Observatoire academic ethics
Menu

Ruffin controversy over gender change at 16: is societal obsession the left's burden?

Ruffin controversy over gender change at 16: is societal obsession the left's burden?

Collective

Observers' Tribune

Table of contents

Ruffin controversy over gender change at 16: is societal obsession the left's burden?

Read More (For subscribers only) FIGAROVOX/OPINION – The left-wing MP has been criticized by some on the left, and by LGBT associations, after declaring that a possible law on gender reassignment should not be "at the heart" of his party's platform. For Pierre Valentin, this controversy reveals a gap between the left's electoral base and its out-of-touch leaders. Pierre Valentin is the author of the report "Woke Ideology" for Fondapol. When questioned on June 1st on France Info about the idea of ​​implementing a law in France allowing gender reassignment at sixteen without parental consent, the La France Insoumise MP François Ruffin attempted to deliver an electorally realistic speech, highlighting the social issue. Clearly uncomfortable in his response, he ended up stating: "We have a society that is deeply fractured in France." In this climate of tension and mental exhaustion, we need calm and stability, we need to rebuild bridges, mend fractures, and avoid deepening them. Within this framework, we mustn't do everything that comes to mind, not everything that might be inherently good. We must seek ways to reconcile our current society. Also read: François Ruffin doesn't rule out running for president "one day." The MP hadn't even dared to challenge the validity of this law on gender reassignment for minors… This article is for subscribers only. You have 86% left to discover.

Subscribers only

FIGAROVOX/OPINION – The left-wing MP has been criticized by some on the left, and by LGBT associations, after stating that a possible law on gender reassignment should not be "at the heart" of his party's platform. For Pierre Valentin, this controversy reveals a disconnect between the left's electoral base and its out-of-touch leaders.

Pierre Valentin is the author of the note “Woke ideology” for Fondapol.

When questioned on June 1st on France Info about the idea of ​​implementing a law in France allowing gender reassignment at sixteen without parental consent, La France Insoumise MP François Ruffin attempted to deliver an electorally realistic speech, emphasizing the social issue. Clearly uncomfortable in his response, he ultimately stated: “We have a deeply fractured society in France. […] In this climate of tension and mental exhaustion, we need calm, stability, to rebuild bridges, to repair the fractures and not widen them further. Within this framework, we mustn't do everything that comes to mind, not everything that might even be good in itself. We must seek ways to reconcile our current society.”

Also read: François Ruffin does not rule out running for president "one day".

The MP therefore did not even dare to challenge the merits of this law on the gender change of minors...

This article is for subscribers only. You have 86% left to discover.

 

"This post is a summary of information from our information monitoring"

Author

[side_notes]

Right of reply and contributions
Would you like to respond? Submit an opinion piece proposal →

You might also like:

Things seen in Bordeaux…

Our friend Vincent Tournier spent a few days in Bordeaux… He shares some anecdotes with us. It is generally in the details of daily life that the ideological obsessions of a society are revealed.

Science, the Besieged Citadel

"Science, the Besieged Citadel" by Jacques Robert denounces the abuses affecting science and reason: the pervasive influence of ideology on critical analysis, numerous unpunished frauds, and the impostures of pseudoscience, with potentially serious consequences for society as a whole and the credibility of scientists. A review by Claudio Rubiliani.
What you have left to read
0 %

Maybe you should subscribe?

Otherwise, it's okay! You can close this window and continue reading.

    Register: