Observatoire academic ethics
Menu

Museums under influence: when ideology erases art

Illustration for the article "Museums under influence: when ideology erases art"

Museums under influence: when ideology erases art

In "Bad Genre at the Museum," Didier Rykner denounces the growing intrusion of woke and decolonial ideologies into museums, accused of falsifying history, censoring works, and sacrificing art to militant causes. Through a series of concrete examples, he criticizes the trivialization of vandalism, racial obsession, cancel culture, and the ideological rewriting of works—all serious attacks on memory, universalism, and the mission of cultural institutions.

Table of contents

Museums under influence: when ideology erases art

Review of Didier Rykner's book, Mauvais genre au musée , Les Belles Lettres, 2025.

Although the founder of "La Tribune de l'Art" avoided calling his book "Wokism in the Museum ," he admits in the introduction that this is indeed its subject. Drawing on his experience with museums and the art market, Didier Rykner offers an uncompromising diagnosis of the penetration of ideologies into French museums, which rival their American and European counterparts in this regard. While one might regret the lack of a comprehensive perspective on the phenomenon, as well as some unfortunate typos (when he repeatedly cites Jean-François as "Bronstein") and minor linguistic ("c'est sans compte avec") and historical errors (he claims there is no trace of women artists in Antiquity, whereas Pliny the Elder mentions several), this book is invaluable because it brilliantly provides and analyzes a series of compelling examples.

TRIVIALIZATION OF VANDALISM

In Didier Rykner's view, "wokism" is a denial of history, a desire to wipe the slate clean that manifests as vandalism—a term coined by Abbé Grégoire, just like the word "vandalist," which was soon abandoned, even though the recurring incidents on the Champs-Élysées should encourage us to rehabilitate it. But unlike revolutionaries, who protested against a power deemed despotic, those who topple statues target the effigies of men who no longer belong to current events, but to history and art. Josephine de Beauharnais, Christopher Columbus, or Gandhi pose no threat to anyone, assuming they ever uttered racist remarks, and yet their statues have been beheaded or toppled. In 2020, when the statue of Josephine in Fort-de-France was demolished by protesters, the prefect had orders to let it happen. The same thing happened to the statue of Victor Schoelcher, who was instrumental in the abolition of slavery. No one was held accountable for these acts of destruction, which the Republic therefore considers legitimate. Vandalism has become just another form of activism, serving causes unrelated to art: in 2023, environmental activists (from the Just Stop Oil collective ) attacked Velázquez's Venus at her Mirror with a hammer at the National Gallery in London, seemingly unconcerned that the goddess was never a shareholder of Total or ExxonMobil.

For the woke, history has frozen in an eternal present and all Black people are still in the cotton fields, regardless of whether they are millionaires or the face of luxury brands. One thing is certain: they are as insensitive to memory (since they erase it) as they are to art (since they destroy it). Rykner recounts a chilling anecdote: Keith Christiansen, a world-renowned art historian and curator at the Metropolitan Museum in New York, went through a violent storm for posting on Instagram an engraving depicting Alexandre Lenoir defending the tombs of the kings at Saint-Denis against the revolutionaries hell-bent on destroying them.

Alexandre Lenoir defending the tombs of Saint-Denis , anonymous, Louvre, Department of Graphic Arts (public domain)

It's worth remembering that Lenoir, a freethinker and Freemason, defended these tombs as masterpieces of medieval, Renaissance, and Classical sculpture, which he would later exhibit in his Musée des Monuments Français. The post read: “How many great works of art have been sacrificed to the desire to get rid of a past we don't approve of. And how grateful we are to people like Lenoir who recognized that their value—both artistic and historical—extended beyond a pivotal moment of social and political upheaval and change.” The Met curator suggested an implicit analogy with the destruction of statues that was then rampant in the United States. No sooner had the message been published than hostile reactions poured in, forcing Christiansen not only to delete his post and his Instagram account, but also to retract his statement in the New York Times : “This post was not only inappropriate and flawed in its judgment, it was simply wrong.” Here is a fine effect of this marvelous "tolerant" and "inclusive" ideology: having forced a museum curator, who valued his job and his life, to approve the destruction of works of art.

ACTIVIST MUSEUMS

In the United States, as in Europe, ideological biases characterize both acquisition policies and mediation mechanisms. Regarding the first point, the injunction has been imposed to purchase primarily—or even exclusively—works created by "minorities," women, or "racialized" artists. In Washington, the National Museum of Women in the Arts, inaugurated in 1981, exhibits only works by women. As for the National Gallery, it has been buying mainly works by women since 2021: some are excellent, but others are uninteresting dross. A small, very clumsy devotional painting by Caterina Pierozzi (an Italian painter from the late 7000th century) was purchased at Drouot for €700000 and resold to the museum for €XNUMX. The Rikjsmuseum has a "women's fund" dedicated to women's art. In England, many museums devote a page on their website to the women artists in their collections.
This bias can also affect the presentation of works: the Museum of Fine Arts in Ghent has scheduled, from 2027, an exhibition on "queer readings in the art of the Netherlands from 1400 to 1950", and launched an appeal for volunteers to unearth works eligible for this new prism.

RACIAL OBSESSION

Museums are particularly obsessed with the history of slavery: they seek out works depicting black people and slaves, but neglect white slaves who were victims of the Arab-Muslim slave trade – portraits of whom can nevertheless be found in auction rooms.

Failing that, the explanatory labels find a link, however tenuous, to slavery: at the Philadelphia Museum of Art, the label accompanying George Romney 's Portrait of the Willett Children makes no mention of the painter or the models, but reminds us that these children benefited from the labor of their father's slaves, who later purchased a plantation. The labels at Tate Britain indict 18th-century English society, and specifically slavery, even though it is not depicted in the paintings.

In 2021, the Rijksmuseum organized a tour of its collections, entitled "Rijksmuseum and Slavery," featuring 77 works. The Night Watch is linked to "the Black community and slavery" because the place where Rembrandt painted the company of musketeers was also a refuge for an African community. As for van Ostade's Pipe Smoker , it goes without saying that he can only smoke his tobacco thanks to slaves. And so on.

In 2023, an exhibition at the Metropolitan Museum (New York) entitled "Tiepolo and Multiracial Europe" saw Black people everywhere, as long as the character was a little dark-skinned or left in the shadows.

This obsession becomes frankly problematic when the decolonial prism leads to misinterpretations of the works: in 2002, the Metropolitan Museum organized an exhibition around Carpeaux's bronze bust, Why be born a slave? Carpeaux made several copies of it, in terracotta, marble and bronze, between 1868 and 1870, from a preparatory study for a figure of Africa on the Fountain of the Four Parts of the World, avenue de l'Observatoire.

Jean-Baptiste Carpeaux, Why be born a slave? (copy from the Villèle Museum in Réunion) (public domain)

Struck by the recent Civil War, Carpeaux wanted to denounce slavery. But Fabienne Kanor, a Martinican novelist invited to comment on the work in an online guide, didn't see it that way and accused the sculptor of racism: "I see a prisoner. I see a white fantasy." According to the dogma of cultural appropriation, white people have no legitimacy to depict Black people, even to create a beautiful work or to embrace their struggles.

While French museums, like universities, long resisted, they now seem eager to catch up in the march of progress and the frantic pursuit of repentance. In 2022, the "Mirror of the World" exhibition at the Musée du Luxembourg displayed a sculpture by Balthasar Permoser, Moor Presenting an Emerald Root (1724), commissioned by the Elector of Saxony to showcase a collection of rare stones: emeralds, rubies, sapphires, garnets, and a tortoiseshell platter. The man depicted is likely a Native American who arrived in Saxony from Colombia as a prisoner of war.

Balthasar Permoser, Moor presenting an emerald root (1724)

In the exhibition's accompanying booklet, Bénédicte Savoy carefully avoids contextualizing the work within the culture of mirabilia , the admiration for the wonders of nature and distant peoples, but instead stigmatizes "racist and exoticizing stereotypes," concluding that a postcolonial perspective is necessary when presenting the works. The art historian is known for her advocacy for the restitution of artworks to colonized countries and her systematic denunciations of France's darker aspects—to the point that Macron reportedly nicknamed her "my casting mistake," according to Rykner. The prevailing opinion is now ubiquitous: 16th- and 18th-century art is steeped in colonialism and racism. Certainly, these works reflect the reductive Western view of these peoples, but it cannot be said that they were created to legitimize Western domination and slavery. On the contrary, the great beauty of the portraits of Black people that we have preserved, both painted and sculpted, reflects the curiosity and fascination for other physical types, considered no less beautiful than the European type.

The "decolonization of the museum" requires re-educating the visitor's gaze. At the Manchester Museum, an empty frame represents "works by Black women," which are too often absent from the collections, despite recent acquisitions. Increasingly, heritage works are being shelved in storage and replaced by digital devices or videos in which celebrities comment on the works. At the Antwerp Museum, Somali singer Ikraan can be heard declaring: "I don't really feel at home here because of this country's colonial and racist past."

In France, it is Françoise Vergès who loudly upholds the mission of "Decolonizing the Arts," the name of her association founded in 2015. This decolonial feminist, who devotes her life to expiating the crime of her great-great-grandmother, the owner of a plantation of 121 slaves in Réunion, is also a great specialist in denial, a denial illustrated by her desire to conceal the role of black Africa and the Muslim world in the slave trade, and more recently by her full support for Hamas in the face of the "structural racism" of the Israeli colonizer.

CANCEL CULTURE

Racial activism often leads to "cancel culture," the removal of works deemed racist or simply too "white." Museums have blindly embraced the activist concept of cultural appropriation, which holds that a Black person can only be represented or portrayed (in film) by a Black person, a woman by a woman, a gay person by a gay person, and so on. In 2016, the Whitney Museum of Art exhibited a painting depicting Emmet Till, a Black teenager brutally murdered by two white men in 1955. But the painting was the work of a white artist, Dana Schutz. A Black artist, Hannah Black, therefore asked the curators to remove it and even destroy it, because "the subject is not Schutz's," and "contemporary art is a fundamentally white supremacist institution"—the painting disappeared. Similarly, the white curator of African art at the Brooklyn Museum was dismissed and replaced by a Black curator, as part of the Decolonize Brooklyn Museum movement.

Cancel culture has not spared French institutions. Rykner recalls the controversy sparked by the sign "Au Nègre Joyeux," which has appeared since the end of the 2018th century on a grocery store on Place de la Contrescarpe: the sign depicts a West Indian, dressed as a gentleman (in the manner of the free Black people of the Antilles), making a toast, a napkin around his neck, served by a white maid—and not the other way around, as has been claimed. In 2021, the city of Paris decided to remove the sign and commission a report from Matthieu Couchet, who emphasized its heritage value and recommended installing a sign for passersby, telling the story of this grocery store and the evolution of the word "nègre," still claimed by Aimé Césaire. But the City Hall decided that the object "is not in line with the anti-racist values ​​upheld by our time and our city" and that "The City of Paris cannot put back into public space this advertising sign with its shocking and undeniably racist title" - which is factually false, regarding the word "negro". Installed in XNUMX in Carnavalet, the work is described as "racist" on the poster. If the representation of Black people echoes stereotypes that could potentially be described as "racist", the approach of condemning without explaining or contextualizing is unworthy of a museum.

Other institutions have given in to this white-glove vandalism: in 2021, the residents of the Villa Medici requested the removal of the Indian Tapestry, a sumptuous Gobelins work depicting a diplomatic visit by the King of Congo to Brazil, on the grounds that it celebrated "colonialist violence." Presented to Louis XIV by Jean-Maurice de Nassau-Siegen, Governor General of the Dutch colonies in Brazil, these tapestries were inspired by cartoons produced during a major scientific expedition tasked with recording in as much detail as possible the fauna, flora, and population of northeastern Brazil. Although the tapestries do not depict any slaves, but only magnificently adorned Black people, including the King of Congo, they are no longer on display, except for the animal scenes... until an animal rights group demands their removal, arguing that they were not woven by tigers and zebras?

The Republic has so far resisted another cancellation request: in 2019, a platform called for the removal of Hervé di Rosa's fresco in the National Assembly (1991), commemorating the abolition of slavery. The Black people in it have enormous lips, but that's the style of this artist who paints all his characters in the same way; if we don't find it beautiful, we can at least give credit to the good intentions of this illustrator of Césaire, actively committed to fighting racism.

This black-and-white rewriting of history is pulling out all the stops, even resorting to conspiracy theories: the anti-racist orthodoxy claims to have discovered the polychromy of Greek statues—a discovery actually made by 19th-century archaeologists—but attributes the erasure of color to a white conspiracy! “It was hidden from you to promote whiteness as the ideal of a fantasized West,” proclaims a podcast on France Culture. This radio station, supposedly dedicated to disseminating academic knowledge to the general public, no longer shies away from militant fake news , at the risk of betraying its mission and its very name. So closely does cancel culture resemble the cancellation of culture itself.

Share this article

Facebook X LinkedIn

Right of reply and contributions
Would you like to respond? Submit an opinion piece proposal →

You might also like:

A look back at the conference "Palestine and Europe: the weight of the past and contemporary dynamics"

Is the cancellation of a conference desirable? Two positions argued by two members of the Observatory.

Science and Ideology Symposium, October 8-10, 2026

What you have left to read
0 %

Maybe you should subscribe?

Otherwise, it's okay! You can close this window and continue reading.

    Register: