Judith Butler, professor at Berkeley, needs no introduction: renowned creator of "gender theory" (although she denies that it is a theory, which is readily granted to her), she is also a valued reference in postcolonial studies [1] See Judith Butler, "Speaking to the Postcolonial Other", in Johannes Angermuller, Dominique Maingueneau and Ruth Wodak (eds.), The Discourse Studies Reader: Main Currents in Theory and Analysis , Amsterdam, Benjamins, 2014, p. 127-145; Christopher Hutchinson, "Postcolonial thoughts: notes on Judith Butler's performativity: spectacle & realism", Creative Thresholds , 26, 2014; Aret Karademir, "Butler and Heidegger: on the relation between freedom and marginalization", Hypatia , 2014, vol. 29, no. 4, p. 824-839.
However, just a week after the Hamas attack in Israel, she was scheduled to give a lecture at the invitation of the Centre Pompidou, in coordination with the École Normale Supérieure. Her past praise of Hamas had put the Centre Pompidou in a delicate position, so a few days earlier she published an article in the journal AOC entitled "No to Violence ," which ensured her safety. And indeed, Cécile Daumas, in Libération on October 14, under the headline "Judith Butler, of the human race" (sic), could write: "The American philosopher admired by the LGBT+ community refuses to be an icon and continues to think about the present, from non-violence to the vulnerability of lives," adding: "More than 800 people—gay, lesbian, trans, heterosexual, non-binary—came to listen to Judith Butler as if she were a near-oracle."
1/ Let's take a step back. Judith Butler explained in 2006 that "it is extremely important to consider Hamas and Hezbollah as progressive social movements, which are on the left and part of a global left [2] "Judith Butler responds to attack: “I affirm a Judaism that is not associated with state violence”, Mondoweiss , online: <http://mondoweiss.net/2012/08/judith-butler-responds-to-attack-i-affirm-a-judaism-that-is-not-associated-with-state-violence>, August 2012. ". They would even be part of the international revolutionary cause, as Hardt and Negri asserted as early as 2000: “The postmodernity of fundamentalism is recognizable by its rejection of modernity as a weapon of Euro-American hegemony—in this respect, Islamic fundamentalism represents a paradigmatic example [3] Michael Hardt and Antonio Negri, Empire , Cambridge, Mass., Harvard University Press, 2000, p. 149. ” It should be understood that these pro-Iranian postmodernists and these jihadists affiliated with the Muslim Brotherhood were deconstructors, not destroyers; left-wing progressives, not fanatical killers.
2/ In 2014, Butler added a further contribution to deconstruction in his contribution to the book *Deconstructing Zionism* [4] Gianni Vattimo and Michael Marder (eds.), * Deconstructing Zionism *, London and New York, Bloomsbury Academic, 2014. The co-editor of this collection, Gianni Vattimo, an international figure in deconstruction, pedagogically titled it “How to Become an Anti-Zionist” [5] Vattimo and Marder’s introduction (I-XXI) is entitled “If not now, when?”. This title refers here again to a title by Primo Levi ( *Se non ora, quando?* , 1982), and then to the question of Hillel the Elder, whose Pirkei Avot , a tractate of the Mishnah appended to the Talmud, recalls: “If I am not for myself, who will be? But when I am for myself, what am I?” And if not now, when will I do it?” (I, 14). After mentioning Ahmadinejad (then still Prime Minister), he insinuated this: “As for the idea of ‘wiping’ the State of Israel off the map—one of the common themes of the Iranian ‘threat’—it seems not to be completely unreasonable. [6] Ibid ., p. 17. Like Heidegger and, after him, all of deconstruction, Vattimo uses quotation marks virtuously. ” He concluded, in the same mode of euphemistic concession: “Speaking of Israel as an ‘unforgivable sin’ is therefore not so excessive.” With this category of political theology, we find here the theme of the damned, even satanic, Jews. However, if the Jews are in sin [7] See Romans , III, 9-10. If it were the State of Israel and not Jewish sin, why would Vattimo rely on biblical hermeneutics? He interprets the psalms against the Babylonians as a call to murder newborns, a traditional accusation echoed in the Protocols of the Elders of Zion . A state cannot be such: this deconstructed anti-Zionism is therefore merely a cover for the most traditional anti-Semitism.
To turn Jewish tradition against Jews, a “cultural” antisemitism is then developed. For example, Vattimo concludes an insane parody thus: “The precious richness and depth of Jewish tradition is so putrid, a suffocating air from which one must free oneself to avoid shedding blood for Rachel’s grave. […] [8] In Vattimo and Marder, 2014, op. cit. , p. 21. ” He thus returns to Jewish tradition an immemorial attribute of antisemitic propaganda, the stench that reveals the Jews’ complicity with the infernal world. We also better understand why Žižek, another contributor to the same collection, finds that “Hitler did not go far enough [9] Slavoj Žižek, “Why Heidegger Made the Right Step in 1933,” International Journal of Žižek Studies, vol. 1, no. 4, 2007: “Heidegger is ‘great’ not in spite of, but because of his Nazi engagement,” <www.egs.edu/faculty/slavoj-Žižek/articles/why-heidegger-made-the-right-step/> . Deconstruction, as understood by the authors of the Deconstructing Zionism collective , must also eradicate Judaism, in short, complete the “self-annihilation” that Heidegger calls for in relation to the extermination of the Jews [10] See in particular, in GA 97, the postscript by Peter Trawny, p. 524.
3/ At the time of the mass Islamist attacks in November 2017, Judith Butler also distinguished herself with remarks that, strangely enough, cast doubt on the attacks: published in English in Verso , they were translated on November 19, 2017, in Libération , under the title "A Freedom Attacked by the Enemy and Restricted by the State . " After finding the attack "shocking , " Butler casts further doubt on ISIS's claim of responsibility. On the one hand, she writes, "experts were certain they knew who the enemy was even before ISIS claimed responsibility for the attacks": this, as with 9/11, would lend credence to the conspiracy theory. The theme of conspiracy is recurrent in this movement, and for example, the Hamas charter calmly refers to the Protocols of the Elders of Zion , this forgery of the Tsarist police which, in its eyes, is authoritative. [11] In its paragraph 22, it unveils a conspiracy hatched by the Jews who, "with their money," supposedly provoked the French Revolution, the communist revolutions, and the two world wars . Hamas thus presents itself as the instrument of divine justice and, in paragraph 7, invokes a prophecy by Muhammad that "the Day of Judgment will not come" until Muslims have waged total war to eliminate the Jews.
On the other hand, the ISIS communiqué speaks of “perversity,” which, according to Butler, is foreign to Islamic language: “The fact that they chose a rock concert as a target—an ideal place for a massacre, in fact—was explained: this venue hosted ‘idolatry’ and ‘a festival of perversity.’ I wonder how they know the term ‘perversity.’ It seems they have reading material foreign to their field of expertise . ” Professor Butler has undoubtedly inadvertently overlooked surahs 3, 5, 6, 9 (especially verses 49–54), 32, and 59 of the Quran, where perversity is rightly condemned, as is proper in religions that respect themselves.
While the true perpetrators of the massacre thus remain in the shadows, Butler clearly denounces the French state: it is led by a buffoon , it proclaims a state of emergency and infringes upon freedoms [12] In a diffuse style, Butler thus echoes the slogan posted at the time by Tariq Ramadan: “Neither Charlie, nor Paris, but… searchable.” , and it wages a “nationalist war against migrants [13] He pushes nationalism to the point of lexical phobia: “France refuses to say ‘ Islamic State ,’ because that would amount to recognizing its existence as a state. It also insists on keeping the term ‘Daesh,’ thus avoiding introducing an Arabic word into the French language” ( ibid. ) . Finally, Butler goes beyond the French context to pit the victims against each other: “Mourning seems strictly limited to the national framework. The nearly fifty deaths in Beirut the previous day are barely mentioned, and the one hundred and eleven killed in Palestine in recent weeks, or the victims in Ankara, are passed over in silence. [14] See the detailed analyses by Marie Docher, “Judith Butler in Paris, or the Bataclan Impasse,” <https://lmsti.wordpress.com/2015/11/24/judith-butler-a-paris-ou-limpasse-du-bataclan-2/>; and by Sabine Prokhoris, <i> Au bon plaisir des « docteurs graves ». À propos de Judith Butler</i> , Paris, PUF, 2016. For background, see Talal Asad, Wendy Brown, Judith Butler, and Saba Mahmood, <i> La Critique est-elle laïque?</i> Blasphemy, Offense, and Freedom of Expression , translated by Francie Crebs and Franck Lemonde, Lyon, Presses Universitaires de Lyon, 2015. Based on the caricatures of Muhammad, the book is directed against secularism and freedom of expression. The indictment of the West and Western states, the questioning of those who ordered the attacks—all of this exerts pressure on public opinion and can even influence the classification of the crimes.
4/ We are now better able to appreciate AOC 's article about the Hamas attack. The title, "Condemning Violence," sets the tone. Are the perpetrators, intentions, methods, and consequences truly specified? "I want to talk here about violence, present-day violence, and the history of violence, in all its forms."
True, Butler writes, “I condemn the violence of Hamas,” without specifying its purpose (the destruction of the State of Israel), nor its genocidal intent illustrated by the murder of young children, but to move on immediately: “Let’s be clear. The violence committed by Israel against the Palestinians is massive: incessant bombing, murder of people of all ages in their homes and in the streets, torture in Israeli prisons, starvation techniques in Gaza, radical and continuous expropriation of land and housing. And this violence, in all its forms, is committed against a people who are subjected to a colonial regime and apartheid, and who, deprived of a State, are stateless.” In short, she takes up “the Palestinians are forced to live in a state of death, both slow and sudden.”
After recalling "the equal pleurability of all lives [15] The term pleurability is at the center of Butler's latest book on the Covid epidemic: as in her inaugural lecture at the Pompidou center, she transposes it to the ongoing conflict. ", she intends to sow terror by asking "whether Netanyahu's genocidal discourse will materialize through a nuclear option".
In the texts of Butler and his school of thought, the absent words are all the more significant because the present words, such as violence , accumulate in repetition. Among these absent words are: Iran, Qatar, Muslim Brotherhood, Islam, Islamism, and terrorism. Conversely, the word colonial and its derivative colonialism appear ten times, as in "the question of whether the Israeli military yoke on the region constitutes colonialism or racial apartheid," or when it comes to "overthrowing the colonial system. " [16] These terms should not be surprising: they are common on Islamist websites like Oumma.com.
The conclusion deserves special attention: “The world I desire is a world that opposes the normalization of the Israeli colonial regime (…). And yet, some of us must cling fiercely to this hope, and refuse to believe that the structures that exist today will always exist. And for this, we need our poets, our dreamers, our untamed madmen, all those who know how to mobilize” (emphasis added).
What are these mysterious “structures”? Could it be the State of Israel? The pathos about dreamers legitimizes the irrational, that about poets diverts attention, a favorite device of authors like Heidegger and Derrida: but “all those who know” have understood. Who are these untamed madmen? Could they be the “madmen of God”? The wish to destroy Israel remains at the foundation of Hamas’s political theology.
In accordance with the principle that the end does not justify the means, Butler condemns the means, but not the objective, and simply asks "what other means can be used to overthrow the colonial system." Under the guise of condemning violence, Butler thus reiterates her support in principle for Hamas without, moreover, returning to the "left" label that she had previously attributed to it.
It might seem surprising that an "idol" of the LGBT community would support an Islamist movement, given that the fifteen countries that still criminalize homosexuality are all Islamic countries, or Islamist movements like ISIS and Hamas. [17] In 2016, Mahmoud Ishtiwi, a Hamas commander, was tortured and executed for "moral depravity" and homosexuality. The usual sentence is ten years in prison. According to the Israeli LGBT association The Aguda, several thousand gay men from Gaza have sought refuge in Israel, "fearing for their lives." Furthermore, we haven't heard any outrage from post-feminists that in Saudi Arabia "witches" are still beheaded with swords.
Regardless, intersectional ideology already plays a geopolitical role. Post-socialist dictatorships were fighting Islamism, as evidenced by the Russian wars in Afghanistan, then in Chechnya, and recently the Chinese state of siege and repression in Sinkiang. Now, a union that one dares not call sacred is emerging through various rapprochements. On the one hand, the rapprochement between Shiite and Sunni Islamism, as evidenced for example by Iran's political and military support for Hamas; on the other hand, the rapprochement of Islamic countries with post-socialist dictatorships: for example, the BRICS, dominated by Russia and China, will welcome Iran, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates in January 2024. A global bloc of tyrannies is emerging, to attack the rule of law, democracy, human rights, in the name of the fight against an essentialized West, all the more paradoxical as it includes Korea, Japan and Taiwan.
Finally, the bloc of tyrannies finds valuable relays in academic and cultural circles to weaken democratic values from within, as attested by decolonial and intersectional intellectuals, of whom Butler remains an eminent figure.
***
APPENDIX: To contextualize Judith Butler's position, here is a recent anthology that testifies to the support of Hamas from postfeminists and LGBT people:
“Feminist and LGBTQI+ organizations and activists, today we reaffirm our support for the Palestinian people and echo the call made in May 2021 by the Palestinian Feminist Collective: “Palestine is a feminist issue. We affirm life and implore feminists everywhere to speak out, organize, and join the struggle for Palestinian liberation.”
"Figures of anti-racist feminism have spoken out in support of the Palestinian people's struggle, such as Françoise Vergès who described ' on one side a colonial occupation with its systemic violence, its structural racism, its illusion of democracy, the theft of land, torture, on the other a legitimate fight for liberation. Nothing else. '"
“Anti-racist and environmental activist Fatima Ouassak [a figure supported by the Muslim Brotherhood, editor’s note] also took a stand : “ In the war between colonizers and colonized, we must support (without hesitation) the camp of the colonized .”
Feminist journalist Mona Chollet, for her part, expressed shock at the violence of the dehumanization process unleashed against the Palestinians: " It is now clear that they have been (at least in the West) definitively expelled from humanity. This is never, and probably never will be, the time for their right to life, liberty, and security. Their suffering will never be acknowledged. I confess that this realization has given me a tremendous shock ."
"The collective Les Inverti-es published a statement affirming: ' Trans, fags, lesbians support Palestine! The liberation of LGBT+ people depends on the liberation of the Palestinian people. '"
Finally, we must denounce Israel's pinkwashing , which seeks to attract LGBT tourism to satisfy an atavistic taste for profit; in short, "we must loudly and clearly denounce Israel's attempts to portray itself as an ally of women and LGBTI people. Queer researcher Jasbir Puar and Sarah Schulman , a former activist with Act Up New York, have indeed documented Israel's attempts since at least 2005 to reshape its international image ( sic ) by instrumentalizing women's and LGBT rights."
"To end the apartheid regime, it is urgent to defend the prospect of a massive struggle of the entire Palestinian people, alongside workers, youth and women from all countries in the region who are rising up, as we have recently seen in Iran following the murder of Mahsa Amini ."
While the Iranian regime is politically and militarily helping Hamas, the instrumentalization of the death of Mahsa Amini, one of its major crimes, speaks volumes about the cynicism of Islamist "feminists."
François Rastier is an honorary research director at the CNRS. His latest book is: Petite mystique du genre (A Little Mysticism of Gender ), Paris, Intervalles, 2023.