Observatoire academic ethics
Menu

Decolonial-indigenist syllogism

Illustration for the article "Decolonial-Indigenous Syllogism"

Decolonial-indigenist syllogism

Collective

Observers' Tribune

Table of contents

This article has no sections.

Decolonial-indigenist syllogism

By Sahar Spivak and Suha Al-Qasim (NRC Decolonial Logic Laboratory)

Decolonial and indigenous studies, the Copernican revolution in human and social sciences. 

Decolonial-indigenist syllogism:

Hourija Bouteldja says she is Mohamed Merah.
Mohamed Merah is dead.
Therefore, Hourija Bouteldja is dead.

Introduction

Since Galileo and until the beginning of the 20th century a scientific revolution took place in physics. It was crowned by the development of general relativity and the formulation of quantum mechanics that we owe to brilliant thinkers like Albert Einstein and some contemporaries like Ernest Schroedinger or Werner Heisenberg. This revolution produced a way of thinking that no longer places man and his mode of perception at the center of the world. With Galileo it is the earth that revolves around the sun, with Einstein and Schroedinger the definition of space, time, matter showed that they are radically opposed to our immediate sensory mode of perception.

These epistemological revolutions have challenged the imagination of men and women of all ages, and of all races (white, black, yellow, mixed race), all religions (Jewish, Christian, Muslim, Buddhist, animist, communist, anti-speciesist, etc.), of all sexual identities (transgender, queer, bisexual, hermaphrodite, and dare we name them, the reactionary racist, sexist and somewhat fascist white cisgender heterosexuals). We apologize if we have forgotten those who do not recognize themselves in these identities. No one is perfect, even the researchers of the decolonial CNRS who are sensitive to all forms of discrimination.

Human and social sciences: epistemological advances

Another scientific and epistemological revolution is at work today, just a century after Albert Einstein and Ernest Schrodinger, but in the field of Human and Social Sciences. Decolonial studies, queer neo-feminism, deconstructionist theories, coming in particular from the United States, are disrupting an obscurantist ready-to-think, which has wrongly placed the white cisgender colonizing and heterosexual man at the center of the world. 

We owe this second Copernican revolution to researchers, geniuses and heifers, irrigated by state and taxpayer money that zealous senior officials know how to use to best effect to improve the quality of public services, from hospitals to scientific and university research. 

Thus, decolonial studies have been a major advance in understanding race-gender-identity relations, and have finally allowed us to understand that the world is divided into oppressive identities and oppressed identities. Arabs and blacks are victims of whites, women are victims of men, homosexuals are victims of heterosexuals. The disabled are victims of able-bodied people, the young are victims of the old, the fat are victims of the thin. Palestinian bombers are victims of colonial Israeli Jews living illegally in the future state of Palestine, in violation of international law which prohibits Jews from living in a state that should have existed if they did not exist there.

Intersectionality

The scientific revolution doesn't stop there; its major advance is the fundamental notion of intersectionality. The basic idea is that the intersection of two victim groups is a subgroup with a higher degree of victimization ; the same is true of the intersection of two oppressor groups—their degree of oppression is higher.

So the old fat black gay Palestinian disabled women with or without explosive belts are the paragon of victim identity. The persecutor group par excellence being the young thin white Jewish Western and heterosexual cisgender able-bodied men (at least before the belt explodes).

Results of decolonial research

We now turn to some of the scientific findings of decolonial studies, and studies of oppressive and victim identities. We draw on the readings of decolonial scholars such as Shlomo Sand, Colette Guillaumin, Monique Wittig, Ilan Pappe, Houria Bouteldja, and Norman Finkielstein. 

Since the work of the Israeli decolonial researcher (yes! yes! it exists!) Shlomo Sand, we know that Jews have Khazar ancestors and that Jews do not exist. Thus a new historical and scientific window has opened and it is entirely legitimate, thanks to the work of Shlomo Sand, to speak of the genocide of the Khazars rather than the extermination of the Jews by the Nazis, as Western revisionists do. It is also more logical to speak of the Khazar state in the Middle East which replaced the state of Palestine which had existed at least since Jesus Christ. See on this subject the work of another renowned researcher, Mahmoud Abbas, billionaire representative of the oppressed: Jesus Christ was a Palestinian Arab. Which clearly shows that when the indisputable scientific reference work, the Koran, points out the Jewish imposture in the reworking of Islamic and Christian texts, it is an undeniable truth.

We also know that the French people do not exist. Indeed, most of the inhabitants of France have as ancestors Germans, Alsatians, Spaniards, Chinese, Maghrebians, Italians, Vietnamese, Franks, Romans, Jews, Africans, etc. The list is long, we apologize to those we have forgotten. 

Unthought of decolonialism

Since peoples are not defined culturally but by biological heritage, Shlomo Sand raises a crucial question here, which remains a major unthought of in decolonial research. 

  1. Aren't humans with Australopithecine ancestors Australopithecine impostors? Interdisciplinary research combining decolonialism, paleontology and genetics would fully justify funding from an ANR or ERC.

b) the work of Monique Wittig, we also know that men have women as ancestors. Thus, there are no men but women who believe themselves to be men. Women, having men as ancestors, do not exist either. Since neither women nor men exist, humanity is only a construction, an invention and therefore humanity does not exist. But since these authors are human, and humanity does not exist, these authors do not exist either.

We still have to write a scholarly work, "How I stopped being human," in order to perfect the Copernican revolution of the Cartesian Cogito. "I am not, therefore I do not think." QED. 

Share this article

Facebook X LinkedIn

Right of reply and contributions
Would you like to respond? Submit an opinion piece proposal →

You might also like:

Eric Naulleau's lesson in political sociology

A fresh perspective on Eric Naulleau's book. A powerful book. Not only for the sheer pleasure of reading it—its style is by turns serious and light, acerbic and nostalgic, moving and unsettling—but also for the social and historical significance of its subject matter. Beyond the chronicle of deeply personal life experiences, it offers insight into a collective future that we often prefer to ignore.

The review of sentences in the Paty trial

It is time to break with these legal ambiguities that undermine the social contract. The restoration of the Republic requires a justice system that names terrorism without euphemism, a massive revaluation of the teaching profession, and a secularism that yields nothing to fanaticism. Samuel Paty did not die so that his indirect murderers could benefit from reduced sentences in the name of an ill-informed youth or insufficiently proven intent. Let us protect the public education system, or accept its decline and the end of republican meritocracy. The time for leniency is over.
What you have left to read
0 %

Maybe you should subscribe?

Otherwise, it's okay! You can close this window and continue reading.

    Register: