In an article published in Libération today , Mr. Noiriel describes a difficult balancing act. When questioned about the law on separatism by the journalist, who writes: "Part of the French intelligentsia no longer defends the idea of what France is. Do you agree?", he replies:
“This is pure political polemic, there’s no point dwelling on it. The difficulty of our position lies in the fact that we are on a knife-edge between two camps: on one side, we are accused of failing to recognize the violence perpetrated against racial minorities when we warn against the overemphasis on ‘race’ in sociological analysis; on the other, we are co-opted by a form of universalism that often tends to underestimate issues of discrimination and racism.”
https://www.liberation.fr/idees-et-debats/mettre-systematiquement-laccent-sur-la-race-neglige-les-appartenances-multiples-des-individus-20210203_Z54ALVCCGNCS5PXRZLSYYSECDU/
For us, the question is simple: there is a scientific issue, and science is not limited to “understanding social facts”.
Speech facts
Job offer at the University:
“The Maison des Sciences de l'Homme et de la Société (MSHS-T) and its branch at Ut1 Capitole are recruiting a junior researcher (postdoctoral level) for a 12-month temporary position at the intersection of social sciences and digital/computational studies to help produce, implement, and evaluate a tool designed to regulate online hate speech within the framework of the interdisciplinary project called Hatemeter . This position is part of a European project aimed at developing a tool to monitor, analyze, and combat anti-Muslim hate.”
http://www.cnrs.fr/infoslabos/bourses-postdocs/docs/Hatemeter_offre_post-doc.pdf:
Because “hate” is reduced to only “hate” against a religion?
Thesis: "Anti-racist mobilizations and social relations in the Île-de-France region "
" We will thus see how the anti-racist mobilizations triggered from the mid-2000s onwards, by French activists of (post)colonial immigrant background, are part of a struggle for hegemony over the definition of racism in France: collective action contributes to producing intellectuals, who in turn produce theory on social issues. "
http://theses.md.univ-paris-diderot.fr/PICOT_Pauline_2_complete_20190315.pdf
The role of academic work is to "produce social theorists for the hegemony of the definition of racism"?
Article: A French problem since the Enlightenment – The prohibition of Islam – Seloua Luste Boulbina
" This politically correct despotism, called 'Republic' or 'secularism', which is linked to widespread practices of relegation and discrimination, can only exist on the condition that all those who might deviate from what, since the beginning of the 1980s, has become a political and social norm are kept away from the centers of decision-making."
https://www.cairn.info/revue-multitudes-2015-2-page-61.htm
No comment: the Republic or secularism, a despotism. Noted.
Article: The contribution of postcolonial studies and feminisms of the "South" to the constitution of a renewed feminism – Towards the end of Westernism? – Pierre Lénel (CNAM), Virginie Martin (researcher)
“ Requiring migrants to adhere to the norms and values of the Republic and to have a minimum level of language proficiency has contributed to transforming the political discourse on integration into a machine for constructing ethno-racial boundaries within French society .”
https://www.cairn.info/revue-tiers-monde-2012-1-page-125.htm
Ok: the language of the Institution is THE problem of integration.
Article: Becoming Muslim and Becoming White: Conversion to Islam as a Discovery of Whiteness in France and the United States – Juliette Galonnier (Sciences Po, CERI)
Due to the racialization of Islam in France and the United States, those who wear visible signs of belonging to Islam, however, experience a change in the way they are perceived racially: no longer categorized as "white," they are exposed to new forms of stigmatization and discrimination.
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-02081660/
"No longer categorized as white, they suffer discrimination": this is a statement that might require some nuance. "Race" may not be the only conceivable vector of discrimination, right?
Article: Feminisms, the veil and French secularism – Hourya Bentouhami
The " new secularism " formulated by the latter clearly – and paradoxically – explains this reformulation of secularism as being part of a French tradition, in a largely fantasized French spirit , since its paragon and central virtue would be the emancipation of women – the latter becoming a marker of national identity – and for which the unveiling of women's bodies would be the best certificate of authenticity.
https://journals.openedition.org/socio/3471
"The new secularism" is the secularism that you and I know. "The old secularism", in the decolonial imagination, is the secularism that wants "all religions to share public space against the evil secularists who want to ban it".
Conference: The white condition
For over a decade, research on racialization processes has been steadily developing within French social sciences . However, while this research indirectly sheds light on the majority viewpoint, it rarely, if ever, addresses whiteness itself . This symposium therefore aims to encourage reflection that takes as its starting point the question of what we will call the white condition in the French context. We will begin with the idea developed by Whiteness Studies that whiteness is a social status manifested in three main ways. First, thinking of oneself as white presupposes that one is not racializable, while simultaneously considering members of other groups to be so. This sometimes leads to believing oneself authorized to racially assign members of these other groups, that is, to place them in a subordinate position by basing this hierarchical act on the idea of a supposedly radical otherness. Conversely, defining oneself as white also means considering that one maintains a neutral and non-racialized point of view on the world, unlike "others" who are supposedly irremediably anchored to a perspective determined by their race.
https://www.ehess.fr/fr/journ%C3%A9es-d%C3%A9tude/condition-blanche-r%C3%A9flexion-sur-majorit%C3%A9-fran%C3%A7aise
“Race-class” combo, we’ll let you think about it.
Model: Degree in Modern Literature, Degree in Teaching), Paris 8:
“[The aim of the course is] to draw practical lessons from the theoretical contributions of gender, racial, and colonial studies, whose work has shown the domination of the epistemological and artistic field by heterosexual white men ”; and to add that “starting from the observation that the canon constructed by literary history silences and renders invisible authors belonging to minority categories, thus relegating them to the margins of the literary space,” the course proposes a reading program of texts “written by racialized authors from the colonial history .”
https://litterature-francaise.univ-paris8.fr/IMG/pdf/version_provisoire_avril_2020_brochure_licence_lettres_2020-2021.pdf
The artistic field is dominated by white heterosexual men . Take that, Rimbaud, Verlaine, Proust, Villon, Ronsard, Du Bellay, Gide, Senghor, Dumas, etc. Teaching license…
Want more? Some redefinitions in keyword books
"Women's emancipation" - "Injunction" which "reflects above all prejudices". "Accredits a Eurocentric vision of allogenic cultures, whose derogatory accents have a disturbing resemblance to the civilizing aims of colonization". "Each invitation to emancipation" only "assigns to a destiny".
“ But while the weight of family on the daughters of immigrants is a commonplace, the impact of ‘assimilationist’ pressure is less frequently acknowledged. Yet, according to sociologist Nacira Guénif Souilamas, this injunction primarily reflects prejudice: it ‘reinforces a Eurocentric view of foreign cultures, whose derogatory undertones bear a striking resemblance to the civilizing aims of colonization.’ Furthermore, ‘this injunction conceals an insidious reminder of a difference treated as an essential characteristic. Underlying every invitation to emancipation is the reference to the devalued culture from which the girls supposedly cannot escape.’” Demanding that the daughters of immigrants be at the forefront of emancipation and integration is nothing more than assigning them a destiny where being a woman of foreign origin is perceived as an insurmountable condition… »
(Eric Lamien, “Women under the influence”, The world of books, Friday, August 18, 2000, p. 28)
What better way to overcome the condition of a foreign woman than to renounce emancipation?
"Forced marriages": An expression that betrays "a Eurocentric view": preferring to speak of "compromised marriages". A nice comparison to make with the matrimonial strategies of "the French aristocracy".
"[…] sociologist Nacira Guénif, a specialist in young girls of Maghreb origin […] prefers to talk about compromised marriage rather than forced marriage. Ms. Guénif readily compares the attitude of immigrant parents to that of the French aristocracy – in both cases, it is a question of perpetuating a threatened world. “Talking about forced marriage is having a Eurocentric viewpoint,” she says, “we must not forget that it still existed in France until very recently.” For the sociologist, “it is not withdrawal,” but a way “of exploiting the limited resources available in the country where we are,” since “a son, a daughter, educated in France, has value.” Perpetuation of the migratory process (the spouse obtains the right to reside), respect for alliances between families, issues of dowries, concern for tradition… The motivations are multiple […].”
(Marie-Pierre Subtil, “Forced marriages tear apart immigrant families”, Le Monde, Monday, April 3, 2000, p. 8)
“ Community withdrawal” – “This is in no way a community withdrawal, but simply an adaptation.”
“ What accounts for this ‘retreat’ into the private sphere? It is in no way a retreat into community, but simply an adaptation, because the institutional means of emancipation are less accessible. The intersecting issues of exclusion, youth unemployment, and identity have obscured the paths to integration. […] [Young women from immigrant backgrounds] are perfectly aware of the professional difficulties to come. In this, however, they prove that they are integrated: they have internalized the changes in French society and are aware that they have no other option than to give up certain things in order to obtain others, more attainable.”
(Nacira Guénif Souilamas, interview in Le Monde, Tuesday March 11, 1997, p. 12)
Want more? Read the decolonial books and theses in our database.