There is no stopping progress in the invention of new woke causes, intended to wake up the troops who are a little too asleep again. Because it's true, by force of stuffing ourselves with "gender" (about half of the themes listed in the 250 or so items of our 2023 Report), "racialization", "Islamophobia", "homophobia", "transphobia", "fatphobia" and all the phobias imaginable (except that of mice and reptiles, the only ones that I unfortunately have to confess), we end up finding the soap opera a little repetitive... Thus the dreary flock of "sheep of thought" periodically struggles to renew the livestock of the unfortunate victims of Domination (curse your name too pronounced!). And the latest discovery to date is children. Dare you?
Already, at the beginning of September, the "Tracts" collection from Gallimard publishers released "For the Right to Vote from Birth." Written by Clémentine Beauvais, a "lecturer and researcher in the sociology and philosophy of childhood," it presents this right as a "just and necessary reform of democracy," expressing outrage that "the fact that babies, children, and teenagers are forbidden from voting is shocking to almost no one." Then, in October, a conference entitled "Misopedia: Adult Domination in Contemporary Discourse" was held at the University of Limoges. Our colleague Jean Ferrette devoted an editorial to it on our website on October 31st, "No to Misopedia Adultism!" "It's high time to make this culture of misopedia visible with the hashtag #touchdonttouchyourasshole!" he quipped, in a fine display of solidarity with these poor kids horribly discriminated against by adults. But since ridicule only kills those who are susceptible to it (and humor is not the strong point of the woke), this was not enough, alas, to stop the movement: now the site TheConversation (winner, let us remember, of one of our last "woke d'or") publishes on November 14 an article signed by six (no less) teacher-researchers (anthropologists, sociologists, philosophers), entitled "Adult-child: the forgotten domination".
Oh yes, that's right, we almost forgot that one...
The article announces a demonstration in Paris on November 16th intended to "denounce violence against children and adolescents": violence which, it asserts, is merely "the visible tip of the iceberg of a structural domination analyzed by Tal Piterbraut-Merx in * The Forgotten Domination: Politicizing Adult-Child Relations *," which "analyzes the legal, familial, and educational logics that maintain minors in the status of incomplete political beings." Incomplete, then, are teenagers, children, and babies? What an insult to equality!
The article informs us that "adult-child relationships are increasingly frequently considered as relationships of domination" (but does not specify which areas are not yet considered from this astonishingly original angle). Thus the inferiority of children is "constructed" (another concept of astonishing novelty) and their vulnerability is "naturalized" (quick, a good deconstruction to clean all that up!), because "produced by their legal status as minors". With this scandalous result: "The child is not only deprived of all economic and psychological autonomy, but also cannot choose where he or she lives, nor leave the family home without permission, nor even constitute himself or herself as a civil party in a trial" (quickly, let's put the children on the street so that they are no longer deprived of their freedom - and if they are not happy, let's send them to complain to the court!) And the worst is still school: being free and compulsory, it "corresponds to a forced and unpaid incorporation of capitalist social and political norms", so as to make children "employable and productive" - what a scandal!
Inclusive writing, of course, is not forgotten: "All children become adults, and all adults are former children" (we still have to give pledges to political correctness). Thus, "They therefore pass, over time, from the status of dominated to the status of dominant." But what a powerful proposition: the world would be divided once and for all into "dominated status" and "dominant status", so that if you are in one, you cannot be in the other. Only, in which box should we put women, dominated by men but dominant towards children? And Mohammed Merah, poor victim of neocolonial racism but who nonetheless murdered three children because they were Jewish? (children who were doubtless "dominant" because they were "Zionists", as we would say today?). In short, what to do with reality, which has the bad taste not to enter into the low-brow ready-to-think of our new revolutionary thinkers?
Normally, on an academic website, a book review, even a very favorable one, would at least mention a few reservations, a few questions. Nothing of the sort here: without being rhetorically apologetic, the article presents, with the utmost seriousness, propositions that are clearly not—to the point that one wonders if it isn't a hoax. If so, I hope the editors of TheConversation will let us know, and forgive me for falling for it. But everything suggests, alas, that this is a serious article…
Our colleague Pierre-Henri Tavoillot explains in his latest book ( Do We Still Want to Live Together?, published by Odile Jacob) that a child belongs neither to himself, nor to his parents, nor to society, but to the adult he will one day become, and that his parents and society have a duty to help him come into being. And our other colleague Jacques Robert recently published a post along these lines: “Parents’ duties towards their children are just as fundamental as children’s rights: our children are temporarily entrusted to us by the adult they will one day become.” "But to hear this wisdom, one must not have sunk into presentism (everything, right now!), into absolute individualism (I have all the rights!) and into ideological blindness, which prevents one from seeing the most obvious realities, and in particular this one: that a child is a child, which means that he does not have all the capacities of adults and that, consequently, the latter have the duty to protect him.
This is precisely what the Geneva Convention on the Rights of the Child stipulates, as recalled on TheConversation website in an article by Yves Denéchère on November 15th (an article which, in his view, perfectly illustrates what analytical work devoid of ideological bias should be) : “The hungry child must be fed, the sick child must be cared for, the mentally challenged child must be encouraged, the wayward child must be brought back, the orphan and the abandoned child must be taken in and assisted.” Will our valiant critics of the “domination” of adults over children then demand the annulment of this international protection?
And so the passion for victimization turns against those it is supposed to defend...