Puer homini lupus
Marcel Pagnol, My Mother's Castle
"Every day, while I was having lunch at the family table, I would also run up the hill and free a still-warm blackbird from a trap. This bush, this blackbird, and this trap were as real to me as this oilcloth, this café au lait, this portrait of Mr. Fallières smiling vaguely on the wall."
News reached us from Scotland that a child was suffering from "species dysphoria" and identified as a wolf [ 1] See here . So far, nothing serious! All the boys of my generation, during recess, identified as either a cowboy or an Indian. Once we were "in line," the dysphoria stopped, and if one of them pretended to be a cowboy in class, he'd get a smack like my father (the teacher) knew how to give [ 2] Rest assured: no, he didn't go to prison, that wasn't done back then… However, the boy, upon returning home, had to turn the other cheek according to good evangelical principles… . But the problem is that this boy was taken seriously by the teachers and the school staff! The Daily Mail tells us that "this is the first known case in Scotland in which a school has acknowledged that a student identified with an animal."
The first? Does this mean that there are, that there will be others? Scotland had already distinguished itself by locking up in a women's prison a man who identified as a woman, which did not prevent him from being convicted of rape and of course allowed him to reoffend on the spot. Self-service sheep in the sheepfold: wolves love it!
The Daily Mail also tells us that "a growing number of schoolchildren are adopting the personalities of creatures such as foxes, dragons, birds, snakes, sharks, and even dinosaurs." Kindergartens will soon be zoos, and school nurses will have to have studied veterinary medicine or be affiliated with the Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals. This isn't so new: a mischievous child was once called a "strange zebra." The real concern might arise the day a middle school student in the same class as this wolf declares that he is a lamb. [3] The teacher could have them act out a skit to put the fable into practice. Have something on hand to mop up the blood . On the day of the (animal) carnival, everyone will be able to choose… The teaching team stated that they offer “personal support” and “more specific support” with the help of a “social worker,” including guidance and learning support, adding: “There is very little specific advice available on species dysphoria.” They explained that they follow the Scottish government’s Getting It Right For Every Child (GIRFEC) guidelines and use a kind of algorithm called the “Wheel of Wellbeing” to support pupils regardless of the learning obstacles or challenges they face. This is a diagram used to identify areas where children can be helped to overcome inequalities and ensure their voices are heard in “decisions that affect their lives, with support where needed.” It seems perfectly positive to me that efforts are being made to ensure the best possible school experience for all children! Except that it has very little to do with this astonishing identification with an animal.
A Conservative MEP in the Scottish Parliament said:
“Teachers who are already under considerable pressure from SNP funding cuts should not feel they have to work around problems in the classroom. Given all the other challenges facing schools, ministers must ensure that teachers are confident they can take a common sense approach when these situations arise.”
This statement is interesting because it reveals a leak of (common) sense and great hypocrisy: is it really getting around a problem to accept that a child makes fun of the teaching staff in this way? Isn't it rather creating a problem for oneself? Invoking common sense in the face of such a situation is absurd. Could saying: "I am a wolf" be performative when one is not one? It is, we are told, about "treating children with kindness, dignity and respect at all times". The woke victim industry thus defines educational standards.
It seems more reasonable to consider two reasons for these teachers' resignations: fear and ignorance. The first is fear: fear of alienating this semblance of "public opinion," which is a tiny minority in Scotland as in France, but which imposes, often violently, the woke ideology. Since activists seek to promote at all costs the idea that transitioning from one sex to another is legitimate and commonplace, they can only support anything that might appear as an extension of their "struggle": changing sex, changing species, it's all the same. And if you contradict their mantras, going from "a trans woman is a woman" to "a feral child is a wolf [4] No, they haven't said that yet! Am I giving them the wrong idea? " in this case, you will be mistreated, harassed, vilified. The ransacking of the Café Laïque in Brussels is one example. Teachers live in fear [5] 5 See Carine Azzopardi's book When Fear Governs Everything , Plon 2023 .: fear of not being in step with the "progressivism" that is applied to everything; fear for their professional integration, which can be revoked with the stroke of a pen – as we have seen; fear for their physical safety and their property. The second is ignorance of child psychology; children are playful by definition, in all mammalian species, it is essential to their development. They play at dressing up, at "being" other than what they really are, to see "what it's like". I didn't study psychology, but I've had children and grandchildren: I spent afternoons with them playing in their tea sets, trembled with fear before a masked Zorro wielding a sword, stretched my arm toward the syringe from a doctor's kit [6] . I also played with dolls with them, but you won't repeat that, will you? Serious, imperturbable, children play; they know they're playing, and they know we know they're playing. What goes through their minds if they realize we don't "know" they're playing? I don't know. Yet that's precisely what's happening in this school where a thirteen-year-old wants to believe he's a wolf. I'm not sure that taking his playful behavior so literally is really appropriate for "ensuring his mental well-being." What judgment does he make about those adults who do not "pretend" to believe him but firmly believe everything he says?
Let's extend the idea opened up by what I still call a game: what if they had blackened their faces with soot? [7] It's easy: I did it when I was a kid. I'll show you! Ah, then things wouldn't have turned out the same way. Blackface is unacceptable: two kids who had put dark green acne cream on their faces that had turned black were expelled from their high school. [8]
A judge forced the school to reinstate them and pay them generous compensation; woke activists prevented a performance of Aeschylus's The Suppliants in Paris because they believed the masks mimicked the (derogatory) makeup of white actors in the 19th century; Yale students obtained the resignation of a teacher, Erika Christakis, who had essentially said that students could wear whatever costumes they wanted to celebrate Halloween without worrying about "propriety" [9] See here , etc.
A "white" schoolboy who had "transitioned" because he had a "feeling" of being a schoolboy from a diverse background might have been severely reprimanded, his parents summoned by the school hierarchy and ordered to follow a course of solemn renunciation of "white privilege". Gender dysphoria, yes; species dysphoria, why not? But "race" dysphoria? Never!