Observatoire academic ethics
Menu

Faced with the specters of the irrational, we are always the advocates of the dead.

Illustration for the article "Faced with the specters of the irrational, we are always the advocates of the dead"

Faced with the specters of the irrational, we are always the advocates of the dead.

Xavier-Laurent Salvador

Linguist, President of LAIC
We are the advocates of the dead, not because we hear their voices, but because we refuse to subject knowledge to seductive illusions. Science cannot be a field of "exceptional" experiments; it is, above all, a space of intellectual demand.

Table of contents

Faced with the specters of the irrational, we are always the advocates of the dead.

In the tumult of epistemological shifts sweeping through contemporary universities, certain approaches are profoundly shaking the foundations of what we still call science. A recent call for papers, circulated by colleagues at French universities, illustrates this drift . It proposes exploring "the voices of the dead, spirits, and entities" by mobilizing tools of the imagination—arts, contemporary performance, psychogenealogy, literature, and spiritualism—while anchoring them in a supposedly scientific approach. This attempt to hybridize the rationality of science with the emotional dimension of fiction constitutes, in my view, a dangerous path that jeopardizes the very essence of academic knowledge.

A surprising call

Here is how the call is written:

Hearing and communicating with other voices (the dead, ancestors, spirits, ghosts, and other entities ) is considered an " exceptional " experience open to multiple interpretations, at the heart of diverse scientific and artistic research, from psychogenealogy to contemporary performance art, including clinical psychopathology , literature, and the study of spiritualism. These so-called anomalous phenomena nevertheless reveal fundamental elements in the construction of our relationship to the world and to our dead, on both an individual and collective level. While scientific actors agree on the prevalence of exceptional experiences, these remain poorly understood by the general public and marginalized outside of psychopathological practice. A better understanding of their modes of appearance and functioning emerges as a contemporary challenge, one in which the collaboration between arts and sciences opens new perspectives, particularly regarding the representation and mediation of these experiences to the public.

If this were a program studying the representations associated with communication with the dead, then it would have its rightful place at the university, under the headings of literary analysis, the anthropology of beliefs, and the sociology of representations: magic, as Technē , is an object of study. But in no way is it a form of epistemology! We remember the case of Élisabeth Teissier's thesis and the subsequent quackery trial. It's an understatement to say, upon reading this text, that it was prescient of the evolution of our studies [1]. a

The University is based on a tacit but solid contract: that of submitting reality to proven methodological frameworks, capable of distinguishing between a well-founded hypothesis and a belief. This does not mean that the human sciences, or even the so-called "hard" sciences, are exempt from imagination. Any scientific approach implies a part of intuition, projection, creativity. But these elements serve as a starting point for a critical and rational enterprise which, by its structure, neutralizes the irrational in order to approach the truth.

But what we see today is an attempt to tip this fragile balance. Approaches that emphasize mediumship, or what they modestly call "exceptional experiences," no longer use the tools of the imagination to fuel rational knowledge. On the contrary, they establish the imagination as an autonomous system, or even a new epistemological authority. In a strange reversal, what was once the domain of literature or artistic expression becomes a scientific fact, treated with the same seriousness as the analysis of quantitative or qualitative data.

Recall our role

Faced with this trend, it is crucial to remember the central role of literature in the analysis and interpretation of discourses attributed to the dead. As I wrote in a previous text , to be literary is to defend the absolute necessity of respecting uncertainty. The dead, by definition, are absent. They cannot intervene to clarify or resolve the debates attributed to them. Their silence, while prompting us to imagine or interpret, also imposes an ethical imperative: that of acknowledging that any position we ascribe to them is a construct, one possibility among others.

In this sense, the science of literature has a specific mission: it does not seek to hear the dead or to transcribe imaginary voices into factual truths, but to open up the range of possibilities, to explore the areas of uncertainty that are the very heart of human experience. To make the dead speak unequivocally is not only to cross the boundary between the rational and the irrational, but above all it is to betray the literary mission, which never claims to reduce silence to a truth but considers it as a space of interpretation.

However, to attribute a speech or an intention to the dead through pseudo-scientific practices is to usurp their silence in order to transform it into an argument. It is to freeze the imaginary into a dogma, whereas literature teaches us to accept that we do not know. It is also to risk confusing what is art - a possible staging of the past or the invisible - with what constitutes knowledge based on proven methods.

This confusion of genres opens the door to the irrational within the walls of the University. Worse still, it risks legitimizing practices that claim to be alternative knowledge. If we consider that "hearing voices" is a valid experience because it reveals "fundamental elements in our relationship to the world and to our dead", where do we stop? Will we soon recognize mediumship as a professional skill? Teach the interpretation of messages from entities as we teach cognitive psychology or critical sociology today? The idea seems laughable, but History is full of examples where epistemological relativism has opened the way to very real excesses.

In the face of this, we have a responsibility. We must reaffirm that science, in its many forms, is based on a critical tension that requires it to be accountable to reality. This does not mean the eradication of the imaginary, but its domestication by rational frameworks. We are the advocates of the dead, not because we hear their voices, but because we refuse to subject knowledge to seductive illusions. Science cannot be a field of “exceptional” experiments; it is, above all, a space of intellectual demand.

Perhaps it is time, beyond the monitoring work of our Observatory, for the CNU and the Institution to take hold of these excesses...

Share this article

Facebook X LinkedIn

Author

Right of reply and contributions
Would you like to respond? Submit an opinion piece proposal →

You might also like:

To celebrate the 60th anniversary of its university, the town hall burns a book

Where Jacques Robert denounces the decision of the mayor of Mont-Saint-Aignan to symbolically burn a facsimile of a book during the 60th anniversary of the University of Rouen: does this reveal ignorance, stupidity or ideological contempt for knowledge and culture? 

Eulogy of Mr. Aurélien Taché, benefactor of the French language – An admiring account of a work that will be groundbreaking, if not groundbreaking.

There are books that revolutionize thought. Others that revitalize the sciences. Still others that change the course of history. And then there are books that allow their author to appear on television. Let us not disregard this last category: it now constitutes a considerable part of our intellectual life. Mr. Aurélien Taché has just published a book with Fayard entitled *French, an African Language*. This is a discovery for which we cannot praise him enough. We have known for some time that French is spoken in Senegal, Ivory Coast, Congo, and a few other countries. African writers had even dared to use it to compose literary works. But it took a French politician to finally reveal to us the significance of this fact.
What you have left to read
0 %

Maybe you should subscribe?

Otherwise, it's okay! You can close this window and continue reading.

    Register: