by Yana Grinshpun
In his book *This Haunting Pain of Freedom *, addressed to Western readers, Vladimir Bukowsky, a former Russian dissident, human rights defender, and ex-Soviet political prisoner, compared the communist system he escaped with Western democracy. Among other things, he made an interesting observation.
"There is no intellectual discipline more useless, if not more harmful, than history in the questions that concern us. There are as many historical conceptions as there are historians, or rather as many as ideologies require in order to find a foundation. History is only a collection of disparate facts that can be manipulated at will."
Observing and participating in the academic debates of recent years, one cannot help but think back to this analysis, especially in a very particular context, where French universalists are constantly accused of being McCarthyists.
The word is fashionable. Only, it turns out that the word refers neither to the history nor to the practices of the time in which it was born. "McCarthyism" is an accusatory political formula, and the "new McCarthyism" is a formula that is supposed to refer to the return of the reprehensible practices of the past. The scope of the accusation stems not only from the meaning of the word referring to an ideology or social practices, but especially from the positioning of those who utter it. Thus, when we accuse someone of belonging to the "extreme right" or of being "racist" it is because we are not one ourselves. This is how the McCarthyist is always the other. But what does this word refer to and who are these new McCarthyists?
McCarthyism or witch hunts here and elsewhere.
I am writing this article not only as a French academic but also as a former Soviet who still remembers the abundant Soviet prose on this movement. When talking about McCarthyism, the official Soviet history and the official history of the United States taught in France describe it in the same negative way. McCarthyism (a word invented by the American cartoonist Herbert Block in 1950) refers to an ideological movement embodied by the figure of Senator Joseph McCarthy, presented as the servant of the capitalist regime, enemy of pluralism, executioner of free thought who hunted down people suspected of having relations with the Soviet communists or of being sympathizers of this regime, between 1950 and 1954. "McCarthyism" is thus the name of an official anti-communist period in the USA. It is a period of cold war between the USA and the USSR. Its emergence is linked to the very real danger that communism represented in its Stalinist version imposed by force on the populations of Eastern Europe and certain Asian countries. During the years of the "Cold War", the USA was infested with a vast network of Soviet spies, designed and developed by the Soviet State Political Directorate, supported by the American Communist Party, financed by the Soviet Union and certain organizations of the American radical left. It was at this time, for example, that the New York communist couple, Ethel and Julius Rosenberg, transmitted plans for the nuclear bomb to the USSR via Klaus Fuchs. Harry Dexter White facilitated the infiltration of Soviet agents into the United States Treasury Department. Wisconsin State Senator Joseph McCarthy and his team then attacked American officials suspected of being disloyal, banned the publication and distribution of communist literature in certain states, prepared "black" lists of personalities sympathetic to the communist regime. It is established by historians that nearly three thousand people suffered from allegations, real or invented, of relations with the communists, of espionage or sympathies for the USSR. Meanwhile, in the paradise of communism, millions of people rotted in Soviet camps and prisons because they criticized the communist regime, which called itself "progressive" and "emancipatory", millions of people were "re-educated" by the communist regime throughout Eastern Europe to better appreciate the fruits of this ideological marvel. These were also years when the "white coats affair" was being prepared in the former USSR, when all literature that criticized the communist regime was banned (both in Russia and throughout Eastern Europe).
At the time, these points of detail did not bother the Western left, which, in the name of its "progressivism", preferred to make "McCarthyism" a synonym for "persecution", reaction and unqualified conservatism, forgetting that the Cold War was above all ideological and political and opposed liberal democracies to communist totalitarianism, which the American government of the time feared and rightly so, given the very real infiltration of the USA by Russian spies or sympathisers.
Thus, the term "McCarthyism" as it is used today has little to do with its origins, and does not refer to anti-communist ideology, but has connotations evoking surveillance, denunciation and persecution. If it is detached from the context of the Cold War, its use is based on a negative vision of the fight against communist infiltration by presenting censorship and ostracization as arbitrary practices, while they had their sources in a very real conflict.
Thus, when the reviews of the Observatory of Decolonialism and the Tribune of the Hundred Intellectuals note that the University is becoming the place of a seizure of power by the proponents of the decolonial discourse which professes that we are still in a world where decolonization has not taken place, that there exists a "state racism" based on "white privilege", that women are an "oppressed minority", that any critical speech of religious practices linked to Islam is "racist" and "Islamophobic", they are immediately called "new McCarthyists".
Following our alerts, thousands of academics immediately presented themselves as victims of the "witch hunt initiated by the signatories of the manifesto of the hundred" ( here ), accusing them through the media, personal messages and social networks of holding the speeches of the "ultra-right" ( here ), comparing them to whistleblowers ( here ), giving them lessons in loyalty to the institution, explaining to them what is correct and what is not, accusing them of being "the thought police" ( here) and, in the latest news, of "smelling bad" according to Aphatie. Meanwhile, the CPU denies the existence of these phenomena, the CNRS offers lessons in "new analytical frameworks," Mélenchon once again invokes McCarthyism, and Blanchard presents himself as a victim of a "witch hunt" initiated by the great villainous persecutor Pierre-André Taguieff and his "new war machine," the Observatory of Decolonialism. Victimhood inversion is decidedly the new lens through which we view the world.
On the other hand, when conferences by philosophers and political scientists are cancelled because they are too critical of Islamism and radicalisation, when researchers are dragged through the mud on social networks and on respectable university sites because they criticise racialist, indigenous and anti-Zionist discourses, the androphobic postulates of radical neo-feminism, the inclusivism that has imposed itself on the academic world; when colleagues send intimidating letters signed by lawyers to their adversaries to silence them, or when they are threatened with death because they dared to criticise Islam, then a part of the academic world uses other formulas, those of the worn-out Marxist archive and mended with politically correct sauce. It is then a question of "emancipation", "progress", "living together", "diversity", and "inclusion" and, of course, "real science". These formulas then have an explanatory, "scientific" function, which rejects all doubt and all ambivalence of reality. They activate large moral categories which are supposed to be indisputable and designate as "reactionaries" and "fascists" and "McCarthyists" all those who question the validity of these categorical victim imperatives.
As Vladimir Bukowski rightly noted about Europe, observing this bacchanalia of dominant ideas that use virtuous and moralizing words:
"The fact that political debate is no longer seen solely through the prism of who is "correct" - and who is not - represents for me the greatest threat to freedom since the collapse of communism. When, from a strictly ideological point of view, people decide what is right to say and a large part of their fellow citizens follow them, whether out of stupidity or fear, I see grave dangers looming on the horizon."
So, the nagging question arises: who is a "McCarthyist"?