Self-censorship and ideology: a threat to scientific research
The University Ethics Observatory recently published a post describing the harmful effects of self-censorship on the quality of research. No, journals should not issue ideological directives regarding the content of submitted articles. No, researchers should not refrain from publishing research whose conclusions do not conform to a certain orthodoxy. No, we should not abandon the principles of evidence-based medicine to appease a self-righteous segment of the population. Let us remember how many philosophers and scientists have had to circumvent the fear of censorship in order to publish their work and reflections. Galileo, Spinoza, and Descartes are the first names that come to mind, but there were so many others! Who could have written and published, until the emergence of the Enlightenment, that God did not exist? If the Springer Nature group had existed in the 17th and 18th centuries , it would surely have published " new ethical guidelines to eliminate potential harm to believers who do not participate in the research but who might be hurt by its publication ." Replace "believers" with "human groups" and you have verbatim what Nature Human Behaviour published.
We also denounced the abuses of DEI ( Diversity, Equity, Inclusion ) in American universities, a smokescreen for social inequalities, primarily intended to give a clear conscience to a certain "elite" and to provide positions for diversity professionals with master's degrees in all sorts of "studies": "gender" studies, "race" studies [1] Americans still haven't grasped that what they call "race" in the human species is simply a different distribution of genetic polymorphisms across ethnicities, with inter- and intra-ethnic overlaps. , "fat" studies [2] How do you translate " fat studies "?, and others. Marx has been relegated to the antiquities store; there's no longer any interest in the living conditions of the poorest (those who were called "proletarians" at the time) or in establishing a "social elevator" that isn't constantly broken down, but only in their equitable representation in genomic databases. Biomedical research must be objective and not concerned with pleasing others… Will obesity be removed from the list of diseases as was done by replacing “gender identity disorder” with “gender dysphoria” [3] See source ? Obesity is a factor in premature death and requires therapeutic intervention, while gender dysphoria [4] Which is better called pubertal sex anxiety today. is “treated” by mutilation and lifelong medication… We must not play with the health of those who entrust themselves to us and pander to their wishes; the Hippocratic Oath forbids it.
When politics enters medicine
And now, even greater absurdities are taking hold in the United States. The new president wants to impose, through an executive order, a certain form of care for minors suffering from this pubertal gender anxiety. This is not his role. A political leader, whether or not one agrees with their economic or social views, should not be issuing medical directives under the guise of common sense. Therapeutic protocols are established based on scientific data, not on a "common sense" that is all too often hypothetical. "Common sense" tells us the earth is flat; science tells us that's false. "Common sense" tells us there are two sexes; science tells us that's true. We cannot rely on our "senses" to state scientific facts, but rather on the analysis of our observations and experiments. Among the issues surrounding gender dysphoria, which I follow quite closely, it turns out that the most influential American organization producing standards of care worldwide, the WPATH ( World Professional Association for Transgender Health ), among other things that discredit its supposedly evidence-based recommendations , committed a major scientific fraud by asking experts from Johns Hopkins University to provide conclusions before they had even completed their assessments. The fact that the President of the United States pointed out this fraud, as we did before him, does not change the fact that it was committed! And it significantly undermines the credibility of this organization.
Between Wokeism and Trumpism: Science in Peril
Let's not be mistaken! Trump did indeed declare (as if he had decided it) that there are two sexes, male and female, but he didn't declare that the earth was round, another obvious point, simply because flat-Earthers vote for him [5] A formulation I borrow from François Rastier . If his opponents hadn't sunk into the web of nonsense about the number of sexes, which I denounced in an article [6] Robert J. "Biology, martyr of philosophers." Innov Ther Oncol 2023; 9: 179-184. , perhaps he would have refrained from such bombast! But then, his presidential opponent, Kamala Harris, used curious language, stating her pronouns before her speeches, saying in an interview that you can never be too woke, and, when she was a prosecutor, requesting that gender reassignment surgeries be covered for inmates who wanted them, even though childbirth costs women at least $12,000, etc. She lost six million voters compared to the 2020 election: three million went to Trump and three million abstained… Trump understood this perfectly, and if his voters had largely believed in the existence of five sexes like Fausto-Sterling, he would have declared that there are five sexes! One shouldn't confuse a scientific statement with electioneering flattery…
It would seem, therefore, that we, scientists and doctors, are caught in the vise between "wokism" and "trumpism"! On the "wokism" side, we have to fight against anti-vaxxers, against harmful beliefs spread seemingly at will against the evidence of health. Some believe that one can be born "in the wrong body" and that sex is "assigned at birth" by an ultimately arbitrary decision [7] An article in the New England Journal of Medicine stated in 2020 [doi: 10.1056/NEJMp2025974] that " Leaving any sex designation visible on birth certificates sacrifices privacy and exposes people to discrimination ." ; others are convinced of the benefits of supposedly "alternative" medicines, naturopathy, etiopathy, and other such nonsense; others that obesity results from the gaze of others and that "fatphobia" is a terrible sin; Others believe that veganism is the solution to all dietary imbalances, when in fact it is a major contributing factor; still others find the classic image of active, mobile sperm seeking to penetrate the passive, immobile egg horribly offensive to women. Reason, according to some doctors and biologists, seems to have vanished from the world of science.
On the Trumpian side, for every sensible statement, there are ten that are not. I won't mention the disregard for the fight against climate change, which is not a medical matter, nor the incredible presidential pardon granted to rioters while Dr. Anthony Fauci's protection was revoked, but I cannot fail to recall Trump's ludicrous pronouncements on the treatment of Covid-19 (bleach, ingesting a UV lamp, and even hydroxychloroquine!). The appointment of a Secretary of Health opposed to vaccinations will be remembered as one of the most serious attacks on public health ever perpetrated in a developed country. Let's not get sidetracked by justifying the nonsense of some with the dictates of others; threats against science can come from any direction, and we should not hesitate to denounce them wherever they originate. That the most powerful attack others is inevitable, but not a cause for celebration. The enemies of our adversaries are not our allies: we are next on their list of proscription [8] A formulation I also borrow from François Rastier.
I thank François Rastier, Nathalie Heinich, Vincent Tournier and Caroline Eliacheff for their constructive comments.