Observatoire academic ethics
Menu

Identity kit of the French least attached to secularism

Identity kit of the French least attached to secularism

Collective

Observers' Tribune

Table of contents

Identity kit of the French least attached to secularism

Read more  Three years ago, Ifop asked a representative sample of French people the following question: "Personally, would you be in favor or opposed to the wearing of conspicuous religious symbols such as the veil, the kippah, the turban or the cross by students in public middle and high schools?" The verdict was that only 25% of those surveyed said they were in favor of highlighting religious symbols. In May 2023, the institute asked the same question and things have changed little since the proportion is 23%.
In terms of social status, level of education or wealth, there are few obvious differences. On the other hand, several indicators make it possible to identify the French who wish to do away with the law of March 15, 2004 "regulating, in application of the principle of secularism, the wearing of symbols or clothing manifesting religious affiliation."
Generation gap
There is a real generation gap on the issue. The situation has the merit of clarity: the younger you are, the more you are in favour of wearing conspicuous religious symbols. Thus, 46% of 18-24 year-olds are, the highest percentage in the study. The proportion drops to 32% among 25-34 year-olds, to 23% among 35-49 year-olds, to 17% among 50-64 year-olds and then to 14% among those over 65.
On the other hand, the study does not explain the reasons for this divide. Are young people more religious than their elders? Are they influenced by Anglo-Saxon communitarianism? Attached to the individual freedom to dress as one pleases? It would be interesting to conduct a survey on this gap which could, in the long term, put "French-style secularism" in danger.

46% of 18-24 year olds want to allow conspicuous religious symbols in middle and high schools compared to 14% of over 65s

Left right divide
Georges Clemenceau, Léon Blum, Jean Jaurès, Georges Marchais and the great figures of the Republican left of the 19th and 20th centuries must be turning in their graves. Formerly intransigent on questions of secularism, the left is becoming the political faction that most wants the return of religious symbols in the "Temples" of the Republic that are public middle and high schools.
Of course, the French left remain attached to traditional secularism. But cracks are growing. Thus, 37% of LFI supporters are in favor of authorizing veils, kippahs, turbans or crosses in public middle and high schools. The proportion is 33% for communist supporters, 39% for EELV supporters. On the other hand, at LR, the figure is 16% as at RN. Reconquête is at 8%. Emmanuel Macron's voters for their part are at 21%.

LFI supporters are the most in favour of visible religious symbols in middle and high schools.

Is being religious being anti-secular?
Does the claimed affiliation to a religion have an impact on the relationship to the 2004 law? Yes and no. Thus, only 23% of practicing Catholics are in favor of wearing conspicuous religious symbols in middle and high schools, exactly the same as the national average. But those that Ifop modestly describes as believers "of another religion" are 59%... Among those without religion, the rate is 20%.
Religious in the cities, lay people in the countryside?
Ifop also highlights a split based on place of residence. The more urban the area, the stronger the desire to do away with the 2004 law. In fact, 34% of people living in the Paris metropolitan area say they are in favor of the presence of veils, kippas, turbans or other crosses in public middle and high schools, compared to 22% in provincial towns and 18% in rural municipalities. Which is consistent with the political map. Are LFI voters the "least secular"? They are elected in the "least secular" areas since 40% of them are located in the Ile-de-France region.
Identikit portrait of the Frenchman who defends the return of conspicuous religious symbols in middle and high schools: a young man aged 18-24, living in the Paris metropolitan area, a voter for Jean Luc Mélenchon and probably of Muslim culture or faith.
A composite portrait of the French person who does not want the return of ostentatious religious symbols in middle and high schools: a rather elderly person living in a rural area, rather right-wing and without any particular religion. 

Three years ago, Ifop asked a representative sample of French people the following question: “ Personally, would you be in favor of or opposed to students in public middle and high schools wearing conspicuous religious symbols such as headscarves, kippahs, turbans, or crosses?” The result: only 25% of respondents were in favor of promoting religious symbols. In May 2023, the institute asked the same question, and the situation had changed little, with the proportion remaining at 23%.

In terms of social status, education level, or wealth, there are few striking differences. However, several indicators reveal the French who wish to abolish the law of March 15, 2004, " regulating, in application of the principle of secularism, the wearing of signs or clothing manifesting a religious affiliation . "

Generation gap

There is a real generation gap on the issue. The situation has the merit of clarity: the younger you are, the more you are in favour of wearing conspicuous religious symbols. Thus, 46% of 18-24 year-olds are, the highest percentage in the study. The proportion drops to 32% among 25-34 year-olds, to 23% among 35-49 year-olds, to 17% among 50-64 year-olds and then to 14% among those over 65.

On the other hand, the study does not explain the reasons for this divide. Are young people more religious than their elders? Are they influenced by Anglo-Saxon communitarianism? Attached to the individual freedom to dress as one pleases? It would be interesting to conduct a survey on this gap which could, in the long term, put "French-style secularism" in danger.

46% of 18-24 year olds want to allow conspicuous religious symbols in middle and high schools compared to 14% of over 65s

Left right divide

Georges Clemenceau, Léon Blum, Jean Jaurès, Georges Marchais and the great figures of the Republican left of the 19th and 20th centuries must be turning in their graves. Formerly intransigent on questions of secularism, the left is becoming the political faction that most wants the return of religious symbols in the "Temples" of the Republic that are public middle and high schools.

Of course, the French left remain attached to traditional secularism. But cracks are growing. Thus, 37% of LFI supporters are in favor of authorizing veils, kippahs, turbans or crosses in public middle and high schools. The proportion is 33% for communist supporters, 39% for EELV supporters. On the other hand, at LR, the figure is 16% as at RN. Reconquête is at 8%. Emmanuel Macron's voters for their part are at 21%.

LFI supporters are the most in favour of visible religious symbols in middle and high schools.

Is being religious being anti-secular?

Does professed religious affiliation have an impact on attitudes towards the 2004 law? Yes and no. For example, only 23% of practicing Catholics support the wearing of conspicuous religious symbols in middle and high schools, exactly the same as the national average. But among those whom Ifop euphemistically calls believers " of another religion," the figure is 59%... Among those with no religion, the rate is 20%.

Religious in the cities, lay people in the countryside?

Ifop also highlights a split based on place of residence. The more urban the area, the stronger the desire to do away with the 2004 law. In fact, 34% of people living in the Paris metropolitan area say they are in favor of the presence of veils, kippas, turbans or other crosses in public middle and high schools, compared to 22% in provincial towns and 18% in rural municipalities. Which is consistent with the political map. Are LFI voters the "least secular"? They are elected in the "least secular" areas since 40% of them are located in the Ile-de-France region.

Composite portrait of the Frenchman who defends the return of conspicuous religious symbols in middle and high schools: a young man of 18-24 years old, living in the Paris metropolitan area, a voter of Jean Luc Mélenchon and probably of Muslim culture or faith.

The typical profile of a Frenchman who does not want the return of conspicuous religious symbols in middle and high schools: a rather elderly person living in a rural area, rather right-wing and without any particular religion.

 

"This post is a summary of information from our information monitoring"

Author

[side_notes]

Right of reply and contributions
Would you like to respond? Submit an opinion piece proposal →

You might also like:

Defending video games is a philosophical imperative in the face of a perverse state.

A state that presents itself as a protector while treating parents as incapable minors, and children as subjects to be removed from reality, builds a society where no one is accountable for transmission.

Review of Nadia Geerts' book: "The Tweet Affair: Gaza or the Defeat of Reason" (H&O, 2026)

Starting from the controversy sparked by a tweet about Gaza, Nadia Geerts delivers a personal testimony which becomes a reflection on the ravages of conformism, disinformation and the rejection of facts in Western democracies.
What you have left to read
0 %

Maybe you should subscribe?

Otherwise, it's okay! You can close this window and continue reading.

    Register: