Observatoire academic ethics
Menu

Society – Trans people, parenthood, inclusion: the battles to come, 10 years after marriage for all

Society – Trans people, parenthood, inclusion: the battles to come, 10 years after marriage for all

Collective

Observers' Tribune

Table of contents

Society – Trans people, parenthood, inclusion: the battles to come, 10 years after marriage for all

Read More Transgender people, parenthood, inclusion: the battles are far from over today, 10 years after marriage equality. Transgender rights. The societal polarization experienced in 2013 with the legalization of marriage equality has been repeated in the last two years regarding transgender rights. Since 2021, the SOS Homophobie association has noted an increase in reports of transphobia, especially in shops and government offices, online, and even within families. According to the association, one reason for this increase lies in "statements by political and media figures displaying a hostile stance in order to create a pseudo-debate on the very existence of transgender people." Today, associations are campaigning, in particular, for the right to self-determination: the possibility for a person to define their identity and their potential transition process for themselves, the latter still being subject to validation by psychiatrists, doctors, and sometimes judges. The goal is to facilitate and depathologize transition processes. Transphobia remains a daily and violent reality for those affected, who are victims of societal rejection and ignorance. This is why organizations like Outrans provide training to organizations within their respective sectors (health, education, HR, etc.) to raise awareness about trans identities and the inclusion of transgender people. Regarding parenthood, the law of May 17, 2013, also granted adoption rights to same-sex couples. Then, in August 2021, access to medically assisted reproduction (MAR) for all women allowed for joint recognition of parenthood for lesbian couples. For Dominique Boren, co-president of the Association of Gay and Lesbian Parents, "there are still gaps in the system." The MAR law does not recognize the legal parentage of a transgender man. Added to this are co-parenting arrangements (involving more than two parents) which are not legally recognized, even though "these families didn't wait to have rights to exist," the activist asserts. Adoption is also a source of discrimination. "The decree providing for the inclusion of LGBT associations in family councils has not been published since the law was passed more than a year ago," points out Lucile Jomat, administrator and former president of SOS Homophobie, adding that these bodies remain hesitant about same-sex parenting projects. Finally, surrogacy is illegal in France. Faced with the ethical questions justifying this prohibition, associations are calling for a debate to regulate this practice, as some families, particularly those of gay men, are currently resorting to it abroad. Christiane Taubira: "Doing good for people in their daily lives, the pinnacle of political action." Not to tolerate, to include. Even in 2022, the Flag! association... SOS Homophobie received nearly 1.800 reports of LGBTI violence through its dedicated app. More than 1.500 testimonies were collected through SOS Homophobie's various listening services (not counting the 3.035 accesses to its online support platform last year). All of this demonstrates that the fight for the inclusion of LGBTI people is far from over. Discrimination mechanisms begin as early as school and are not specific to LGBTIphobia. The prejudices that arise there lead to violent behavior. The suicide of young Lucas, harassed by his classmates because he did not hide his homosexuality, in early 2023, is a tragic example. These behaviors, "originating in schools, are repeated among adults," notes SOS Homophobie in its 2023 Report on LGBTIphobia. "The victim is very often isolated, facing a group of people who stigmatize them daily, both at work and elsewhere." All contexts are still subject to discrimination against LGBTI people today. This is why associations remain committed to raising awareness among the general public, as well as within the health, education, sports, and business sectors, etc. Nicolas Certes

Trans people, parenthood, inclusion: there is no shortage of struggles today, 10 years after marriage for all.

Trans rights

Trans rights. The polarization of society experienced in 2013 with marriage for all has been repeated in the last two years around trans rights.

Since 2021, the association SOS homophobie has noted an increase in reports of transphobia, especially in businesses and administrations, online but also in families. One of the origins of this increase, according to the association, lies in "the speeches of political and media figures displaying a hostile position with a view to creating a pseudo debate on the very existence of trans people."

Today, associations are campaigning in particular for a right to self-determination: the possibility for a person to define their identity and their possible transition path by themselves, the latter still being subject to validation by psychiatrists, doctors and sometimes judges. The objective is to facilitate and depathologize transition paths.

Transphobia remains a daily and violent experience for those affected, victims of rejection and ignorance from society. This is why associations like Outrans train organizations according to their sector of activity (health, education, HR, etc.) to raise massive awareness of trans identities and the reception of trans people.

Parenting

The law of May 17, 2013 also opened the right to adoption for homosexual couples. Then, in August 2021, access to medically assisted procreation (MAP) for all women allowed joint recognition of the parenthood of lesbian couples.

For Dominique Boren, co-president of the Association of Gay and Lesbian Parents, "there are still holes in the racket." The PMA law does not recognize filiation as the father of a trans man. Added to this are co-parenting projects (with more than two parents) that are not legally recognized even though "these families did not wait to have rights to exist," assures the activist.

Adoption is also a source of discrimination. "The decree providing for the inclusion of LGBT associations in family councils has not been published since the law was passed over a year ago," points out Lucile Jomat, administrator and former president of SOS homophobie, adding that these bodies remain cautious about homoparental projects.

Finally, surrogacy is illegal in France. Given the ethical issues that justify this ban, the associations are calling for a debate to be opened to regulate this practice because some families, particularly gay men, are now resorting to it abroad.

Christiane Taubira: “Doing good for people in their daily lives, the pinnacle of political action”

Do not tolerate, include

In 2022, the Flag! association received nearly 1.800 reports of LGBTI violence via its dedicated application. More than 1.500 testimonies were collected via the various SOS homophobie listening devices (not counting the 3.035 accesses to its online help platform last year).

So many elements showing that the battles to be fought for the inclusion of LGBTI people are not over. From school, the mechanisms of discrimination are triggered and are not specific to LGBTIphobias. The prejudices that arise there lead to violent behavior.

The example of the suicide of young Lucas, harassed by his classmates because he did not hide his homosexuality, in early 2023, is tragic proof of this. These behaviors "born in the school environment are repeated among adults", notes SOS homophobia in its Report on LGBTIphobias 2023. "The victim is very often isolated in front of a group of people who stigmatize him daily, in his workplace but also outside". 

All contexts are still subject to discrimination for LGBTI people today. This is why associations remain committed to raising awareness among the general public but also in the health, education, sports, business sectors, etc.

Nicolas Certainly

 

"This post is a summary of information from our information monitoring"

Author

[side_notes]

Right of reply and contributions
Would you like to respond? Submit an opinion piece proposal →

You might also like:

Back to school 2026: the ongoing monitoring

The start of the academic year is traditionally a time for announcements: new courses, new seminars, calls for proposals, conferences, and research programs outline the direction of the coming year. At the Observatory, we consider it our mission to document this academic news, make it accessible, and preserve a record of it. Saclay, Sorbonne, Nanterre, Sciences Po—it's all covered...

The Forbidden Book: Ferghane Azihari Against Islam

Ferghane Azihari's latest essay offers a critique of Islam, which he portrays as inherently hostile to modernity, freedom, and progress. Despite its publishing success, Vincent Tournier has noted a silence or reluctance in the media to discuss these ideas.
What you have left to read
0 %

Maybe you should subscribe?

Otherwise, it's okay! You can close this window and continue reading.

    Register: