Observatoire academic ethics
Menu

Jean-Eric Schoettl: “Pap Ndiaye wants to neutralize the Council of Elders of Secularism”

Jean-Eric Schoettl: “Pap Ndiaye wants to neutralize the Council of Elders of Secularism”

Collective

Observers' Tribune

Table of contents

Jean-Eric Schoettl: “Pap Ndiaye wants to neutralize the Council of Elders of Secularism”

Read More On April 11, Pap Ndiaye announced the appointment of five new members to the Council of Wise Men on Secularism (CSL) and promulgated a decree modifying the functioning of this council, created by Jean-Michel Blanquer to promote a universalist vision of secularism, inseparable from the republican tradition. Is this an attempt to let the differentialist wolf into the universalist sheepfold? In any case, Pap Ndiaye appointed political scientist Alain Policar to the Council of Wise Men, a proponent of Anglo-Saxon secularism (an oxymoronic formula if ever there was one): “The emancipatory dimension of secularism, which consists of imposing enlightenment, is not what I defend. Rather, it is an Anglo-Saxon approach that takes into account the notion of tolerance. Tolerating the wearing of a headscarf does not mean approving it.” In an opinion piece, Samuel Paty's sister, Mickaëlle Paty, denounced the arrival of Alain Policar. Constitutional expert Jean-Eric Schoettl resigned from the Council of Wise Men after Pap Ndiaye announced its reform. He denounces the undermining of the Council by a reform that hinders its means of action. Marianne: Why are you resigning from the Council of Wise Men on Secularism? Jean-Eric Schoettl: Under the leadership of its president (Dominique Schnapper), its secretary general (Alain Seksig), and its deputy secretary general (Iannis Roder) – and with the active support of all its members – the Council of Wise Men on Secularism (CSL) has thus far defended a universalist vision of secularism, which is inseparable from the republican tradition. By establishing a “Council of Wise Men on Secularism” alongside him on January 8, 2018, Jean-Michel Blanquer expressed a demand: that the dust no longer be swept under the rug. On the contrary, it was essential to brilliantly reinforce the republican model by providing a systematic response and clear support to teaching staff who were often bewildered (and tempted by self-censorship) in the face of the rise of politico-religious fundamentalism. "The CSL worked to preserve the memory of Samuel Paty."

On April 11, Pap Ndiaye announced the appointment of five new members to the Council of Wise Men on Secularism (CSL) and promulgated a decree modifying the functioning of this council, created by Jean-Michel Blanquer to promote a universalist vision of secularism, inseparable from the republican tradition. Is this a move to let the differentialist wolf into the universalist sheepfold? In any case, Pap Ndiaye appointed political scientist Alain Policar to the Council of Wise Men, a proponent of Anglo-Saxon secularism (an oxymoronic term if ever there was one): “ The emancipatory dimension of secularism, which consists of imposing enlightenment, is not what I defend. Rather, it is an Anglo-Saxon approach that takes into account the notion of tolerance. Tolerating the wearing of a headscarf does not mean approving it.” " In an opinion piece , Samuel Paty's sister, Mickaëlle Paty, denounced the arrival of Alain Policar."

Constitutionalist Jean-Eric Schoettl resigned from the Council of Elders after Pap Ndiaye announced its reform. He denounces the Council being torpedoed by a reform that hinders its means of action.

Marianne: Why are you resigning from the Council of Wise Men on Secularism?

Jean-Eric Schoettl: Under the impetus of its president (Dominique Schnapper), its secretary general (Alain Seksig) and its deputy secretary general (Iannis Roder) – and with the active support of all its members – the Council of Wise Men of Secularism (CSL) has so far defended a universalist vision of secularism, which is inseparable from the republican tradition.

By installing alongside him, on January 8, 2018, a "Council of Wise Men of Secularism", Jean-Michel Blanquer had expressed a demand: that the dust no longer be swept under the carpet. On the contrary, it was necessary to brilliantly strengthen the republican model by providing a systematic response and clear support to teaching staff who are often helpless (and tempted by self-censorship) in the face of the rise of political-religious fundamentalism.

“The CSL worked for the memory of Samuel Paty.”

 

"This post is a summary of information from our information monitoring"

Author

[side_notes]

Right of reply and contributions
Would you like to respond? Submit an opinion piece proposal →

You might also like:

Eulogy of Mr. Aurélien Taché, benefactor of the French language – An admiring account of a work that will be groundbreaking, if not groundbreaking.

There are books that revolutionize thought. Others that revitalize the sciences. Still others that change the course of history. And then there are books that allow their author to appear on television. Let us not disregard this last category: it now constitutes a considerable part of our intellectual life. Mr. Aurélien Taché has just published a book with Fayard entitled *French, an African Language*. This is a discovery for which we cannot praise him enough. We have known for some time that French is spoken in Senegal, Ivory Coast, Congo, and a few other countries. African writers had even dared to use it to compose literary works. But it took a French politician to finally reveal to us the significance of this fact.

Convergence of struggles

Ms. Panot has succeeded in converging a strange struggle she has waged against public health and anti-Semitism! We expect her to use Israel, and therefore all Jews no doubt, to justify the fight against the high cost of living, against the loss of biodiversity, and who knows what else? 
What you have left to read
0 %

Maybe you should subscribe?

Otherwise, it's okay! You can close this window and continue reading.

    Register: