The hunt for problematic symbols
In 1871, the Communards who distributed cans of oil to set fire to the flagship monuments of Paris, architectural jewels and testimonies of a brilliant past (Tuileries, Hôtel de Ville, Palais de Justice, Prefecture of Police, Ministry of Finance, Council of State), were compared to Erostratos, the arsonist of the temple of Artemis in 356 BC. This comparison finds a new relevance with the phenomenon of unbolting that we have been witnessing for several years.
Since 2020, calls to remove certain markers of public space have multiplied. Street names, statues, memorials—the campaign, which began in the United States, easily crossed the Atlantic (first reaching England). Unable to address present-day inequalities, the past is being vilified, particularly the traces of a colonial past, associated with a mortal sin and supposedly inextricably linked to racism and slavery. Of course, this discourse only concerns Western leaders. Few calls have been made to rename squares honoring Emir Abd-el-Kader (in the 5th arrondissement of Paris or the 7th of Lyon), a figure of North African resistance against France, even though he knowingly owned slaves while the African and Islamic slave trade was still rampant in the 19th century.
The historical logic of erasure
The logic of online revolutionaries is to purge public spaces of any "problematic" references, a concept that the Black Lives Matter protests have helped to amplify, even though it already existed. For example, as early as 2017, the president of the Representative Council of Black Associations of France expressed his outrage in Libération at the presence of a statue of Colbert in the National Assembly, on the grounds that he had drafted one of the versions of the Code Noir, a legal treatise regulating slavery in the French West Indies—even though this Code aimed to grant rights to slaves vis-à-vis their owners. The list is long, from the vandalized statue of Joséphine de Beauharnais on July 26, 2020, in Martinique, to the imprecations hurled at the statue of Cecil Rhodes at Oxford University. Every Western country should perform its act of contrition and purge its public spaces, even without having had colonies. Like Switzerland, "complicit" in colonialism through its banking operations, as asserted in a decree by Le Monde , in an article dated October 23, 2024.
In the West, no one is considered innocent; yet the aims of this hunt, all the more courageous given that a statue has rarely been seen to retaliate against a demonstration by having it toppled, raise questions. The practice is not new, dating from the damnatio memoriae of the Romans, quick to erase the memories of the previous emperor, to the French Revolution. Indeed, the revolutionaries largely encouraged "vandalism" (the term was coined for the occasion by Abbé Grégoire), the destruction of statues of kings, and even the desecration of the tombs of sovereigns at Saint-Denis: it was necessary to put an end to it, to break with the long French monarchy…and above all to announce the other, very real, purges to come. According to Louis Prudhomme in * Révolutions de Paris* , "We are erasing from our walls and our coinage the effigy of a crowned assassin, and the original is not yet erased from the book of the living." This is where we should have started [1] Bertrand Tillier, The Disgrace of Statues , 2022. . » The destruction of the symbols of Louis XVI from 1791 onwards heralded the republican victory and the retreat of the royalists, driven out of the realm of visual acceptability.
The challenges of contemporary moral judgment
Destroying a statue or renaming a street represents the mark of the victor, or of one poised to seize power. It marks the public space with one's imprint to demonstrate what is no longer acceptable, or conversely, what is the new norm, in a kind of expiatory rite. In France, the conquest of North Africa, waged over several decades, left its share of statues and other tributes. The figure of Marshal Thomas-Robert Bugeaud sparked controversy during his lifetime; his memory is now vilified. Conqueror of Algeria and avowed enemy of the 19th- century revolutionaries , he alone embodied a powerful convergence of struggles! On October 14, 2024, the Paris City Hall renamed the avenue bearing his name, located in the 16th arrondissement . He was described as a "sinister figure" according to the capital's official website, in a text riddled with historical errors. He did not order the massacre on Rue Transnonain in 1834, and it was his subordinates who carried out the massacres in Algeria, even if the general covered them up afterward. The Parisian initiative was welcomed in Lyon, where calls have since been growing to rename Rue Bugeaud in the 6th arrondissement . The "Algerians of France" collective already has the new name in mind: "Rue du 17 octobre 1961" (October 17, 1961 Street), to pay tribute, according to this group, "to the millions of victims of colonialism, of French-Algerians who were murdered." In Paris, Bugeaud had already been replaced by Hubert Germain, a Companion of the Liberation, one soldier replacing another… In Lyon, the intention is quite different: to brand the French Empire with infamy. Because Bugeaud is merely the most visible part of a series of demands and targets to be eliminated. In Lille, how many calls have there been to rename the high school and the statue of General Faidherbe? Also in Lyon, the stele in homage to Sergeant Blandan has been "contextualized," its presence now deemed problematic. Why is he suspect? His crime was encouraging his comrades to fight and sacrificing himself to save them. But that was in Constantine in 1842, facing North African combatants… Rank, courage, grade, or sacrifice are irrelevant: setting foot on African soil is enough to be erased. The statue of Faidherbe in Lille primarily honored the general of 1870-1871 who had preserved the North from Prussian occupation; now he is nothing more than the infamous architect of the Senegalese riflemen.
To speak of a “reconciliation”, an “appeasement” that would come through the elimination of these signs of memory is misleading. The requested erasure of these parts of the past could concern any figure in French history. After all, almost all French political leaders of the time – including the left – supported colonial expansion at one time or another, even with scruples, or else had the misfortune to rejoice in the success of the army in the conquest. As shown by the examination of conscience requested of the Swiss, having benefited, indirectly, from colonial products or financial assets drawn from colonial exploitation is a reason for being blacklisted…
The list is long, above all, because it is not intended to ever be finished.
Let's look at the Guide to Decolonial Marseille , published in 2022 by Syllepse, which lists 300 "problematic" places or monuments to denounce. Bugeaud tops the list, followed by General Lamoricière, a 19th - century French officer considered a "butcher" in Algeria (because a French officer who served on the front was supposedly a butcher by nature), but also Léon Gambetta and even…Léon Blum. Gambetta had the misfortune of being supported by financiers with interests in Algeria—among his millions of voters—while Blum had mentioned racial inequality in a public speech. A single remark, an attitude, or a "complicity" is enough, therefore, in this endless purge.
To condemn, one need only pillory a line written several hundred years ago, in the light of 21st- century comfort , and subject these figures to an implacable moral judgment, so "enlightened" and "awake" that it is capable of condemning centuries and millennia of history… The statue of Colbert in front of the National Assembly is, according to Frank Lollia, spokesperson for the "anti-negrophobia brigade," an association quick to denounce "state racism," the presence of which in the public sphere remains to be demonstrated…
The approach is clear: attack the national memory to subject it to the marks of shame and prepare the ground for its erasure.
The enemy is indeed the nation, and the weapon consists of stoking hatred and division to better glorify the clan and the ethnic, political, and religious group, each claiming its own "safe space," even though this space seems imposed on everyone else. Public space is thus denationalized and entirely rewritten to suit the desires of a minority of activists. At Lollia's trial in May 2021, where he was accused of tagging the statue of Colbert, historian Françoise Vergès – a self-proclaimed activist in decolonial movements – called for Colbert to be erased in the same way as…Pétain in 1944. A trial with highly dubious arguments, judging by the activist's lawyer's remarks: "When a person suffers trauma, their DNA undergoes a change; this is true for a woman who is a victim of rape, for example, and her granddaughter would see an aggravation of this. The logic is the same with the descendants of slaves [2] Vincent Geny, 'Statue of Colbert defaced: the trial becomes a platform for the anti-negrophobia brigade', Marianne , May 11, 2021. "
Who will be next? Winston Churchill was called every name under the sun during the BLM protests, his statues were tagged and calls to tear him down multiplied. A “racist”, “imperialist”, “colonialist”… without whom a good number of the protesters and crusaders of good conscience, and their parents, would probably no longer be here to reproach him for it.
Calls to tear down, erase, or "cancel" monuments in the name of 21st - century moral standards constitute an attack on both a shared memory and the necessary nuance that history provides. These are in no way attempts to "create a shared memory," as some might claim, but rather a deliberate attempt to erase French history in order to ensure the triumph of the clan, destroy the common good, and revel in the division sown.
These activists are the Herostratus of our time, or rather, the Herostratus of the woke.