In an opinion piece on RFI, a political scientist named Alain Policar, a member of the Council of Wise Men on Secularism, calls for a tolerant and case-by-case application of the 2004 law on religious signs in schools, in this case the Islamic veil — in other words, its neutralization: a tolerant law on red lights would likewise amount to "abolishing" traffic lights in favor of the largest vehicles, as is done de facto in Egypt or elsewhere.
A few hours after little Samara from Montpellier was beaten into a coma in front of her school — with head trauma — because her hairstyle did not please a veiled girl who called her an unbeliever, was it necessary to commit such cowardice? Which in fact initially referred to the Paris high school whose principal was forced to take early retirement (in French, to resign) following the lie of an illegally veiled student in his own high school.
The Montpellier schoolgirl, Samara, had dared to come to her middle school in La Paillade for a week with dyed hair, which earned her, according to her mother, daily spitting, intended to make her fall into line with the Salafist ranks: discreet and dreary dress at school, veiling again upon leaving and in the street, shapeless dress to hide her supposedly alluring young girl's body, no makeup and no clothing likely to attract the gaze of a man, who is assumed not to know how to calm his predatory instincts in front of a young girl. Samara was "lucky". In front of the French high school in Algiers in 1989, as in some cities in England today, acid was thrown at the naked limbs of young girls with hair and skirts, in order to remind them of the patriarchal law of veiling.
We would have to pay for a plane ticket for our political scientist to go to Tunisia, where - despite occasional Salafization and the appearance of the full veil - he could see that in this Muslim country the majority of women walk around without a veil in public spaces, because Bourguiba's egalitarian law, which Tunisians voted for in 2014 when the new constitution was voted on, imposes an egalitarian order on society. The veil is possible, but it is only worn by the poorest and most religious women; in this country, individual emancipation and social advancement, which are the objectives of a modern republic, involve, in particular, the unveiling and freedom of women. This is no longer the situation in the suburbs of Islam in France, where the patriarchal order of the Muslim Brotherhood and the Salafists reigns, and where thugs enforce it with insults (whore, "qahba") - and I know from my daughters and their friends that these daily insults are poured out well beyond just Muslim women in appearance, according to the very words of these street spitters -, spitting, even head-butting and sweeping, as described by the sociologist Sabrina Medjaber, who already experienced this in a French suburb during her adolescence before the arrival of the 2004 law. That was twenty years ago.
Let our political scientist, who probably doesn't have many pupils or students and who seems to rarely visit neighborhoods where the Islamic veil predominates in public spaces, know that the veil is rarely a choice—whatever official denials—because the populations and cultures he's talking about are, at least in the working classes, bound to a communal and collective life that disregards individual aspirations. On the contrary, it imposes collective norms on them, of which the veil and the control of women's bodies through invisibility, seclusion, marriage, and tolerated or imposed relationships are the categorical imperatives. Let him read or reread * The Harem and the Cousins* , by the anthropologist Germaine Tillion, now a member of the Panthéon, to know who and what he's talking about.
One might have expected a self-proclaimed "secularist" to be utterly dismayed by the grim reality of school life under Islamist control during Ramadan 2024, a situation that clearly provokes some Islamist zealots to overreact, but the opposite is happening. According to him, it's not the most anti-feminist form of patriarchy that should be fought, but rather the republican order itself that needs to be further undermined. History, it seems, serves no purpose after decades of Islamist proselytizing disseminated in the media by provocative young bourgeois women (such as the promoters of Hijab Day at Sciences Po), who sleep soundly in their affluent neighborhoods, or by agents paid by the Qatari dollars that are pouring in—as we have seen even at the highest levels of the European Parliament. The only response from so many Republicans and so many Europeans, weakened by a history they cannot digest, is to further debase our principles, which would be inconsequential if it did not shatter the lives and freedoms of hundreds of thousands of our fellow citizens — assuming that citizens are immune to such cowardice and its effects.
One might have expected that, outraged by such relentless flouting of our laws (last year, there were up to 200 abayas in a single school in the Lyon region, and this year, an average of 6 teachers are threatened daily with improvised weapons), the self-proclaimed "wise man" of secularism would want to protect all minors in France from the Islamic veil, or even all users of public education and university services. But the opposite has happened: since we are having trouble enforcing the law, let's abandon it! Not officially, but with "discernment." Our political scientist clearly hasn't grasped who he's dealing with. Unless, of course, he believes that the patriarchy so despised by our young women should reign supreme over the working classes in the French suburbs. In that case, his place on the Council of Secularism is no longer justified, and the Ministry of National Education—which appointed him to this position—would do itself credit by demanding his resignation. A free-thinking woman in touch with the 21st century would be a more suitable replacement.
Pierre Vermeren, President of the LAIC Scientific Council.