end of times when this scandal is resolved ” [41] M. Gauchet, 1985; The Disenchantment of the World , Gallimard 2012, p. 227. This is how it clearly asserted itself, probably around the 5th century BC. B.C., and with a certain posterity, the promise of the coming of a Messiah abolishing History, restoring to the world its Unity and purging it of enemies and the unjust in an end of times where “ His sovereignty will extend from one Sea to the other / And from the Euphrates to the ends of the earth ” (Zechariah, 9:9 ff.) [42] Birth of God, op.cit . pp. 157-163. . Thus, “ the imperial logic, in opposition to which monotheism was formed, re-emerges in it, once well established, as its obligatory horizon: universal dominion to the universal God” [ 43] The Disenchantment of the World, op.cit . p. 227. . This messianic eschatology is indeed consubstantial with consistent monotheism, whether believers forget it or fall into quietism, make it an element of inner comfort or engage in holy war to hasten the Apocalypse.
But this messianic Judaism, this “ mystical imperialism ” [44] Ibid . p. 226. , had to renounce the salvation of the world through what remains undoubtedly the worst ordeal of its already thousand-year existence: Greek influence.
Emergence of Hellenistic humanism
The democratic city-states of ancient Greece emerged bloodless from the internal strife of the Peloponnesian War, and the civic virtues that had characterized them for three or four centuries waned. [45] Cf. G. Glotz, 1968, “La cité au déclin” in La cité grecque , Albin Michel. The end of polycentrism, of the people in arms, and of self-government, which radically distinguished them from surrounding societies, marked the establishment of the imperial logic embodied by Alexander the Great, a disciple of Aristotle, and his fantasy of a “universal empire,” which in reality was immediately and permanently fragmented. From 300 BC until the Roman conquest (64 BC), he blended Hellenism with the cultures of the peoples of the Middle East: Persians, Egyptians, Babylonians, Syrians… and Jews. This melting pot of peoples, a true globalization so close to our own in certain aspects, was an extraordinary breeding ground where Greek humanism broke down the barriers between particular identities while profoundly altering itself. Thus, philosophy descended from the heights it had reached, turning almost exclusively towards the increasingly religious aspects of individual morality, the salvation of the soul, and its immortality: amidst the mixing of a multitude of deities and the emergence of new cults, skepticism, cynicism, Epicureanism, and above all Stoicism reigned, followed by philosophical syncretism with a very strong religious dimension, spreading a "philosophical religion" [46] L. Gernet & A. Boulanger, 1932; Le génie grec dans la religion , Albin Michel 1970. whose various tendencies preached in the streets and could not help but strongly challenge traditional beliefs.
Upheaval of Judaism
The Hebrew world, despite its exceptional effort at isolation, could not resist this multicultural melting pot where, in two centuries, Eratosthenes and Archimedes succeeded Euclid (preceding Ptolemy) and where the catapult and ballistic calculations, the Antikythera mechanism and mechanical puppets were invented. Aeschylus and Aristophanes were performed; astronomy, botany and human anatomy became exact sciences while the Lighthouse of Alexandria, its library and its museum shone brightly… Hellenistic Judaism brought together these assimilated individuals, often from the Alexandrian diaspora, who frequented the gymnasium naked, embraced rational speculation, abandoned circumcision, spoke Greek and read the Bible only in translation (the Septuagint ). The latter later incorporated texts under strong Hellenistic influence, such as " Ecclesiastes "; marked as " The Book of Wisdom " by tragic philosophy [47] Cf. Birth of God, op. cit. p. 327 n. 1 ; the " Second Book of Maccabees" where the very Greek notion of creation ex nihilo arises [48] Id . p. 263 n. 1 ; or the famous "Song of Songs" so surprising for the importance given to love ( agape ) and the place of women, an innovation of the Hellenistic world [49] Growing political role of queens, of women of the palace in intellectual life, homage paid in poetry, departure from the women's quarters and entry into schools of instruction, etc. Cf. A. Aymard, 1963, The Orient and Ancient Greece , PUF, pp. 504-505. This “revolution of morals,” paradoxically of Greek origin, seems to have run from Hipparchia the Cynic (4th century BC) to the Neoplatonist scientist Hypatia (355/370 – 415), murdered by Christians. Thinkers such as Aristobulus of Paneas, the pseudo-Aristeas, and later Philo of Alexandria (20 BC to 45 AD), drawing on Posidonius (c. 134 – 51 BC), also contributed to incorporating Platonism and Stoicism into Jewish thought. Sects arose, such as the Essenes, who formed egalitarian ascetic communities open to non-Jews, even as Hellenistic fraternities like the Eranoi or the Thiasoi “ most often brought together men and women, free men and slaves: they therefore no longer admitted social distinctions, because their members rejected all the oppositions that divide and felt themselves to be brothers, united as they were in the worship of the same god whom they had chosen ” [50] P. Lévêque, Art. “Religion” in Dictionnaire de la Grèce Antique (Collectif, Albin Michel, 2000), p. 1147. He adds: “It suffices to change the name of the god in the famous phrase from the Epistle to the Galatians to have the definition of all these communities: ‘There is henceforth neither Jew nor Greek. There are neither slaves nor free men.’” There is no longer male or female. You are all united in Christ Jesus. '
Birth of an original, acosmic Christianity
All this constituted a primitive soup from which emerged in a diffuse manner a new religious spirit which aimed to radically separate the spiritual from the temporal. It seems to borrow its myths and its liturgy from many peoples of the Empire, Egyptian in the first place, and is nourished by the multiple Greek contributions, from the Word (Logos) to the immortality of the Platonic soul, to the divinization of monarchs and heroes (soter : "savior") to the affectionate and very stoic piety of a Cleanthes [51]The Greek genius in religion, op. cit. p. 411. . This new religion in formation resulting from the crossing much less strange than it seems [52]See The Disenchantment of the World, op. cit.. p. 294 sqq. between Jewish revelation and late Greek wisdom was of course proto-Christianity, which was born, grew and truly founded in and through the Hellenistic universe: the first followers, the Nazarenes, were the hellenists like Paul or Stephen, who will form the first and second circle and will massively convert the Greeks of the diaspora; all their writings are in the Greek language (church/church, apostle/apostles, christ/christos, heresy/hairy, etc.) and take up Greek themes and terms. And these are the Christianized Greeks, the Apologists who, later, will defend their faith against Jewish and pagan attacks... This original, primitive Christianity breaks the Jewish alliance between a people, its God, its Law and its place: it frees its own like Moses, by " coming out of the world ", his Kingdom " is not of this world ", he wants to be spiritual and no policy. This new millenarianism is fundamentally acosmic : it therefore unites those for whom Jesus was not to liberate Palestine from the Greco-Roman yoke, but to announce another world by his resurrection. The militant messianism of Judaism, the mystical imperialism of Israel of which he remains the bearer will be concealed by this massive Greek contribution to which we owe what the Christianity of the origins can possibly contain of so little enslaving or even of egalitarian or universal. It is indeed inconvenient for the contemporary believer and attentive reader of gospels to do something other than put on his toga and set off on the trails to announce the Good News of the Resurrection. Paradox of history: it is to this "same" Christianity that helped to pacify the Roman Empire by infiltrating it that we owe, once in power, one of the most important ideological purges and then the establishment of the first real monotheistic theocracy in the Byzantine Empire. Proof that texts, even sacred ones, are of little weight in the face of the millenarian determinisms that monotheisms ontologically carry – at most they require exegesis in the face of the inevitable and massive contradictions and, in the Catholic case, a dedicated exercise of exceptional duplicity in History. Its true castration would come later during the Reformation and then, definitively, during the anti-religious movements that Europe witnessed for four centuries, two moments of reappropriation of the ancient heritage, consequently bringing the cult of Jesus back to its inaugural letter and its practice in the intimate sphere. The millenarian and apocalyptic side of Christianity experienced some resurgences (from the Anabaptists to the Jehovah's Witnesses) but remained incapable of instituting political entities (at least until their Marxist-Leninist metamorphosis).
Millenarian reactions: birth of theocracy
To understand the lineage of Jewish messianism, one must return to the Hellenistic period. Alongside the birth of Christianity through assimilation, the existential crisis provoked by the penetration of late Greek culture into the Hebrew world also engendered its exact opposite: a stubborn rejection and a rigid adherence to dogma. This is exemplified by the famous Maccabean Revolt (175–140 BCE), a liberation struggle against Alexandrian occupation, following the Hebrew model of resistance to subjugation, whose victory is still celebrated in the festival of Hanukkah – but above all, a traditionalist resurgence against the acculturation brought about by Hellenistic Judaism. This initial schism gave rise to a succession of proselytizing sects (Galileans, Sicarii, Zealots) dedicated to the restoration of the Kingdom of Israel—that is, to the continuation of the theocratic project through the expectation of a Messiah who would politically liberate the Temple and the territory of Jerusalem—and, above all , to the establishment and hermetic maintenance of the integrity of the dogma. Terror and clashes with the authorities continued unabated, leading to the First Jewish-Roman War (66-73 CE) and the destruction of the Temple in Jerusalem (70 CE), the riots of Kitos (115-117 CE), and then the Bar Kokhba revolt (132-135 CE), whose Roman repression was devastating and ultimately provoked the famous diaspora . Just as territorial claims signified the preservation of Jewish purity, expulsion from Palestine implied an abandonment of the religion of the Temple and the Priests: rabbinic reform, the majority Judaism of today, through the reinterpretations compiled in the Mishnah and the Talmud, signifies the resignation of the Jewish people, gathered around the synagogues and the rabbis, to not re-establishing a theocracy. Here again, political messianism disappears, apart from a few largely marginal resurgences entirely foreign to any imperial logic. [ 53] The “re-territorialization” that was the creation of the State of Israel remains foreign to this. See below.
The heirs of millenarianism: proto-Islam
The torch seems to have been passed to a post-Christian sect, to which a growing number of contemporary historians attribute a crucial role in the emergence of Islam. [54] See the works of Patricia Crone, Manfred Kropp, Guillaume Dye, Robert M. Kerr, and especially the synthesis by Edouard-Marie Gallez, * Le Messie et son prophète* (2 volumes, Édition de Paris 2005-2010). All of these works have been collected and presented in * Le grand secret de l'islam *, Olaf, 2015, available online. See also the documentary series by G. Mordillat and J. Prieur, * Jésus et l'islam* , December 2015. In opposition to these theses, see also the barrage of criticism presented as a very unconvincing counter-argument in * L'invention de l'islam* by M. Orcel, Perrin 2012 : the Judeo-Nazarenes. Having taken refuge in Syria after the destruction of the Temple and recognizing Jesus as a political prophet humiliated and unjustly put to death by the "infidel Jews," they are said to have continued to nurture the project of reconquering Jerusalem and establishing the Kingdom of God on Earth. They are believed to have participated in the establishment of the short-lived Palmyrene Empire (270-272) of Queen Zenobia, but it was primarily in the 6th century among the newly Christianized Arab tribes, particularly the Quraysh, that religious indoctrination was crowned with success through the invention of a common ancestry (the " Ismailis "). They would have translated their preaching texts from Syriac-Aramaic into Arabic, the lectionaries ( qor'ono/qur'ân , which would give Quran), divided into śûrat (surah) where the figures of Jesus and Mary are omnipresent, while anti-Judaism is systematized and the millenarian project of establishing a terrestrial empire is hammered home: this would be the birth of a proto-Islam, whose first mosques are modeled on the churches of the region and oriented towards Jerusalem (and not Mecca ). The gradual success of this enterprise, thriving once again on the fertile ground of regional chaos created by the incessant and colossal clashes between the Byzantine and Persian empires, ultimately culminated in the capture of Jerusalem around 637. This marked the beginning of a series of lightning conquests that capitalized on the military anarchy caused by a regional geopolitical collapse to annex the entire Middle Eastern region, a zone that provided a lasting geographical advantage as an intermediary between East and West (at least until the discovery of America). The rapid displacement of the Judeo-Nazarenes in favor of the Arabs alone was achieved through historical revisionism and the gradual fabrication of a "new" monotheism capable of competing with Byzantium, Islam, in a mimetic fashion. The late invention (around 680) of the figure of Muhammad, destined in reaction to become obsessive, made it possible to gather and recruit under the patronage of a war leader and to legitimize, structure, and organize the future Umayyad empire by forging the Muslim legend as we know it [55] This historical hypothesis on the origins of the invention of Muslim worship may seem bold: it appears in fact to be rigorously the only one that can explain both the available archaeological, linguistic and textual data and the inexplicable and disturbing familiarity that emanates from Muslim practices as from an attentive (but oh so laborious, and for good reason) reading of the Quran for a subject of vaguely Judeo-Christian culture – which the Muslim improbably prides himself on to establish the transcendence of the Revelation.
Islam is thus the sole civilization that inherited monotheistic messianism, the Quran the historical recipient of the theocratic will, Muslim legend the quintessential embodiment of imperial religion, its radical currents obsessively apocalyptic [56] Cf. J.-P. Filiu, L'Apocalypse dans l'Islam, 2008 , Fayard. ; its religious specificity seems to reside in its immediately theocratic, never reformed millenarianism . Judaism, having had no political foothold for two millennia – contemporary Israel is a secular nation like few others [57] G. Fargette, “En Palestine plus qu'ailleurs s'epesantit le crépuscule du XXe siècle”, in bulletin Le Crépuscule du XXe siècle n°13, March 2005
– only Christianity could compete; but the multiple metamorphoses it has undergone, the continuous exit of religion which continues to operate via the West, notably through the intersection of the Hellenistic foundations of the New Testament and the rediscovery of the rationalism of ancient Greece, seem to prohibit any imperial resurgence, at least in a monotheistic or even religious form, in the medium term – and in the West.
Resumption of a thousand-year-old conflagration?
Contemporary Islam has been reconnecting for over half a century with its congenital millenarianism, its sacred scriptures containing intact apocalyptic and imperial tendencies and awakening them in believers lulled to sleep by centuries of blind faith. [58] It is only through this dynamic of imperial restoration and the need for recruitment from the periphery that one can understand the return to Quranic literalism, to the “possession by the text” that D. Sibony brilliantly analyzes in Islam, phobia, guilt (Odile Jacob, 2014). Review available on our website . Historical conditions today are strikingly similar to those in which Jewish messianic movements developed more than two thousand years ago: whether it be ancient Judaism facing a declining Hellenic culture or contemporary Islam facing the Western world, it is a revealed dogma that is being profoundly and patiently eroded, not by a higher truth or a new prophet, but rather by a civilization for which there can be no more a revealed dogma than a prophet . A.J. Toynbee noted that Islam, having drawn " its inspiration largely from Judaism ," had finally restored the integrity of the territory of the Persian Empire by permanently ridding the Middle East of the foreign irruption that was Alexandrian culture. [59] A.J. Toynbee, 1951; History, an essay in interpretation , Gallimard, p. 25 , carrying this Greek germ so corrosive to all traditionally despotic, imperial and profoundly heteronomous cultures.
We cannot ignore the fact that this age-old struggle is reigniting today, with the West and its Greco-Roman heritage clashing with an Islam pregnant with the messianic, theocratic, and imperial genealogy of which it is the custodian, and for which the mere existence of societies and individuals striving for self-determination, boundless inquiry, and historical creativity is utterly intolerable, demanding either the extermination of a few or apocalypse for all . It would be unwise to push the comparative exercise further, except to note that while Roman civilization ultimately triumphed over apocalyptic Jewish currents, it was a long and arduous process, achieved at the cost of unprecedented devastation of the region, deportations, and typically imperial massacres . Following this same path would spell the end of the West as we know it today, as surely as the incessant capitulations to which its current decline condemns it.
What is certain is that Islamism, this neo-Islam, both as the Muslim extreme right, as a new totalitarianism, as an imperial enterprise with a theocratic aim and as an apocalyptic millenarianism, will prosper where the conditions are favorable to it – devastation. Its growth, its expansion, its development, its transformations will depend first and foremost on its ability to take advantage of the current geopolitical crises and the chaos engendered by the food, health, climate, ecological and, of course, economic, political and cultural crises.
New front lines
The struggle that is ours today must be capable of such historical perspective in order to grasp its own issues – and to understand the external and internal dividing lines.
External factors: if Islam so perfectly embodies theocratic millenarianism, the resurgence of this archaic imperialism [60] G. Fargette, “Renaissance of an Archaic Imperialism,” in bulletin Le Crépuscule du XXe siècle no. 13, March 2005. seems to announce, as we have seen, the return of a non-religious logic of empire on a global scale, and cannot mask it. Quite the contrary: the violent irruption of a theocratic imperialism can only, in every way, embolden the various civilizational tendencies toward domination and render them comparatively acceptable (see Syria today). Rereading Samuel P. Huntington twenty years later (or reading him for the first time!) compels us to acknowledge that we are indeed witnessing the formation of continental entities that each seem to be adopting, with their own particularities, the major imperial features identified by Ibn Khaldun . Russia's now evident expansionist aims, or the hardening of tensions in the Asia-Pacific region around China, are of the same nature as the increasing pacification of European populations, who are even being disarmed of their own capacity to think, while the plundering oligarchy plans community fragmentation on a daily basis.
It is within the West itself that the second front line is located: the ruling oligarchy, freed from the counterweight that social and political struggles had provided for centuries, seems to be reverting to its imperial reflexes, relentlessly exploiting the productive sectors, erasing all common cultural ties, and facilitating unprecedented population movements through mass immigration. This transformation has been taking place for thirty years under the ideological sway of the contemporary “Left” [61] C. Castoriadis, “Illusion et vérité politiques,” in Quelle démocratie?, vol. 2 , éd. du Sandre, pp. 25–39, passage reprinted on our website under the title “L’autogestion de la mystification.” , that is to say, the only Western totalitarian faction to have survived the Second World War. It is now employing the tried-and-tested mechanisms of Marxism-Leninism, the principal one being absolute cynicism in the manipulation of the masses. It is obviously in the militant and/or media-oriented Islamo-leftist fringes that we find the most enlightened discourses on the upcoming earthly realization of the multicultural Paradise, taking up all the tropes of religious millenarianism – with the very Christian guilt-tripping in the name of good feelings added.
This should come as no surprise: Marxism as a dogma, degenerated into a protean leftism, and whose vanguard is today embodied by Islamo-leftism, is indeed the ultimate revival within the West of the messianic enterprise. It confusedly believes it has found in contemporary neo-Islam a substitute for the failure, for it incomprehensible, of its own Marxist-Leninist prophecy and the means to finally put an end to populations that centuries-old Western emancipation movements have made too resistant to domination. It is these people, wherever they are and wherever they come from, it is their behavior, their discernment, their capacity to act that will determine the course of future events.
Common Places
April – August 2016