Observatoire academic ethics
Menu

Critical Race Theory, Reading Note for Mr. Pap NDiaye and Other Zealots of the New Racism

Illustration for the article "Critical Race Theory, a reading note for Mr. Pap NDiaye and other proponents of the new racism"

Critical Race Theory, Reading Note for Mr. Pap NDiaye and Other Zealots of the New Racism

Collective

Observers' Tribune
"Identify and challenge the ways in which mathematics is used to defend capitalist, imperialist, and racist views. Expose students to examples of people who have used mathematics as a means of resistance. Provide learning opportunities that use mathematics as a means of resistance.".... Shall we continue?

Table of contents

This article has no sections.

Critical Race Theory, Reading Note for Mr. Pap NDiaye and Other Zealots of the New Racism

This document may be reproduced freely, in part or in full, provided the source is explicitly cited as follows: Morneau-Guérin, F., Santarossa, D., Boyer, C. (2022). Dismantling racism in mathematics education and the cobra effect. Montreal: Éditions de l'apprentissage , collection Des points sur les i et des barres sur les t.

Foreword 

This text was written in the fall of 2021, then submitted in January 2022 to the Bulletin of the Quebec Mathematical Association . In October 2022, the editorial committee had still not managed, it seems, to find two " informed and relevant " arbitrators (these are the words of the editor-in-chief).

Ideas have consequences ( Richard Weaver)

Critical race theory , which is clearly a typically American phenomenon, posits that racism is omnipresent and operates relentlessly and constantly to the detriment of people of color, who are aware of it, and to the benefit of white people. Among the many privileges enjoyed by white people is the ability to live without ever having to become aware of the extent of this pervasive racism working to their advantage (Applebaum, 2007; Bell, 1991; Bell, 2008; Rollock and Gillborn, 2011). It is evident that the two fundamental tenets of postmodern philosophy—(1) the rejection of any claim to objective truth and its replacement by cultural relativism, and (2) the belief that knowledge is determined, conditioned, and modified by the exercise of power—occupy a prominent place in critical race theory (Hiraldo, 2010; Pluckrose and Lindsay, 2020).

Long confined to social science faculties, critical race theory has now emerged from its academic incubator (Perna, 2018). Indeed, around 2010, the idea that everything should be decolonized (including institutions or environments that had never been literally colonized) began to spread under the influence of activists and social justice warriors using and developing the concept of decolonization in increasingly radical ways (DiAngelo, 2018; DiAngelo 2021; Pluckrose and Lindsay, 2020).

As is often the case when an ideology reifies its fundamental dogmas, adherents of critical race theory are now seeking to shape tomorrow's society by producing and distributing propaganda materials. A case in point is the publication, in May 2021, of the booklet * A Pathway to Equitable Math Instruction* (Cintron, Wadlington, and ChenFeng, 2021), produced by the California-based activist group The Education Trust-West as part of its project entitled *Dismantling Racism in Mathematics Instruction *. Let's examine how the authors of the booklet present their work:

This booklet provides teachers with an opportunity to examine their actions, beliefs, and values ​​regarding mathematics education. This guide to deconstructing racism in mathematics offers essential characteristics of antiracist mathematics teachers and critical approaches to dismantling white supremacy in mathematics classrooms by making visible the toxic characteristics of white supremacist culture (Jones & Okun, 2001; Brown et al., 2016) as it relates to mathematics. (p. 4) 

As is often the case in literature associated with critical race theory, this booklet contains a multitude of references to patriarchy , white supremacist culture , the hoarding of power , and colonialism, which are said to exist “in a state of immanence—always and everywhere present, but disguised under a more agreeable veneer that does not entirely conceal them” (Pluckrose and Lindsay, 2020). Words like meritocracy and objectivity are also brandished as insults without any attempt at explanation to accompany these sweeping statements, presumably assuming they are self-evident.

As evidenced by the following excerpt, the Pathway booklet belongs to an increasingly large body of texts presenting as an indisputable truth that every white person contributes (deliberately or unconsciously) to maintaining a system that oppresses minorities (even if there were no one left to harbor racist intentions or beliefs in their hearts) and that it would be imperative to dismantle this Eurocentric system:

White supremacist culture manifests itself in the classroom when curriculum developers and enculturated (sic) teachers in the United States present mathematics as they were taught it, without critical reflection. This reinforces the idea that there is only one right way to do mathematics, which may not meet the needs of all students. The history of mathematics, its colonization, and what is considered “acceptable” knowledge is rich and complex. Therefore, the way mathematics is taught in the United States must be challenged, as it is currently centered on Western and Eurocentric ways of processing knowledge. When students who have been taught differently are required to learn in this way, they must unlearn their Indigenous traditions to meet the expectations of teachers, or they are deprived of learning mathematics in their ancestral history. (p. 38) 

For the authors of this booklet, dismantling racism in mathematics education and overcoming the mentalities that legitimize colonialism clearly requires advancing an ideological agenda rather than implementing best educational practices based on evidence: 

White supremacist culture manifests itself in the classroom when “good” mathematics education is seen as an antidote to mathematical inequity for Black, Latinx, and multilingual students. “Best practices” for mathematics pedagogy often exclude the unique needs of Black, Latinx, multilingual, and immigrant students. This reinforces either/or thinking by reinforcing stereotypes about the type of mathematics education that certain groups of students receive. It allows the defensiveness of Western mathematics to prevail, without addressing the underlying causes of why certain groups of students “underachieve,” a characterization that should also be up for examination. It also assumes that “good” mathematics education is about a Eurocentric type of mathematics, devoid of cultural ways of being. Instead, discover authentic, cultural ways of teaching and learning that represent the students in your classroom. Professional Development: As a department, study ethnomathematics and incorporate it into all classrooms. (p. 31) 

Although presented as a scientific synthesis, we will demonstrate that the Pathway booklet is a militant pamphlet. Not content with fomenting a revolution in education (a revolution which, in light of current scientific knowledge, has no chance whatsoever of improving the academic success prospects of the target audiences), its authors call into question the fundamental principles of the empirical method of scientific research in order to usher in an era of subjectivity, emotion, feeling, and intuition, all draped in the mantle of virtue of valiant knights resisting the forces of evil:

Identify and challenge ways in which mathematics is used to defend capitalist, imperialist, and racist views. Expose students to examples of people who have used mathematics as a means of resistance. Provide learning opportunities that use mathematics as a means of resistance. (p. 9) 

This booklet, which might raise a few eyebrows due to the radical nature of its arguments, is far from being the product of some obscure university department; it was funded to the tune of one million US dollars by the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation (Stieglitz, 2021). We will refrain from drawing too many conclusions from such funding, as that would be purely speculative. What is worth emphasizing, however, is that the ideas promoted in the Pathway booklet have attracted the attention of a foundation with an international reputation, demonstrating their growing importance. The booklet's website lists 25 partners and organizations that have implemented its strategies. These partners include teachers' associations in various US states, university departments, and other organizations conducting educational research. Moreover, the ideas conveyed in this booklet are currently being implemented in various school districts in Georgia, Ohio, California, and Oregon (Stieglitz, 2021), despite many voices being raised to decry its unnecessarily divisive nature.

This anti-racism guide does not appear to have actually been used in Canada, but similar documents have been put forward in Ontario. In 2021, Ontario's Grade 9 math curriculum stated that "mathematics has been used to normalize racism and the marginalization of non-Eurocentric mathematical knowledge" (Radio-Canada, 2021). This sentence has since been removed, but several media outlets reported it at the time. Following strong reactions in traditional media, social media, and from many teachers, the government changed this sentence to the following: "The curriculum emphasizes the need to remove barriers and better serve students who have been historically disadvantaged in mathematics education." (Radio-Canada, 2021) 

Also in Ontario, at the end of 2021, a judge ruled that the standardized mathematics test required of all prospective teachers caused racial disparities in results, and therefore the test was unconstitutional. For clarity, the judge specified that there were alternatives to the test to ensure teachers had a good grasp of the material without creating racial disparities ( Ontario Teacher Candidates' Council v. The Queen , 2021). This ruling has generated considerable reaction, and the government may appeal.

While not yet part of common sense, it is quite clear that the ideas contained in the Pathway booklet are increasingly popular and are part of a much broader movement of deconstruction in the name of anti-racism. In Quebec, too, we discuss the issues surrounding racism, but these questions have not yet entered the discourse of school service centres and the Ministry of Education through the lens of critical race theory. However, in recent years, fueled by the zeal of new converts, critical race theory has gradually gained ground in the Quebec media landscape, most often through the prism of American history (Bock-Côté, 2021). Public figures and activist commentators have gradually come to impose racialist language and terminology in the media and to present critical race theory as revealing indisputable truths that accurately describe Quebec society, to the point that the belief that society is made up of systems of power and identity-based privileges as pernicious as they are difficult to perceive at first glance should henceforth be considered the starting point from which to understand society. Add to this the previous examples and the presence of this movement in Ontario, and it is certain that the questions raised by critical race theory will arise in our institutions.

Share this article

Facebook X LinkedIn

Right of reply and contributions
Would you like to respond? Submit an opinion piece proposal →

You might also like:

The Forbidden Book: Ferghane Azihari Against Islam

Ferghane Azihari's latest essay offers a critique of Islam, which he portrays as inherently hostile to modernity, freedom, and progress. Despite its publishing success, Vincent Tournier has noted a silence or reluctance in the media to discuss these ideas.

Academic freedom under attack: from the Jason Arday case to the Nathan Cofnas case

The Jason Arday and Nathan Cofnas cases demonstrate how universities, alternately invoking inclusion or professional ethics (but not academic freedom), avoid assuming their own responsibilities. After examining Cofnas's controversial work, particularly on the heritability of intelligence, Jacques Robert considers some of his positions highly questionable from a scientific and ethical standpoint, but nevertheless believes they fall within the scope of academic freedom.
What you have left to read
0 %

Maybe you should subscribe?

Otherwise, it's okay! You can close this window and continue reading.

    Register: