Observatoire academic ethics
Menu

On the ideology of care: the return of a soft fanaticism

Illustration for the article "On the ideology of care: the return of a soft fanaticism"

On the ideology of care: the return of a soft fanaticism

Collective

Observers' Tribune

Table of contents

This article has no sections.

On the ideology of care: the return of a soft fanaticism

By Charles Coutel

The matter was thought to have been settled in the 2000s with the debate within the parliamentary left between Manuel Valls and Martine Aubry; we sincerely believed we were done with the ideology of care . However, a recent publication by Sandra Laugier and Najat Vallaud-Belkacem, * La société des victimes* (Gallimard, "Tracts" collection, 2020), has reignited the debate.

A media campaign is developing and it is the latest chic to invite the former minister to present her text. The Care Bears camp seems to be swooning again. Taking advantage of the economic, social and health disarray of our fellow citizens, we are invited to make Marianne cry at a time when it is a question of comforting and strengthening her.

Arguing that the English term "care " (to take care of), duly distinguished from " cure" (to treat), is untranslatable, we are lectured and invited to broaden our understanding of care in order to finally give a voice to those who suffer. Hence the thesis put forward by Sandra Laugier: "Vulnerability and dependence are part of the human condition." (see the interview published in Le Monde on October 29, 2020).

And to add insult to injury, half of humankind is dismissed: only women are deemed capable of caring for the vulnerable. To be convinced of this, one can refer to Fabienne Brugère's book: *The Sex of Solicitude* (Seuil, 2008). Sandra Laugier concludes: "Our society must be a society of the vulnerable […] a profound transformation is essential." ( ibid .) We can note the same peremptory tone as that of the fanatics of decolonialism, gender theory, and intersectionality. From a working hypothesis and a topic of study, care has become an "ethic," then an "anthropology," and finally a directly political project. A politically correct (and self-righteous ) left is summoned to convert to this new gospel. From a sometimes short-sighted economism, which considered the fragility of citizens solely in terms of the precariousness of their situations, it is invited to adopt a compassionate vision of the world; as if by defining ourselves as vulnerable by nature, we should aspire to be protected for life.

Being vulnerable and dependent would make us receptive to a protective and "reassuring" discourse. Yet, as early as 2006, Didier Sicard warned us, with the ideology of care : "Protection takes precedence over liberation (for oneself), while we demand liberation (for others)." He continues: "Doesn't our need for protection ultimately make us exchangeable, commodifiable?" (See The Ethical Alibi , Plon, p. 13) Accepting submission appears as a desirable outcome, since the State presents itself as "benevolent."

Through this ideology of care , the welfare state is called upon to become the lifelong protector state. However, in this "demonstration," everything needs to be re-examined, as sophistry vies with simplistic shortcuts and ideological power plays.

The difficulty with this idea of ​​care is that it seems to have gained traction not only within republican and humanist circles, but also within training centers for healthcare and social work. Distancing oneself from it appears as a sign of culpable indifference, a relic of the old world, the pre-pandemic era. Consequently, populations are infantilized, and attempts are made to intimidate and guilt-trip those who resist. The same tactics are at work among the "decolonial" movement and its ilk.

The critical duty of republicans and humanists

Faced with this “compassionate onslaught,” to borrow Myriam Revault d’Allonnes’s phrase, republicans must wield the weapons of criticism. As early as 2008, she pointed us toward a critical path: “This promotion of neighborliness has little to do with the conquest of a universality that […] proceeded by progressive distancing from feeling.” (see * L’homme compassionnel *, Le Seuil, 2008, p. 96) These proponents of care commit several logical errors that their provocative rhetoric masks.

The first mistake lies in essentializing vulnerability. But isn't the very word " vulnerability" contradictory? It comes from the Latin *vulnus * (wound), yet the human condition is precisely mortality , not some vague vulnerability: for if I am wounded… I am no longer vulnerable, but if I am vulnerable, it is because I am not wounded… and wounded or not, I remain mortal . Haven't we invented this fiction of vulnerability to forget our mortality? What is so dangerous about this first logical fallacy is that it can generate the opposite sophism: declaring oneself invulnerable by nature, with the deadly, even terrorist, consequences that need not be reiterated here. In the humanist tradition, to philosophize is to learn how to die, not to take refuge in some improbable vulnerability.

The second logical error lies in the essentialization of feminism. While the historical struggle of feminists has always defined itself as an expansion of human equality, proponents of care distort this initial emancipatory process into one of exclusion and guilt-tripping of men alone, reducing them to the status of mere males . Hence, too, this gendered approach to care, again severed from its humanist and universalist emancipatory power. In this process of exclusion, other fanatics will add: colonialists, chauvinists, whites, and Westerners…

The third logical fallacy is more technical. It corresponds to the temptation of all those who confuse ideology and science: the holistic temptation, which amounts to using empty generalities to counter all criticism, as Tocqueville already feared. We are immediately urged to put ourselves "in the other's shoes" in the name of an empathy that is never defined…

Thus, the ideology of care, combining all these logical flaws, gradually becomes the spiritual essence of a social order that is anti-republican, anti-humanist, and anti-universalist. It therefore falls to all humanists to organize resistance against this ideology of care, remembering the philosopher Alain's dictum that "to cradle is not to instruct"; likewise, to cradle is not to heal.

In 2015, seemingly responding to Najat Vallaud-Belkacem, Francesco Paolo Adorno summarized this entire ideological operation in his book "Should We Worry About Care ?" (Éditions de l'Olivier, 2015, p. 14): "It is as if, faced with the impossibility of creating a more just society, left-wing political forces were trying to retreat to more concrete and, above all, more modest objects [...] would care embody this new politics?"

Share this article

Facebook X LinkedIn

Right of reply and contributions
Would you like to respond? Submit an opinion piece proposal →

You might also like:

We lived side by side – The journey of a “little white guy” from the suburbs.

Blending autobiography and analysis, Alexandre Devecchio recounts the metamorphosis of Seine-Saint-Denis, from an assimilated suburb to a deeply fractured territory, while also hinting at a possible reconciliation. A review and a pastiche by Lucien Vollesan.

Marc Bloch and antisemitism: a contemporary instrumentalization

That a great medieval historian, a member of the Resistance and a victim of the Nazis as well as some French citizens, executed in 1945, should be honored in this way is certainly cause for celebration. More questionable, however, are a number of instances of appropriation and misappropriation that are not only the work of politicians, but also originate within the historical profession itself. This is nothing new.
What you have left to read
0 %

Maybe you should subscribe?

Otherwise, it's okay! You can close this window and continue reading.

    Register: