Observatoire academic ethics
Menu

"The discourse of (de)colonial ecology is a total scam"

Illustration for the article "The discourse of (de)colonial ecology is a total scam"

"The discourse of (de)colonial ecology is a total scam"

Table of contents

"The discourse of (de)colonial ecology is a total scam"

Transcript published in May 2021 on the Lieux Communs website , of the Offensive Sonore program broadcast simultaneously on Radio Libertaire . Significant changes have been placed in brackets. To counter contemporary Newspeak , the terms "decolonial" and "indigenist" have been transcribed as "(de)colonial" and "(anti)indigenist" to restore their original meaning – this issue is addressed during the broadcast.

Refer to the resource page "Beware of (de)colonial ecology!" , which is regularly updated, to find the sources of the elements presented here, and many others.

This show was obviously so disliked by the Politburo of Radio Libertaire that it banned Lieux Communs from the airwaves, after having previously suspended "Offensive sonore" for six months (it ceased its activities a year and a half later).

---

Quentin  : In reality, (de)colonial ecology is very simple to understand: it is only the so-called (de)colonial or (anti)indigenist theses, that is to say racialist or communitarian and Islamist, which are applied to the field of ecology. It is quite simple, so you just have to have followed French political life a little bit for the last ten years or so and you can see more or less what it is about. It will obviously require a little more attention but overall the principle is quite clear. So, there has been a rise in power for a few years, particularly for the last two years, since the municipal elections and we will see why, there is a growing affirmation of this ecology in most activist groups, in official ecology too and in universities. All this is a cause for concern because there is both a void on the ecologist side and an increasingly important affirmation on the side of the (de)colonial, (anti)indigenist movement, etc.
We wanted to approach things throughout the conversation around four points: first the actors (1) and then the birth or the way in which this thing was able to assert itself (2), then the theses which are defended which we will discuss a little (3) and finally, if we have time at the end, discuss political ecology as it exists and which makes such infiltration possible (4).

1 – The actors of (de)colonial ecology

So if I start with the actors, we can roughly classify them into four main types of actors, starting with the (de)colonial activists themselves.

(De)colonial and (anti)indigenist activists

We know them, they often wear several hats and for example Fatima Ouassak who had the honor of having an entire article devoted to her in the March issue of "La Décroissance" - an article that can also be found on the internet - where she was given a rather brilliant costume. Maybe you want to talk about it a little, Cyrille?

Cyrille  : She is an indigenous activist, as they say, she was part of the Parti of Inatives of the Rrepublic (PIR) – which was called the Mmovement of Inatives of the Republic at the time – she started her career in that, I don’t know exactly what her role was. Then she created a collective called the Ffront of Meras officially known for campaigning for vegetarian meals in schools. Officially, it was about ecology, but if you dig a little deeper into her interviews, you can see that it's also strongly because she doesn't want her children to eat anything other than lawful. So all this is a bit mixed up with her because she thinks that true halal is not really possible in France, so you have to eat vegetarian. So she will mix these speeches a bit but above all she plays a lot on the ambiguity especially when we see her links, etc. She is, for example, the partner of Youssef Brakni from the "Adama committee" and very involved against "Islamophobia", etc. These are activists who claim to be anti-racist and victims of discrimination, who will put forward religion. This is really what we also find in Fatima Ouassak with this double discourse claiming that Arabs do not have the right to talk about ecology and would be sent back to their religion while she is the one who talks about it constantly... It is a victim discourse that we find in a lot of racialist or Islamist positions that put forward a religious agenda and at the same time when we question we are told that we are being racist so we prevent people from talking about ecology, etc. In reality, she doesn't really talk about ecology: she mainly talks about anti-Muslim "racism" or "Islamophobia", etc. Depending on the interviews, it changes, depending on the context, and we see that her speech is very well-honed, which allows her to be invited to a lot of ecology forums to talk about the link between ecology and "neighborhoods", etc. She then presents herself as an ecologist and then in other forums she will be much more direct...
His collective is Ffront of Mothers, but I know that now she is evolving in groups closer toEcry Éecology Les Vore (EELV).

Quentin : Indeed, she's been a frequent guest at EELV (Europe Ecology – The Greens), speaks at universities, is interviewed by Mediapart , with whom she has close ties, has also appeared on France Culture , been interviewed by Le Monde , and so on. So she really has a significant audience, or, as we say nowadays, a considerable media presence, even though her message, as you rightly pointed out, is very weak. In fact, ecology is a pretext, and we'll see that this is truly the case with all (de)colonial ecology: ecology is a pretext for imposing themes that are completely foreign to it.

R imso : What needs to be clarified for listeners who might not know is that one of the disseminators of these ideas is the publishing house La Découverte , because this woman has published with them, even if her ideas are rather limited. The friend from " La Décroissance " who wrote an article about this woman includes quotes from her book, * The Power of Mothers* (2020) , which was accepted by this major Parisian publisher, La Découverte , no less. They have this fear of alienating themselves from working-class communities that are fighting against police violence in their neighborhoods, etc., because she also has this whole delusional narrative around "our children are being exterminated" and "the power of mothers who protect their children from immigrant backgrounds," "white society is racist," etc. It's her stock-in-trade.

Cyrille : Yes, it's a completely paranoid discourse. I mean, for some listeners who live in the suburbs, she's saying that when you're a mother in the suburbs, you're afraid your child won't come back, that they'll be killed by the police… Frankly, having lived for a long time in rough neighborhoods, you're afraid of other things when you have children than the police… But indeed, in circles like France Culture, this kind of discourse goes down very well. But honestly, it's really bordering on the unhealthy; it's an unbelievable paranoia.

Quentin : There's a good chance she'll be nominated as a candidate for the legislative elections by EELV, so she's still destined for a future – at least until this show…

Cyrille : (Laughs) We can see that the article in La Décroissance has no impact, that we are not going to change things because we are still in a system where as soon as there is criticism of this kind of person, it is necessarily issued by people of the extreme right or Islamophobes, that is to say that no criticism is possible with regard to these personalities.

Quentin  : Of course, there is a very quick closing. I also wanted to talk about a second character: Nabil Ennasri. Now he is another type, he is more calm and he still has a slightly higher intellectual level, he is a real political scientist very close to the Muslim Brotherhood and he has multiple contacts. He is notably at the IESH of Château Chinon which is an Islamist training center, he has written several books and seems to specialize in ecology – so Muslim ecology, Islamic ecology. He also has the right to a fairly large audience: interviewed in Muslim media, of course, but also in Reporterre, where there are several articles by him, notably the day after Islamic attacks to explain that the Muslim religion is ecological, that is the ambition of these articles… He wrote a book Les SSeven major challenges [Essay aimed at the Muslim community in France, Sana éditions, 2014] in which the last of the challenges is devoted entirely to ecology. And then he is co-founder and president of theUnion FFrench of Cconsumers Musulmans (UFCM) with a close friend of Tariq Ramadan and another from the CCIF, so he is really at the heart of the French Islamist nebula. They are in the process of creating a label organic halal since the organic label – it's very recent – ​​cannot be awarded because of ritual slaughter, the animal suffering it involves, so they decided to create an office that allows products to be labeled with their own label. Within the Islamist nebula of the Muslim Brotherhood, we have the development of a theme around ecology that is very strong and which is more than just greenwashing, which is really a constant concern.

Cyrille : It's sincere.

Quentin : In any case , it's very strategic, it's not just a passing phase, it's something that's likely to last. The other players, we know them a little better, are Danielle Obono from La France Insoumise ( LFI ) or Esther Benbassa from EELV, who are also invited quite often to gatherings of environmental activists, in which they systematically force the link between ecology and their own concerns, which are racism, discrimination, immigrant neighborhoods, etc.

Environmental activists

The second category is that of environmental activists as we know them. We've seen (anti-)indigenist and Islamist activists, but environmental activists are very receptive to all these themes because, as we said at the beginning of the program, the (anti-)indigenist and Islamist circles are relatively small sociologically speaking, but there's a rather extraordinary receptiveness among the most motivated activists, those on the left, from EELV (Europe Ecology – The Greens), or others who are a bit more radical. In particular, I'm thinking of Génération Climat, which held a demonstration a year ago during the summer alongside the "Adama Committee"—the Adama mafia—as did the Alternatiba collective . There's also PEPS, the Party for a Popular and Social Ecology , which really gives a lot of visibility and platforms to all indigenous and Islamist discourses. There's also Reporterre , which is more surprising, but Hervé Kempf's online journal, which is excellent in itself, really acts as an echo chamber for all these (anti-)indigenist and racialist environmentalist pronouncements. They too are chasing after the people and find in these pronouncements the impression of connecting with the reality of ordinary people. Extinction Rebellion , too , is becoming very receptive to these discourses.

Official ecology

Thirdly, I would put the official environmentalists. We've seen EELV (Europe Ecology – The Greens), all the municipalities they won in 2019, implementing very conciliatory policies towards Islamists, (anti-)indigenists, and community activists. And they are also invited quite regularly to summer schools, to appear in magazines, for interviews, etc. We've also recently seen Greta Thunberg, the prophetess of young environmentalists, assert that the cause of ecological damage is that we live in a colonial, racist, and paternalistic world – so she absolutely endorsed the tenets of (de)colonial ecology. All this is also starting to resonate in the columns of Le Monde , the evening daily, and shows that (de)colonial ecology is not simply a delusion of a few radical activists but that it responds to something and in particular, in my opinion, to a great void on the part of the "ecology" institution.

Rimso : In the sphere of activists and the environmental press, there's also the long-established monthly magazine S! lence, through some of its writers who have been receptive to this, to all these ideologies—you could call it "Woke culture , " this ideology that seeks to defend the cause of minorities. They're open to these issues and have already dedicated an entire issue to them, and these are truly historic publications. When young people come along, they try to be as "clean" as possible and create a kind of leftist ideology where they're supposed to fight all the forms of oppression suffered by minorities. Why not? But in this case, we'll see later in the program that the discourse isn't necessarily very good.

Cyrille : I'd like to come back to Alternatiba . S ! lence is a mail-order magazine with a fairly large readership among environmentalists, but Alternatiba is more of an organized forum, a kind of catch-all fair. So I think that some (de)colonialists who came and proposed this, it was accepted, like a lot of articles on alternative medicine, on Esperanto, on things, topics that aren't necessarily political ecology but that will be accepted. It's backboneless, and since political ecology is so weak, it can't necessarily see the limits, and they accept pretty much everything; everything will be accepted in this type of organization or magazine. This is to put things into perspective a bit…

R imso : I think there's definitely a real conflict. For S ! lence, it's an editor on the editorial board like Guillaume Gamblin who's fully committed to pushing these issues, unlike other magazines like "La Décroissance" where their journalists and editors have published some very interesting things in recent weeks, but they're being vilified. And when you see the reactions if you do a little research online regarding the latest articles from La Décroissance, it's not going down well. So there are definitely differences within the media outlets.

Cyrille : Yes, of course. For example , "La Décroissance" has a fairly clear editorial line: you read a few issues of the journal, you understand what kind of idea you're dealing with, but if you go to an Alternatiba-type demonstration , you can come across various things, for example homeopathy and next to it you'll find very Islamo-leftist things, next to it you'll find a very different stand… In fact, it's a bit of a catch-all where ecological and decolonial type organizations can integrate very easily.

The academic and publishing world

Quentin  : After the (de)colonial activists, the green activists and official ecology, I would talk about the academic and publishing world. We talked about it a little with some editions LaDdiscovery who notably publish two authors who have left their mark on me: Pierre Charbonnier,Abondage and Freedom [2019] which is very painful to read, very academic, a lot of boring references and which, in conclusion, endorses the drift towards (de)colonial ecology under the pretext – we will talk about it again – of getting out of the dichotomy between humans and nature, of opening up to other cultures, to other views of the world, etc., of breaking the Western worldview. And R. Keucheyan who wrote La Nature is a the land of fight I believe [LNature is a battlefield (2014)], where he states that the victims of environmental damage are only "racialized people"... This really goes in the direction of decolonial discourse. And then on the side of the Threshold, which is still an extremely important institution, we have the collection "Anthropocene" directed by Christophe Bonneuil who himself has a very (de)colonial inclination. Last year he published Malcom Ferdinand AÉdecolonial ecology, a book that has had a huge impact in the press – the activist press, the official press, the environmentalist press – and which is a sort of breviary of (de)colonial ecology with the underlying principle that ecological problems are solely due to the West and more precisely were born with colonization.
This is roughly the theme and the theses that are defended in this academic and editorial world – academic because the latter, Mr. Ferdinand is a research director at the CNRS and P. Charbonnier too [R. Keucheyan too]. So here we see that the movement of “(de)colonial” ecology, in quotation marks – we will discuss the terms, I think – is still something that has a relative importance and all this dates back [roughly] three years, so it is still quite significant growth. It is not simply a small group, it goes from EELV to Mwhere visit us at the Seuil, La Ddiscovery, etc.

Rimso : To make it concrete for the listeners, the problem is that all these people are recoding social criticism on purely ethnic things, and that's what's causing problems and creating dead ends in thinking.

Cyrille : Perhaps we can move on to the "genesis" part of (de)colonial ecology?

2 – The genesis of (de)colonial ecology

Quentin : It will be quick, I had just noted a few points to explain the temporality as they say.

The 2019 municipal elections and the decline of the left

Quite clearly there is a starting point which is 2019: most of the web pages, most of the issues of magazines, most of the conferences, remarks, etc. date from 2019, more rarely before. 2019 is obviously the municipal elections where it is EELV which has a relative success – relative because essentially due to abstention – and sweeps most of the big cities of France. From there a call for air is created, because EELV is an essentially empty apparatus, it has always been a stepping stone for the oligarchs, and we see, moreover, there, week after week the affairs in all the town halls led by the Greens, the completely stupid or at best clumsy remarks of the municipal councils or mayors, it is quite catastrophic. And this void is obviously a breath of fresh air, it attracts all the people who are fascinated by power and this is obviously the case for (anti)indigenous people, Islamists, racialists. In any case, that is one explanation.

Cyrille : Isn't this the same kind of surge in support that occurred when La République En Marche (LREM) emerged? Isn't it the same sort of thing?

Quentin : If that's absolutely it. The same goes for LFI; a few years ago, they were a huge success, everyone rushed there. In fact, I get the impression that it's a movement that's somewhat unconsciously employing a scorched-earth strategy: wherever they go, they destroy what they invest in. We see it very clearly with Jean-Luc Mélenchon's LFI: it wasn't exactly brilliant to begin with – it's very watered-down leftism – but now they're sinking, sabotaging themselves by making statements worthy of the Indigènes de la République movement of 2005. The left has been burned , and now it's the environmental movement's turn, in a way…

Cyrille : So you analyze this more as an infiltration than as a transformation of EELV, or rather of the ecologists themselves?

The ecological void in the face of the rise of (anti)indigenism

Quentin  : I think there are both. Because here I spoke of a reason that was quite circumstantial but more fundamentally there is a rise in power, I said it in the introduction, of (anti)indigenist and Islamist movements. It is obvious: there is a radicalization of discourse, radicalization of activists, there is also a demographic increase – so it is also mathematical –, there is the situation which is deteriorating in the suburbs. There is really a surge of something with, in the background, what is happening in the United States, so a real dynamic in progress. And on the side of the ecologists it is exactly the opposite: we are in inertia. On the side of ecology, basically, for 40 years, there is nothing new. Neither socially; there is no real popular base, we know that the electoral base of the ecologists is the urban bobos of the big metropolises, in large part, while ecological concerns interest many more people, but in electoral terms it is very very poor. In political terms, it is a disaster: there is no real project for society on the side of the ecologists, there are developments, there are reforms to be made, etc. but there is no global vision, no real project for society. And intellectually, it is completely useless: there is no real progress, when we see the substance of the doctrine, everything was said in the 1970s, basically, there is really nothing new since. And this inertia of the Greens is facing an environmental catastrophe - and social catastrophe for that matter - which is deepening.
So the inertia of the greens in the face of an (anti)indigenist and (de)colonial dynamic: this encounter is therefore not only infiltration, it is, I think, a metamorphosis, like the extreme left has become entirely racialist in ten years: between 2010 when the discourse was very marginal and today, we see that the entire left has converted to this discourse. I think that is what is happening on the side of the ecologists.

Rimso : I would also like to clarify that for the left, we have to go back to the anti-globalization movement, the European Social Forums where Mr. Tariq Ramadan was invited and received little criticism—a few people disrupted the conferences—they had managed to infiltrate it. Then, around 2003, there was also the second Iraq War, where certain alliances of anti-war committees in England and also in France were not very clear in their support for fighting the "evil Americans." So these are also bridges that existed and which, later, were perhaps formalized because activists formed somewhat larger groups, like the Indigènes de la République (Natives of the Republic) , to gain influence.

Cyrille : That era was the era of Socialism Par En Bas, which was really linked to Trotskyist groups that had, at least theoretically , called for an alliance between Islamists and leftists. And in their group, you find people like Danielle Obono, people who are now found in these movements. So it's true that it goes back a long way.

Quentin : You're absolutely right to point that out, Rimso: given that environmentalists are essentially left-wing or leftist, they've co-opted all this Islamo-leftism. It's a kind of reciprocal exchange. All the Islamo-leftism that really developed between 2000 and today is now passing into the environmental movement. We also remember José Bové going to Gaza: there was also, within the environmental movement at that time, a tendency towards Islamism, the proto-indigenist movement that was brewing, and so on. There were anti-Western, anti-modern, anti-European rhetoric, etc. It's fertile ground on which indigenous discourse can obviously only flourish.

3 – The theses of (de)colonial ecology

Cyrille : We could perhaps delve directly into the tenets of (de)colonial ecology, because we're circling around them, but we haven't yet defined them. Here you're talking more about what we call Third-Worldism: when we were discussing support for Palestine, it's often pretty much the same movements that are part of Third-Worldism. The basic idea is really to hope that Third-World countries will rebel against the "evil West" that continues colonization through neo-colonialism—we can indeed agree with some of their observations, but it's more the way they instrumentalize Third-World countries by mythologizing struggles, particularly the Palestinian one, that can cause disagreements. When you're a revolutionary and a libertarian, for example, you can't be a Third-Worldist; for me, it's contradictory. How can that be mixed up, for example, with (de)colonial ecology?

(De)colonial ecology is a betrayal of anti-colonialism

Quentin : I think we need to go a little further. In reality, ecology has been decolonial from the very beginning , in the truest sense of the word. From the start, the environmental movement has campaigned for decolonization because political ecology is about finding harmony between a society and its environment—a natural environment in the broadest sense, an ecosystem, a milieu—and this is only possible if there is self-determination on the part of the people. It's not possible for a people dominated by another, exploited, without their own practices, forced to achieve a certain level of productivity, forced to submit to land development projects, and so on. So, from the beginning, there was a very strong critique of colonization and a hope placed in decolonization: the idea—I'm talking about the 1960s and 70s—was that the newly decolonized nations would manage to find a different path to development than the Western one. So there is a truth in (de)colonial ecology, but ecology has always been so, at least in recent history it has been decolonial, immediately.

Cyrille : There's a difference between being against colonization and being (de)colonial…

(De)colonial ecology is colonial and consumerist

Quentin  : So, here we come, in my opinion, to the heart of the matter, that is to say that we are in thearnwater of (de)colonial ecology. For all the people we talked about here, for all these movements, we are not talking about ecology or decolonization. Fatima Ouassak doesn't give a damn about ecology, she doesn't care about it, Nabil Ennasri doesn't either, I think, deep down he doesn't care about it: it is not a question for them of reducing consumption [or demography], it is not a question of reorganizing societies with a view to sobriety, nor of direct democracy, that seems quite clear to me. And above all it is not decolonial in the sense that decolonizations have already taken place. This is something that is valid for the entire (de)colonial, (anti)indigenist, racialist, etc. movement. These countries have been independent for at least half a century, Algeria has been independent for 60 years – this is something that we never hear. If there is an ecology to be done from an Algerian point of view, it is to be done en AAlgeriaIt is in Algeria or in other decolonized countries that we must succeed in reorienting development towards something other than the environmental devastation that we know and this is not at all, obviously, the direction that the decolonized countries are taking and especially not Algeria.
So there is a scam which is total: the (de)colonial ecologists, its activists, are consumerists and Colons. Because if we go back to the meaning of the words, an indigenous person is someone who lives in the country of his ancestors. We are the indigenous people, we are the indigenous people. This was already pointed out in 2005 with the call for Inatives of theRrepublic, The contradiction had been formulated in particular by JC Michéa who had written a page on it which was very clear and it was absolutely obvious. A native is therefore someone who lives in the country of his ancestors and a colonist is someone who comes to a foreign country and wants to impose his culture there. So we have here attitudes which are not decolonial but colonial and an absolute inversion of the meaning of words, which we see everywhere; pseudo-anti-racists like Houria Bouteldja, etc., we are realizing, finally the general public is realizing, that these are racist – said racialists but they are racist. The (anti)indigenous are not indigenous, the (de)colonials are not decolonial. In fact, they are people who are driven – one could discuss the reasons – by a clothes from the West, it is beginning to be known and also, now, white people. And ecology is in fact a pretext to infiltrate the environment and, in fact, destroy the discourse, destroy the institution.

Daman : Don't the (de)colonials respond to this by saying that there was no real decolonization and that, due to geopolitical and economic interests, France, for example, has retained a certain world of interests and plays on the internal politics of decolonized African countries, and that, as a result, many people had no choice but to emigrate to France?

(De)colonial ecology is a crazy discourse

Quentin : You're absolutely right, that's their standard response. But if you look at it closely, it doesn't hold water for a second—I'm referring to a text on Common Places , " Immigration, Ecology, and Degrowth ," where I discuss this very issue. If Algeria, taking Algeria as an example, isn't truly independent, it needs to become so. Therefore, Algerians need to free themselves from France—but they won't do that in France. If an Ivorian in Ivory Coast considers Ivory Coast to still be France's property, Ivory Coast must finally become independent. Therefore, Ivorians need to fight in Ivory Coast to reclaim their country, not come to France and make money; that's not consistent. Or, another possibility is that these are people who immigrated here to sabotage France so that it collapses and their country can regain its independence – but in that case, they're caught in a contradiction: if they're here as "anti-France" activists, in quotation marks, they can't complain about racism, it's impossible. Deep down, I think this talk of (anti)indigenism, (de)colonialism, etc., is madness , it's the rhetoric of lunatics , it's completely insane: if you want your country to be independent, you have to stay in your country and fight for its independence, there are no other options. During the German occupation, the French didn't go to Germany to liberate France – it doesn't make sense, it's absurd. If you look at the 2011 revolution in Tunisia, it was Tunisians in Tunisia who made the revolution, not Tunisians in France. If you look at the Hirak movement in Algeria today, it's Algerians in Algeria who are making the Hirak , not Algerians in France.

Rimso : These are complicated questions. Since we were talking about Ivory Coast, when some presidents really wanted to oppose things like the CFA franc, or things like that, they were eliminated, but it's true that the struggle is happening there. Especially since the French, or others—it's not necessarily them, if you make this dichotomy of Whites/non-Whites, West/non-Western—are the ones ruining Africa today. There's a whiff of Françafrique, just as there's Chinese capitalism seizing ports and land all over the place. Regarding Whites/non-Whites, we can also cite the countries that emit the most CO2 per capita: they're the Persian Gulf countries. So there's also something else: this West, these Whites who dominate the world and enslave on an ecological level, that only half holds water if we really look at these purely ecological issues.

(De)colonial ecology is fascinated by the West

Quentin  : You're right, it's obvious that when we talk about colonization, it's completely crazy to talk about colonizing France when that's the attitude we see today from Turkey, China or Russia, which is never mentioned. Tibet is never mentioned, it's not ? question of Tibet in France whereas when I was an activist, twenty years ago, there were still movements for the liberation of Tibet – we don't hear about it at all anymore so it's a process of colonization. We hear about the Uighurs, obviously since they are Muslims so that pleases a lot of people. There is a focus on the West, only. This is a bias that is completely crazy within the (de)colonial discourse and that makes no sense.
Houria Bouteldja's speeches are as if she were nostalgic for the colonial era, as if she had come here to place herself exactly in the situation of the colonized. But in Algeria people are not colonized and if there is an ecology to develop in Algeria it is to develop en AAlgeria. All the agroecology experiments that are taking place in the Maghreb, for example, are being carried out by people from the Maghreb and who are there – I am thinking of Tunisia where there are many initiatives that are trying to reform the rural world and it is a long-term job, a day-to-day job, it is a job that requires strong local involvement and it is not from France that we are going to do it. In the radical sense, political ecology is the search for adequacy between a society and its environment and from this point of view, the discourse of (de)colonial ecology has not no senses

Cyrille : We can also question the terminology because, in fact, there was an "anti-colonialism" movement until the 1960s, during the actual decolonization processes that were taking place; it wasn't over yet. Then there was the "decolonial" movement, which, if you look into it, comes from Latin America. The PIR (Party of the Indigenous of the Republic) often refers to the European invasion of Latin America, but they forget the Ottoman Empire, etc. They idealize a perfect world and only see the arrival of the white man who massacres, colonizes, etc. So we're dealing with a completely delusional myth, and that's obvious. That's what you were saying, Rimso, about the petro-monarchies that pollute enormously. There's also Greta Thunberg's view that white men are the bad guys, as if by removing white men we would eliminate everything that's a problem, the pollution, etc.

(De)colonial ecology is blind to the non-West

Rimso : There are some very important things to say on this. In Mr. Raoul Anvélot's latest article in "La Décroissance" (Degrowth), he states that colonization is primarily capitalist and technological, and a consequence of industrial society. Who, in our part of the world, benefited from colonization and its economic advantages? It wasn't necessarily the average French citizen initially—indirectly, yes, but it was a colonization from which capitalists benefited, and not just French capitalists; in Africa, there was also the Lebanese bourgeoisie. In our part of the world, there was a colonization that decimated the entire peasant class and which, therefore, continues to wreak havoc today ecologically due to our lifestyle in France. Currently, yes, we benefit as a developed country with nuclear weapons, a power that is better positioned in the markets. One could say that all French citizens, whether they are (de)colonial activists or ourselves, benefit from our privileged position in global consumption, regardless of the differences in society, the gap with the wealthiest. It is they who can consume more and are the most protected from certain forms of pollution, but…

Quentin : …although [European] nuclear waste is buried in France…

Cyrille : There are still some third-world countries that are used as dumping grounds, at least that's what people say, I don't know if it's true…

Quentin : That's absolutely true, but it's a question of social class on a global scale; it's obvious that it's generally the poorest classes who bear the brunt of industrial society's waste, that's absolutely obvious, but in every country and at every level. If there is indeed an oligarchy here, it's absolutely obscene in the Emirates, obscene in Russia, in China, etc. There's an ethnocentrism in the discourse that betrays this fascination with the West, and it's typically the discourse of a colonized person for whom the West is responsible for everything, owes everything, and can do everything, as if, ultimately, the West were going to solve ecological problems or as if simply overthrowing the West would make everything better. Obviously, that's not it at all, not at all… If we really want to discuss consumerism, it's obvious that the developed countries that China, Russia, India, Brazil, etc., are now... They are over-consumers – and the West in particular, but let's be clear: this is a prospect that is unfortunately desired by most of the world's population, especially immigrants. When people immigrate, particularly to the West, to Europe, and to France, it's to improve their standard of living: they don't immigrate to France to experience degrowth. And, very strangely, degrowth is never mentioned in the context of (de)colonial ecology, which is not surprising at all: they are the hypocrites of the environmental movement.

Cyrille : There are still groups that are degrowth and (de)colonial, they do exist… Well, small groups, maybe it's just one person behind a website…

Quentin : I did see a Twitter account, but it was completely incoherent, all over the place, supporting "Adama" and degrowth... But you only have to take a walk around the housing projects where many of us come from: the consumption there is ostentatious, it's quite obscene. If you don't measure up in terms of clothes or smartphones, etc., or if you don't have the ambition conveyed and glorified in rap videos with a nice car, girls, and money, you're nothing, you don't exist. That's what we need to talk about: this "popular" culture, in quotes, the "immigrant" culture, which is a culture of social climbers, a culture of upstarts that doesn't correspond at all to the claims of (de)colonial ecology.

(De)colonial ecology despises the working classes

Cyrille : That's a real difference between, precisely, the " bourgeois bohemians" of city centers, who, perhaps for some, mostly focus on appearances but tend towards genuine environmentalism, cycling, etc., and the suburbs, who indeed have completely different desires. This is also the case for the working class in general; they dream more of supermarkets and consumption than of degrowth.

Rimso : This raises the question of a place that gives you value in society, what symbolic place you have in society. It's easier for an urban man or woman with a good job, cultural capital, which is valued and which is valued by others, to make thoughtful choices in terms of ecology and lifestyles or places of ethical consumption and all that, than when you are in relegated areas where the only thing that makes you visible is having a very nice car, whether you are a farmer's son, a suburbanite's son or a factory worker.

Quentin : Yes, but that's a bit simplistic because you're saying that when you're poor, you can only desire to be rich. We're on Radio Libertaire, after all , and we have behind us two centuries of workers' movements that were more than just a movement of poor people wanting to become rich. It was a movement of very poor people, much poorer than most of today's suburbs—excuse me: than all French suburbs today. They were slums back then, and the workers' movement established a vision of social equality, and didn't just imagine it, it implemented it: mutual aid societies, the principle of pooling resources, the principle of pensions, the principle of social security, they created workers' cooperatives and they invented self-management, municipal libraries; that was the workers' movement, it's nothing like what we see in the suburbs today. So to say that degrowth is a movement of privileged rich people is partly true, but we cannot symmetrically say that it is impossible when one is poor, that is not historically true and it leads nowhere because it means that we will only be able to truly degrowth when everyone is rich – which is a contradiction in terms.

Cyrille : I think the bourgeois - bohemian culture of city centers is not declining…

Quentin : I completely agree with you: it's also hypocrisy, it's all about appearances, it's, as Bourdieu said, a form of social distinction, it's a way of not resembling the masses and of standing above them. I totally agree with that.

Cyrille : To paraphrase Rimso: it's sexy and chic in rich neighborhoods to have ripped jeans, it's much less chic in poor neighborhoods where people can have ripped jeans, but not for style…

Quentin : In reality, environmental circles are only susceptible to all this nonsense because they're not actually in touch with the general population. There's a disconnect between the environmental discourse that exists today and the reality of people, especially the French people. You said that rural France, the Yellow Vests, crave consumerism, and you're partly right, but in this case, I think they also have a fairly close connection with nature. It's astonishing that we live in a society that talks so much about ecology and is destroying the farming community, in particular. Farmers are the segment of the population most in contact with nature—farmers, hunters, fishermen, groundskeepers, foresters, etc.—all these people are in very direct contact with the natural world but are excluded from the environmental discourse, electorally, sociologically, and intellectually. There's something on this that we really need to delve into, and it leads me to believe that environmentalism as it exists in France today is entirely ideological; it's an " ecologis me ," a virtual construct that has nothing to do with the fundamental aspirations of the people. I'm not saying the Yellow Vests are for degrowth—that's very clear, we've done programs on it, and it's one of the criticisms I would make of this movement, it's absolutely obvious: it's attached to a certain standard of living [ 1 ]. But it also contributes to the overall evolution of a society in which they no longer recognize themselves at all, particularly the fact that the emphasis is placed on the "poor," in quotation marks, of the suburbs, the "poor," in quotation marks, immigrants, etc., and all this (de)colonial discourse in which we are immersed and which is very tiresome. The Yellow Vests movement was also a reaction to this, and I think that the environmentalists missed an opportunity at that time to reconnect with the people, and to compensate for this, I'll end on this point, well, they are opening the doors wide to (de)colonialists and (anti)indigenists who claim to represent working-class neighborhoods…

Cyrille : It was a bit complicated for the environmentalists because it was ultimately a tax supposedly for the environment that triggered the movement. That's what we said at the time: it was as if they were being blamed by being told, "It's your fault." Most of the Yellow Vests are quite poor, and they were being taxed on top of that, being told that environmental issues are partly their fault, so they're going to pay more for fuel.

Quentin : That ecology is becoming a discourse of social domination and with (de)colonial and (anti)indigenous ecology, an ethnic and religious domination, that's really what I see, as plain as day, coming at us.

4 – The errors of contemporary political ecology

Rimso : I would like us to ask the question of the end of the peasantry because currently there are no more peasants, those who are in the countryside, there is a whole imaginary to recreate about the peasantry. All of this involves the exploitation of workers in the industrial distribution chain of adulterated food, with all the associated negative impacts. It's mostly very large farms that are doing quite well, or big bosses who exploit workers, sometimes and even often immigrants – and during Covid, we see the bosses crying that they won't be able to harvest and that the fruit will rot on the trees because they no longer have cheap labor from Eastern Europe or North Africa… In short, it's complicated. We're in a society where a whole segment of the population is being exploited, creating ecological imbalances and enormous pollution. And we've somewhat lost sight of the concept of the imagination we were talking about earlier, the consumerism, whether in the suburbs or even in the most remote areas, the dream of tuning cars or luxury vehicles, etc., and it's very, very, very present, unfortunately.

Disconnection from the people and their nature

Quentin: You're right, Rimso, the countryside is almost completely industrialized, but there are still a little over half a million farmers today, and many of them are still trying to make it a human endeavor with genuine relationships to animals, species, livestock systems, agricultural systems, and the agroecosystem. There's also a whole neo-rural movement. So it's something that isn't entirely destroyed. I think, in any case, that what's also being destroyed is a distinct culture: I've recently been in contact with farming communities in the provinces, in the regions as they say, and I'm struck by the fact that only rap and suburban attitudes are influencing young people. It's become a model for over thirty years now: the role model for young people is the "suburban youth," in quotes, with the look, the behavior, the sexism… It's very surprising, but the colonization is happening right here. When Serge Latouche talks about "decolonizing the imagination"—and we see that the term opens the door to (de)colonial ecology, it's a very strange expression—this decolonization would first have to take place on this scale, meaning that young people from the regions stop seeing themselves as young people from the suburbs and that they have a symbolic existence. They don't exist anywhere. A young person today in the collective imagination is a young person from the suburbs, a young person of immigrant origin, which is very strange. Young people from rural areas or the periphery or the peri-urban, from rural areas who still make up more than 60% of the under-25 population, have no existence, how to put it, no symbolic existence, no resources, they are invisible: hence the Yellow Vests who emerged, notably during the movement of the same name [ 1 ]. So there is a rural life that is not completely dead, I think, and which, in any case, is completely neglected by the environmental discourse, which aims almost exclusively to deliver a moralizing and guilt-inducing message to farmers, but also to fishermen and foresters, etc. [ 2 ]. There is a sociological divide, but it is also a political one, and it is into this chasm, in my opinion, that the discourses of (de)colonial ecology infiltrate, completely losing their bearings, resorting to abstractions that do absolutely nothing to resolve, that solve no problems. On the contrary, they only deepen them.

Cyrille: Here we are getting into the roots of environmentalism, of (de)colonial ecology which are found in several beliefs that environmentalism itself has put forward.

Mono-causal explanation

Quentin: Yes, I think we need this intellectual movement—which I find interesting—[that consists of] starting from the dead ends we're in and tracing them back: how did we get here? For example, it's very simple, well, it's a bit clearer now than it was a few years ago, regarding the Left: how did Islamo-leftism come about? We can trace its genealogy, we talked about it a bit; the proletariat that disappoints; we're looking for a substitute proletariat: Third-Worldism; etc. [ 3 ]. We should do the same thing regarding ecology: how can political ecology, as it has existed for the last fifty years or so, be so porous to the idiotic rhetoric of (de)colonial ecology? I think one of the fundamental causes is that political ecology as it exists has developed within the leftist framework, within the left-wing framework, that is to say, with the same flaws, the same reflexes, the same automatic responses [ 4 ], and in particular with the belief in an ultimate factor, in an element that embodies Evil. For example, capitalism. On the left, we've long seen the word that obsesses them: "capitalism," and to every question that is asked, the answer is: "the problem is capitalism." Among environmentalists, there are other variations in the discourse: it can be industrial society, and then all ecological problems come from industrial society; or from development, from techno-science; or from technology, and then all problems are attributable to a single, unique factor: technology. I think that's a religious stance: we seek the embodiment of Evil in a single figure, and once that figure is eliminated, a miracle solution, also a single solution, will appear. That is to say, once capitalism is overthrown, we will live under communism, it will be Paradise on Earth; once industrial society is superseded, we will live in peaceful relations with nature; once the question of technology is "settled"—in quotation marks—I don't know what that means—we will have a guaranteed ecological future; and so on. I think these are positions inherited from the left [ 5 ] and which are completely, utterly unsuitable in the ecological field.

Cyrille : It's the idea of ​​the Great Day, meaning that there will be a moment when everything will change and everything will be better. This is what we find in millenarian ideologies, etc.

Historical blindness

Quentin : Absolutely. When you take a step back, and this has started to happen in the last twenty years or so, you realize that ecological problems have been almost constant throughout history [ 6 ]. Not only in the West before colonization, obviously, but also in other civilizations: we know of the massive deforestation that took place in China around the 11th and 12th centuries; it was monumental. We know of empires that collapsed because they devastated their natural environment…

Cyrille : …I was thinking about Egypt…

Quentin : Of course, but even the whole Mediterranean basin, for example: today we praise the merits of the garrigue and the maquis, typically Mediterranean landscapes, but in fact these are the scars of forests that were previously there and were ravaged by the Greeks, the Romans, the Persians, and the Assyrians… The Mesopotamian basin, therefore present-day Iraq, was a plain of extraordinary fertility – it was there that the great civilizations of Sumer, Assyria, etc., were born – and it has been largely desertified and today these are plains that are very infertile. Looking back through history, it would seem that this kind of catastrophe existed even before the Neolithic period: we know that when humans landed in Australia, the ancestors of the Aborigines caused the extinction of extremely important local species, and this happened forty thousand years ago… When Homo sapiens arrived on the American continent twelve to thirteen thousand years ago – therefore the ancestors of the Native Americans – exactly the same thing happened: a staggering massacre, and we find fossils of animals that have completely disappeared over a few centimeters, showing that for two to three thousand years, there were systematic massacres [ 7 ]. This is, in my opinion, a very relevant response to (de)colonial ecology, which claims [or implies] that before colonization, peoples had harmonious relationships, concord, communion with nature: this is partly false. It is partly true; There have been very intimate and balanced relationships [with nature] in Europe and the Maghreb, in China, India, etc., and there have also been massacres, destruction, and environmental devastation. Environmental history is extraordinarily complex, and it's difficult to offer lessons. The best approach is to adopt a humble stance and try to sort things out. I'm not defending capitalism, industrial society, or techno-science, etc. What I'm saying is that we can't reduce the ecological problem to a single factor while implicitly promising a single solution.

Lack of prospects

Cyrille : Especially since what we can observe in (de)colonial ideology is that it's purely negative. There are no thinkers, no philosophy that originates from Africa [for example]: it's only people who criticize colonization, slavery, etc., but there's no positive thinking in the sense that there are very few alternatives to the Western system. Moreover, all the ideological underpinnings generally come from American universities; there's no development of independent thought, so it would be a bad start to recreate a society that puts ecology and humanity at its center after (de)colonial revolutions… It's hard to see an alternative…

Quentin : The situation is the same with Islamo-leftism. We can compare Islamo-leftism, for example, to the complacency towards the USSR or other regimes of Pol Pot, the FLN, Castro, etc.; it's a complacency towards totalitarianism [ 8 ]. But at least behind it lay the ideal of a utopian socialist society. The parallel with Islamo-leftism ends there because here there's nothing positive: there's no model Muslim society, it's absurd, it doesn't inspire anyone, and if it did, we'd simply go there, we'd go live there… But that's not the case. And there, indeed, you're right, we find ourselves with (de)colonial ecology in the same situation: it's a critique and even a hatred of the West and even of white people, it's madness, it's a hatred without a solution. It seems that the solution lies in annihilation… But once everything is annihilated, we don’t see what could replace it… But I believe it is this blind hatred that gives them such energy.

Primitivism

That being said, if we're talking about genuine decolonial ecology, then this criticism simply doesn't apply. We see a primitivism developing within the environmental movement—a very old one, too—that is, the dream of returning to a pre-modern society with cosmogonies like those of Amazonian Indians, African bush peoples, and so on. Particularly after Philippe Descola's book *Beyond Nature and Culture* [Gallimard 2005], a very interesting book in itself, many environmentalists, like those at Reporterre , have started dreaming of adopting the mythology of the Achuar; this is an animist Amazonian tribe in which there is no separation between nature and humans, where everything is blurred, and relationships with natural elements are equivalent to relationships between members of a family, siblings, or cousins, etc. Here we have an alternative, but it is completely metaphysical; it is absolutely inapplicable [ 9 ]. So environmentalists have come to dream of this.

Cyrille : It 's the departure from rationality

Getting rid of modernity

Quentin : Completely, absolutely. This is a departure from modernity. And so the (de)colonial ecology we're talking about today uses this primitivist tendency to, in an equally implicit way, make the West dream of a future beyond modernity [ 10 ] . But it's absolutely empty; there's nothing there at all, it's a dead end. I think that, very profoundly, it's a dead end, especially because we're talking about political ecology, and ecology as a science and politics as a domain of thought require a separation between nature and humankind. Perhaps we'll talk about this again another day, but these are philosophical notions that are important in my opinion. Take, for example, the case of China, where there isn't a real separation between nature and society, or at least not in a very approximate way. There's a form of Taoism where there's an alternation between two principles, the Yin and Yang you know, man and woman, darkness and light, and so on. This is very appealing to environmentalists—another cosmogony, another ontology, as anthropologists say, where nature and society aren't opposed. But the problem is that, once there's no longer an opposition between nature and society, ethical questions won't be posed in the same way. For example, this week, the creation of a half-human, half-animal embryo by a Franco-Chinese team, I believe, was announced…

Cyrille : … a chimera…

Quentin : …absolutely, what we call a chimera. We're very shocked; it's something we absolutely don't want, genetic manipulation of living beings. But behind this attitude, which is ours, there's a divide between the natural and the artificial. This divide is largely mitigated in Chinese cosmology; there's no problem, for a Chinese person, creating hybrid beings in robotics as well as in genetics. But, of course, environmentalists don't talk about that… It's very complicated, these are truly complex stories, and we can't say that the West has to abandon modernity to embrace a Chinese, Indian, Achuar, or whatever cosmology. That's absurd.

Evanescence of politics

Rimso : Everything you're saying reminds me of a myth; it's a bit of a return to magical thinking, a psychological state where we're all searching for Paradise on Earth, Eden, even if it's actually already established for some. It can be religion, for example, or Islamist or other forms of thought, where we dream of territories where people would go and which would be magnificent… It's true that this doesn't hold water at all for transforming our daily lives, our relationships… What's important to me is that if we want to challenge important aspects of our relationship to ecology and society, we have to address the modes of production. Because if the question of work and how we produce things isn't addressed, we can always try to make different micro-consumption choices, try to combat excess, etc., but we would need to develop a philosophy that also allows us to establish our means of subsistence, as we were saying. We don't want to live in societies where, I believe, less than 5% of the population feeds everyone else; inevitably, this leads to mass industrialization and all the associated problems. Regarding work, we can ask ourselves: how should we organize ourselves to produce? Because if we refuse to allow certain tasks to be highly specialized, if we extract countless tons of metal from certain places to power industries, airplanes, armies, phones, flat-screen televisions, and all that, it's polluting, it's dangerous… Perhaps someone should ask themselves: am I ready to put myself in their shoes? There, we tell ourselves that there's a hierarchy of work, that's just how it is, others will take the burden, I don't care, I'll keep stuffing myself… But obviously, we also need to make the question of how we organize ourselves desirable, and whether we ourselves are ready to do, to think about it? What kind of work are we, ourselves, ready to do, or not? And what are we willing to inflict on others in order to benefit from our consumption?

Quentin : You're absolutely right. You're actually referring to the societal project. Ecology is political by nature, in the way we understand it here: an ecological policy would require the development of a societal project. But we're extremely far from that, indeed. The way we produce, and who produces and how, but also the way we make decisions. That's more or less the question I pose to the degrowth advocates; I'm not against degrowth myself, but they remain within an economic framework – growth/degrowth – and I very rarely read political considerations about who produces and how and for whom, and who decides and how and when and according to what protocol [ 11 ]. That is to say, there's no question of direct democracy, or very little, or it's very implicit, and the same goes for production. The problem is that ecology—as I was saying earlier—is very much influenced by left-wing ideology, and we need to break free from that because the left, the Marxist left, posits that politics doesn't actually exist. For a Marxist, there is only economics, and politics is secondary to economics; therefore, the question of the society of tomorrow doesn't even arise. Very few of Marx's writings discuss communist society; it's very allegorical, very elliptical, and it's the same in most 20th-century movements; we rarely read anything about what tomorrow's society will be like. I think ecology should reconnect with politics in the noble sense, that is, with the question, "What kind of society do we want?" "And to try to describe it, not to describe a utopia, but to try to find our bearings again, at least, and I think that today we've reached such a level of disembodiment, of abstraction, that we've ended up with (de)colonial ecology that talks nonsense. I agree with you; I'm in favor of a return to very political questions."

The problem is that when we start discussing this again within a left-wing framework, we end up with the old leftist divisions which, in fact, have never been superseded: Stalinists, Trotskyists, post-Maoists, insurrectionists, etc. So we fall back into old politics [ 12 ]. This is a dead end of our time, and one in which ecology is mired up to its shoulders.

A new religious mythology

To pick up on what you were saying at the very beginning; you are also entirely right – if I understand correctly – when you talk about religious imagination. Basically, political ecology is a copy of the leftist imagination which is itself, at its core, a copy of the Judeo-Christian imagination and therefore in which we have a chosen people – the proletariat –, a Paradise, a Bible – Capital – , a God – an evil God called Capital , precisely, therefore capitalism as the incarnation of the Devil, etc. And today, when we talk about ecology, we're even more immersed in a religious imagination: we talk about the Garden of Eden, the Flood, the Apocalypse; we're truly swimming in myths, contemporary myths steeped in Judeo-Christian guilt, which (de)colonial ecology and (anti)indigenous movements exploit to the fullest—it's the white people who are guilty, " you bit into the apple, etc., therefore you are evil, you must atone for your sin! " It's about repentance, and so on. That's not politics; that's psychotherapy, bad psychotherapy…

Perhaps to move on to something a bit more specific: the term "Anthropocene" is very popular, and there are many variations on it: "Capitalocene," "Colonisanocene," "Technocene," "Thanatocene," etc. And here, for me, we're really getting into speculation that leads nowhere. The Anthropocene, I think the listeners are aware, is the idea that for the last century or two, we have entered an industrial society where human beings have an impact on the functioning of the planet. The problem is that we conclude from this that before, we had no impact, and that's wrong. The very use of the term, in my opinion, reveals a flawed perspective: since Homo sapiens has existed—and Homo sapiens is three hundred thousand years old—it has had a massive impact on its environment, it has deforested on a monumental scale, it has caused mass extinctions of species, it would even seem that it has changed the climate two or three times… There is a history between the environment and humankind, and in this respect, the term Anthropocene seems to me to reduce the problem to the question of the West. So, here too, we see that the term, which originates from the Western environmental movement, paves the way for the offensive of (de)colonial ecology. That is why I think that (de)colonial ecology unfortunately has a future; the terrain of political ecology as it exists today is very devastated, very impoverished, very ideological, even religious, and it leads nowhere.

Cyrille : I have the impression that it goes back even further: it reminds me of all those stories about the nurturing mother, etc. Ecology is full of myths, so it's not necessarily anti-rationalist, but there are still foundational myths that refer to the image of the noble savage. That is to say, there was a time in humanity when we were good by nature, and society corrupts us, and this society is the capitalist system, and it's the West.

Quentin : Yes, absolutely. But this Rousseauian myth is also present in the libertarian imagination; there's something of it in the anarchist imagination , which would have us believe that it would be enough to overthrow systems of oppression, hierarchies, domination, [religions], etc., and there would be an agreement between our mutual desires, a little discussion would suffice, and then everything would be sorted out… That's an imagination that permeated the workers' movement, which was very naive. Unfortunately, we realize that it doesn't work that way: human beings are not made a priori —weren't conceived, if ever, by anything!—to live harmoniously, neither among themselves nor between humanity and nature. If there are ever agreements, if there are ever occasional harmonies, if there is ever an establishment of equitable relationships, it is invariably a creation, a cultural creation—and even then, it requires a will to make it happen. You are absolutely right to say that we are swimming in myths as soon as we talk about ecology, but also as soon as we talk about politics. And I believe that thought, one of the goals of thought, the very goal of thought, is to manage to escape myths, not once and for all, because we live with them, but to manage to think, which means arriving and thinking outside of myths…

Cyrille : … demystify…

Quentin : Yes, occasionally, but at some point, managing to think outside of myths, outside of religion, outside of solutions that date back several millennia [ 13 ]… And we struggle with that…

Between techno-scientific, managerial and leftist ecology

R imso : I also wanted to clarify, regarding environmental ideologies and the myths they can perpetuate; some say we need to return to ecology, to the foundation of ecology, which is a science, ecological science. And here, be careful, I'm also critical of rationalism as it can be practiced, with all its scientistic aspects. I think we need to find our way out and discuss politics and what we want in society without falling into or reverting to ecology as a science or to mystical ecology.

Quentin : Yes, we're at the intersection of several ecologies. I think there are three pitfalls in political ecology. First, there's techno-scientism , which you just mentioned, the belief that science will solve everything. Then there's managerial ecology, which basically means we don't change anything except for a few laws; we put up wind turbines in addition to nuclear power plants, we protect small birds, and so on. And then there's leftist ecology, which I think is becoming (de)colonial ecology [ 14 ]. I think these are indeed three dead ends, and there's a huge amount of work that needs to be reopened: the thinking behind political ecology. This is an enormous undertaking, but one that urgently needs to be addressed because we're going to have a "mix" of the three: we'll have techno-scientists through geoengineering projects where they try to shape the major cycles of the biosphere, notably by sending particles into the atmosphere to filter sunlight in order to limit climate change, sequester carbon using artificial processes, etc.; we'll have managerial ecology since there's little chance of an emancipatory revolution, or at least things aren't looking good; and then we'll have (de)colonial ecology since these are global dynamics that are taking shape and the West is clearly declining. So we risk ending up with a regime that adopts the worst of these political ecologies [ 15 ]…

Cyrille : Perhaps we can conclude there. Unless you have anything to add…

Daman : Quentin, perhaps you could mention one or two articles, links or books…

Quentin : I can refer you to the page "Beware of (de)colonial ecology!" and to the articles in "La Décroissance" in the two March and April issues, which are very good.

Cyrille : The April issue was more or less an argument against (de)colonial ecology, with a long article inside. There's also the Lieux Communs pamphlet called Pandemic, Ecology and Politics.

Quentin : And on this page "Beware of (de)colonial ecology!" we have attempted to synthesize most of the things that have been said here in terms of sociological descriptions of the infiltration of (de)colonial ecology into environmental circles, with references to some texts.

Share this article

Facebook X LinkedIn

Right of reply and contributions
Would you like to respond? Submit an opinion piece proposal →

You might also like:

Convergence of struggles

Ms. Panot has succeeded in converging a strange struggle she has waged against public health and anti-Semitism! We expect her to use Israel, and therefore all Jews no doubt, to justify the fight against the high cost of living, against the loss of biodiversity, and who knows what else? 

Review of Nadia Geerts' book: "The Tweet Affair: Gaza or the Defeat of Reason" (H&O, 2026)

Starting from the controversy sparked by a tweet about Gaza, Nadia Geerts delivers a personal testimony which becomes a reflection on the ravages of conformism, disinformation and the rejection of facts in Western democracies.
What you have left to read
0 %

Maybe you should subscribe?

Otherwise, it's okay! You can close this window and continue reading.

    Register: