Observatoire academic ethics
Menu

Islamism and Postmodern Thinkers

Illustration for the article "Islamism and Postmodern Thinkers"

Islamism and Postmodern Thinkers

Francois Rastier

François Rastier is an honorary research director at the CNRS and a member of the Laboratory for the Analysis of Contemporary Ideologies (LAIC). Latest work: Petite mystique du genre, Paris, Intervalles, 2023.

Table of contents

This article has no sections.

Illustration for the article "Islamism and Postmodern Thinkers"

Islamism and Postmodern Thinkers

By François Rastier

The “revolutionary” turn of Islamism was heralded in various ways. In his book, Revolutionary Islam (2003), Ilich Ramírez Sánchez, known as Carlos [1] , was already urging, with the fervor of a new convert, the “anti-globalization movements” to join the fight to “liberate the world from imperialist exploitation and Palestine from Zionist occupation.” Islamism would then be considered left-wing, and Judith Butler, a global authority on gender theory, explained in 2006 that “it is extremely important to consider Hamas and Hezbollah as progressive social movements, which are on the left and part of a global left [2] .” They would even be part of the international revolutionary cause, according to Michael Hardt and Toni Negri: “The postmodernity of fundamentalism is recognizable by its rejection of modernity as a weapon of Euro-American hegemony—in this respect, Islamic fundamentalism represents a paradigmatic example.” » ( Empire , 2000, p. 149).

This anti-modern revolution strongly resembles the "conservative revolution" in Weimar Germany. By this euphemistic term, Armin Moehler designated the movement of thought which prepared the establishment of a totalitarian state justified by an obscure political theology [3] and radically opposed to the values ​​of modernity such as democracy, human rights, the autonomy of citizens, equality between men and women, and the rule of law.

Today, Khomeini's Iran would have shown the way to this revolution, according to Hardt and Negri: "Insofar as the Iranian revolution expressed a profound rejection of the global market, it could be considered the first postmodern revolution." Besides the fact that Iran is part of the global market and constantly denounces access restrictions, it is worth noting that the Iran Times celebrates Iran's international trade agreements every day.

Regardless, we understand that the postmodern revolution presented here as a paradigmatic example is the establishment of a theocracy, whether Shiite or Sunni, like the caliphate according to ISIS. In this metapolitics, assassins can become heroes (or martyrs), and the repression of democrats, independent journalists, or human rights defenders illustrates a “paradigmatic” anti-imperialist revolution. This dual regime of truth was recognized by Michel Foucault, a supporter of Khomeini, from the very bloody establishment of the Islamic Republic: Iran does not have “the same regime of truth as we do [4] .” The state of exception creates its own truth; this was already the theme of Nazi thinkers like Martin Heidegger and Carl Schmitt. The fact remains that, in this regime of truth, democrats and secularists are ruthlessly repressed: let us recall the thirty thousand political prisoners massacred in 1988 on the orders of a fatwa issued by Khomeini, and the international Holocaust denial conference organized in 2006 by Ahmadinejad. Since then, in Syria, jihadist groups of various persuasions have had nothing more pressing than to fight secular or simply democratic resistance fighters.

Such a “revolutionary” orientation found various echoes in France, particularly after the first attacks of 2015 against Charlie Hebdo and the Hyper Cacher supermarket, which targeted both secularism and Judaism. It would be worth revisiting Emmanuel Todd’s book, * Who is Charlie? * , which deals with “zombie” Catholicism ( sic ), not Islamism… For his part, Alain Badiou, in his Racine-inspired work * Our Evil Comes from Further Back: Thinking About the November 13th Killings *, credits the perpetrators with a “sacrificial heroism.” Less fortunate, Jean-Marc Rouillan, former leader of Action directe, who had simply mentioned the terrorists’ “courage,” was sentenced to eight months in prison for condoning the crime. The “courage” of the murderers had already been praised by the philosopher Susan Sontag in her contribution to the New Yorker ’s special issue on the September 11, 2001 attacks.

Badiou also justified nihilism, “a popular subjectivity that is generated and fostered by globalized capitalism,” since “it is fascism that Islamizes and not Islam that fascizes.” Finally, let us move on to Onfray, whose interviews have been used in ISIS videos, such as this statement in Le Point on November 15, 2015, two days after the November 13 attacks, under the title “France Must End Its Islamophobic Policy ” : “If we continue to pursue this aggressive policy toward Muslim countries, they will continue to retaliate as they do. France should end this Islamophobic policy aligned with the United States [5] .”

Regarding these thinkers, Boualem Sansal spoke of "useful idiots", but, however well-founded it may seem, this formula of Leninist tradition overlooks the fact that their statements are perfectly concerted and even clever if we judge by their dissemination. In fact, our radical thinkers share the same enemies with the Islamists: the fantasized West, democracy, human rights, international justice, rationality. All fear that the rule of law will disarm and dissipate their political theologies, whether they are based on Sayyid Qutb or Hassan Al Banna, Martin Heidegger or Carl Schmitt.

A good number of radical philosophers, from Nancy to Vattimo, Agamben, Žižek, Badiou reject the rule of law by invoking Heidegger – who, even before the publication of his most anti-Semitic and openly Hitlerian writings, attracted the support of various Islamists, from Abdul Rahman Al Badawi to Ibrahim Vadillo. Ahmad Fardid in Iran claimed to be his followers in order to create a school of thought from which Mahmoud Ahmadinejad emerged.

Moreover, ISIS ideologues are perfectly adept at postcolonial rhetoric and use it to recruit. While they are obviously reserved regarding gender theory, they equate humanitarian action, crusades, and genocide. They are not the first: Derrida, in * Monolingualism of the Other*, listed the secondary evils of the "colonial drive," enumerating "religious missions, philanthropic or humanitarian good works, market conquests, military expeditions, or genocides" (1996, p. 47).

On the Qatari channel Al Jazeera , closely aligned with the Muslim Brotherhood, the deconstructive philosopher Slavoj Žižek became the designated commentator on the Arab revolutions [6] , warning them against Western democracies—and electoral democracy, which is not well-regarded in the Gulf. On the channel's website, in a tribute to Derrida, the postmodern philosopher Santiago Zabala also warns against those who "still believe in nostalgic and dangerous ideas such as 'objectivity,' 'reality,' 'truth,' and 'values' as preconditions for democracy," because this amounts to "the pursuit of fanatical and absolute assertions [7] ." Indeed, the absolutist fanaticism of democrats must be duly denounced in the media of Qatari feudalism.

In what way, however, could our radical thinkers be of any use to Islamists today? The aim of the attacks is not simply to target symbols like Charlie Hebdo , the Hyper Cacher supermarket, the Jewish Museum of Brussels, or the Bastille Day celebrations in Nice. Beyond the shock of the violence, the Islamists seek to disorient public opinion, to stifle critical thinking, and to reverse the roles of victims and perpetrators. By exacerbating the confusion, strategically deepening it, and pursuing violence through other means, our ideologues can thus claim the historical role of auxiliaries.

One final example. Sandra Laugier, a highly influential Hamon-supporting philosopher at the CNRS (French National Centre for Scientific Research), specializing in gender and care , co-authored an article in Libération with Albert Ogien (already co-author of Antidémocratie ), two months after the beheading of Samuel Paty, entitled “The Fanatics of the Republic.” They assert: “This reduction of the Republic to secularism leads the last bastion of the devout to take to the front lines as soon as they sense a threat to this pillar of the republican order […]. This irritates the zealots of secularism, who have found an outlet for their frustration: the Muslim presence. Thus, they come to confuse the defense of the ‘values ​​of the Republic’ with a crusade against a minority, singled out for collective vengeance” (December 12, 2020). Should we lament that Muslim children are forced to attend secular schools and undergo “digital tagging”? Originating in the Islamist conspiracy sphere, the accusation of "computer tagging", popularized by a Pakistani minister, had been denounced as fake news as early as November 22, three weeks earlier.

Who is threatened by the "madmen of the Republic"? Accused of discriminating against young Muslims, was Samuel Paty not one of these madmen?


[1] Ilich Ramírez Sánchez, Revolutionary Islam , Monaco, éd. du Rocher, 2003.

[2] “Judith Butler responds to attack: “I affirm a Judaism that is not associated with state violence””, Mondoweiss <http://mondoweiss.net/2012/08/judith-butler-responds-to-attack-i-affirm-a-judaism-that-is-not-associated-with-state-violence>, August 2012.

[3] Announced notably by Carl Schmitt, Political Theology (1922), Spengler, The Decline of the West (1918-1922), and by Arthur Moeller van den Bruck, The Third Reich [ Das Dritte Reich ] (1923). Heidegger took up the main themes of these, from the Rectoral Address to the Black Notebooks which are now being published.

[4] I n Janet Afary and Kevin B. Anderson, Foucault and the Iranian Revolution: Gender and the Seductions of Islamism , Chicago, University of Chicago Press, 2005, p. 125. See also the synthesis by Michael Walzer, “Islamism and the Left”, Dissent , <https://www.dissentmagazine.org/article/islamism-and-the-left>, winter 2015.

[5] Translated into Arabic, his interview with Jean-Jacques Bourdin in 2013 on France 24 earned him many, entirely justified, Islamist votes: "We are not going to make the law in Muslims' homes. Muslims are in their own homes [ sic ]. In that case, why don't we make the law in Israel... We must stop pursuing our colonial policy under the pretext that we are motivated by human rights!"

[6] His latest book was also reviewed and praised on Al Jazeera by Santiago Zabala, a figure of Spanish-speaking Heideggerianism, collaborator of Gianni Vattimo and also co-author of Deconstructing Zionism ( in Vattimo and Marder, 2014, op. cit .).

[7] See <www.aljazeera.com/indepth/opinion/2014/03/ten-years-without-derrida-20143291559170321.html>.

Share this article

Facebook X LinkedIn

Right of reply and contributions
Would you like to respond? Submit an opinion piece proposal →

You might also like:

WOKISM VS TRUMPISM: A NEW WAR OF IDEAS

An interview by Pierre-Henri Tavoillot with the philosopher Manuel Maria Carrilho who analyzes wokism as an ideology stemming from the "paradigm of the unlimited", based on a boundless conception of identity and language, and marked by a censorial fanaticism deeply rooted in Western institutions.

Science and ideology: where is the boundary today?

From October 8 to 10, 2026, the Observatory of University Ethics is organizing a symposium at the Sorbonne and the Condorcet Campus dedicated to the boundaries between science and ideology. Free admission.
What you have left to read
0 %

Maybe you should subscribe?

Otherwise, it's okay! You can close this window and continue reading.

    Register: