by Alex Morey
October 12th 2020
translated from English by the Observatory of Decolonialism
(original version on thefire.org website)
Gordon Klein , a faculty member at UCLA, never imagined that a simple email exchange with a student this summer could place him at the center of an explosive international controversy. Accused of racism and abuse of power, and expelled from his class, Klein was dismissed from UCLA's Anderson School of Management, where his teaching had been impeccable for nearly 40 years.
“I meticulously followed university policy by refusing to discriminate,” Klein said of his email response to a white student who asked Klein to relax his grading to help black students during protests over the killing of George Floyd.
Klein stated that he was simply following the UCLA faculty code of conduct , which prohibits administering exams in any way other than as scheduled. It also forbids evaluating students on criteria other than academic performance and engaging in racial discrimination.
But Klein's message , which challenged the student to critically examine the implications of his request by suggesting a series of hypotheses highlighting problems with race-based ranking criteria, was misunderstood. Soon, a screenshot of the email was circulating on social media. Klein's dean quickly denounced the message publicly as "outrageous" and an "abuse of power," and UCLA placed Klein on leave, indicating that disciplinary action would follow. A petition calling for the professor's removal garnered 20,000 signatures.
Soon, however, a counter-petition for Klein's reinstatement garnered over 75,000 signatures. And after FIRE intervened —publicizing the case and reminding UCLA of its constitutional obligations regarding academic freedom— the university dropped the case in July, admitting it didn't even warrant an investigation.
But Klein - a nationally recognized accounting expert - said the personal cost of the controversy was immense.
Klein tells his story to FIRE. This interview has been lightly edited for length and clarity.
FIRE: How have you experienced these last few months?
Gordon Klein: The last few months have been very disconcerting and stimulating. I was very surprised, of course, to be at the center of a controversy.
All I had done was reach out to a student, who I knew well enough from having had him in class before, and try to challenge his reasoning when he seemed to encourage me to racially profile, to identify students based on their race, to discriminate based on stereotypes.
These stereotypes being, in his opinion, that his black classmates were less capable than he, a non-black individual, in terms of performance in the classroom.
I thought I was simply challenging him, in a Socratic way, to reconsider his reasoning that grades should depend on the color of a person's skin, rather than on a particular assessment reflecting an individual's performance at a given moment.
This caused quite a storm, much to my surprise.
FIRE: When did you realize it was exploding? And what did you do?
Klein: Within hours, my email had been shared with people outside the university, and a number of these people from outside organized themselves to complain to the university's higher-ups, including the chancellor and my dean.
And it seems like they made multiple accusations against me to the dean. But none of my accusers ever identified themselves as knowing me or being a student of mine. Some were from outside the campus and some were not even students.
The dean asked me to call him that evening, which I did. To my surprise, the dean spoke to me on the phone for about a minute, tops, and then hung up.
He didn't give me any opportunity to explain myself, and he wouldn't listen to the context. He simply acknowledged that we had known each other for a long time and that he was referring the matter to the "BPD", which I later understood to be the Office for the Prevention of Discrimination. I taught at the university for 39 years and during that time taught about 23 students, and I had never heard of the Office for the Prevention of Discrimination because my teaching record and my relationships with students were always impeccable.
I was deeply disappointed by the dean, who did not even give me the opportunity to explain the circumstances.
The next morning, he sent emails to all those students who were complaining and accusing me of being racist, telling them that I had indeed behaved inappropriately. He described my conduct as “inexcusable” and “outrageous.” The next day, he sent a message to alumni and faculty saying that I had violated the core principles of the Anderson School of Management and had engaged in “an abuse of power.” That email, addressed to the Anderson community at large, was sent to tens of thousands of people.
Many of them are my friends, former students, colleagues or business associates in the local community. I was astounded that he did this. Especially because the university has very strict policies on privacy and confidentiality when it comes to personnel management. And there are normally very strict policies to ensure due process.
In other words, it was not the Dean's job to act as judge and executioner. It was the Dean's job to refer the case back to the University for further investigation. And in the meantime, it was his job to remain silent.
What is very ironic, now that I have been reinstated, is that when the media asks the University to say why they made this huge mistake, they invoke confidentiality and say they cannot speak on this subject.
This happened at a very strange time for American society. There were riots across the street from campus, and I think UCLA was very concerned about the possibility of them spreading to campus. I think the dean acted unwisely in making me a scapegoat, in the hopes of appeasing the mob.
It didn't work. All it did was destroy my reputation and my relationships with my colleagues and friends. Because I come from a very politically progressive family, I was aware that it might destroy my family relationships.
FIRE: How did you end up getting in touch with FIRE [an organization defending freedoms at university]?
Klein: I was at the center of this controversy, with 75,000 people signing a petition demanding that the university rehire me. Among those 75,000 people were many wonderful supporters I would never have met otherwise, as well as former students who know me, know my character, and know my kindness toward them in the past and present. Several of them contacted me and suggested I get in touch with FIRE.
And thankfully I did, because I received incredible help, compassion and understanding at a time when I was under attack. Not just professional attacks, but I was receiving death threats requiring police protection.
The FIRE attorney I spoke to was incredibly helpful, wrote a letter to the university, gave me advice on this. FIRE brought the case. I think that's what prompted the UCLA Committee on Academic Freedom to do an independent investigation.
And the Committee on Academic Freedom made a decision that made it clear that what had been done to me was wrong, and that it would have an incredibly chilling effect on me personally and, much more seriously, on the conduct of all faculty at the University of California.
The committee made a special point that if you can be publicly humiliated like I was, no one will dare to do their job well. No one will speak freely. No one will pursue research that might lead to a controversial conclusion. No one will speak in class in a way that will stimulate controversy and discussion. No one will ever address some of the most important issues of our time, such as issues of discrimination, freedom of speech, and freedom of association.
I was therefore very grateful for FIRE's actions, which were a catalyst for the UCLA Academic Senate's Committee on Academic Freedom to reach the conclusions they did on the importance of a free exchange of ideas on campus , including ideas that might encourage students to revise their thinking.
Unfortunately, at this point, professors are afraid to do anything that might cause controversy.
This is a horrible situation, because freedom of exchange of ideas is the very nature of a university. When you feel that you can only say one kind of idea or you feel compelled to self-censor, you create a lowest common denominator of blandness in the educational process.
I think it is important that people involved in the educational process are able to propose extreme hypotheses.
I think it's important to be able to ask students challenging questions.
FIRE: Was the worst part of this experience that people believed you were racist?
Klein: It was, and remains, a horrible scarlet letter that was placed on me, based on an email that was completely taken out of context.
The social media mob deliberately failed to publish the first email from the student I was responding to, because if that message had been published, it would have mentioned that the author himself was not black. And it would have mentioned that the author himself was not in any particular emotional distress. And it would have mentioned that I had previously sent the class anti-racist materials.
All of these facts would have led a reasonable observer, reading what I wrote, to recognize that I found the student's email condescending and paternalistic toward black students.
In my opinion, all of my students are capable. All of my students are talented. And I don’t discriminate based on race. I was frankly offended that this individual, who I knew was not black and who identified himself in his email as not black, would dare insult and characterize his classmates as less capable, less persistent, or less talented than he was. And so, if there was racism, the racism came from the student who wrote to me. And I challenged that racism.
FIRE: Can you tell me how you took the news of your reinstatement?
Klein: I knew I would be reinstated because I knew there was not an ounce of discrimination in my heart or in my communication.
I knew what my contract told me about upholding university values against racial stereotypes.
I knew I had done nothing wrong.
I was pleased that the Academic Senate, without any action on my part, investigated this matter on its own and justified all my conduct. It stated that if a student asks a provocative question to a professor, the professor has the right to respond to that provocative question and challenge the student's reasoning. I also learned later that the Office for the Prevention of Discrimination did not even investigate this matter. It closed the file without even bothering to speak to me because a clear reading of the email chain from beginning to end indicated that I had done nothing wrong.
And so, I knew I would be reinstated. It was just a matter of time for that reinstatement to happen.
FIRE: But it seems things haven't returned to normal.
Klein: Regarding the damage done to me, there's the old adage: "What are you doing to restore your reputation?"
The initial accusations were widely publicized and remain on the internet forever. When someone is rehabilitated, it rarely has the same impact in the media or online. So it remains to be seen how horribly damaged my reputation is.
I am pleased to know that most of my friends and relatives, and I hope my colleagues, recognize that the way the dean presented me was not who I am and that it was a caricature, at a very difficult time in America when the university needed a scapegoat.
The person I blame is my dean. Unlike people on social media, he had a job to do. Before he destroys the livelihood and reputation of one of his most trusted colleagues, he has a duty to be meticulous, careful, respectful, and abide by the university’s confidentiality rules. He acted recklessly, causing me untold harm, from death threats to the loss of my outside income.
Indeed, on the very day I was reinstated, he sent another message to tens of thousands of people that again denigrated me, tacitly suggesting that I would be reinstated, but that there was another part of the story that, due to confidentiality, could not be disclosed. He is not ashamed of anything. He knew there was nothing more to the story, but he decided to create the illusion that, although he was disowned by the School, he would have been right if all the facts were known.
Let me be clear. He was reckless. He was insensitive. And the School has caused me indelible harm.
There are certain accusations in this world that are horrible, and rightly so. A true racist must be denounced in society and must be marginalized.
But someone who is not racist and is labeled as such suffers enormous harm.
FIRE: How should universities handle these types of allegations?
Klein: In my opinion, universities should definitely investigate any allegation of racism. They shouldn't tolerate it. I support that.
I have volunteered at UCLA over the years for programs that serve underprivileged students, many of whom are minorities. I revere those programs, and I revere the university for its belief that everyone should be treated equally.
It seems to me, however, that in some recent situations, universities, instead of defending the importance of the free exchange of ideas or the rigorous examination of facts through due process, react reflexively and condemn someone who has been accused without foundation.
I can't talk about every situation in the world and every other teacher. I don't know these facts well enough. But I can talk about what happened to me and I know that my situation has turned into a horrible caricature.
FIRE: Can you tell me why you became a teacher? What do you like about teaching?
Klein: I'm someone who has been fortunate enough to succeed in both the business and legal worlds. I'm a qualified lawyer and a certified public accountant. And it's always been important to me to be involved in education. My mother was a schoolteacher. I have a brother who is a teacher and an uncle who is a teacher. And we were always raised to be generous with others and to give back what we had received.
My passion for teaching comes from a desire to help others. A way of “giving back,” because others were generous to me and gave me advice when I was younger. I do my best to mentor others, whether it’s giving them background knowledge, teaching them critical thinking, or coaching them in their careers. It’s also a desire to always be surrounded by bright, talented, curious, and optimistic individuals. Most students have an abundance of talents and interests, and their varied experiences have enriched my life beyond belief.
I like to put it this way: Many people go to college, meet dozens of people, and leave with maybe a dozen good friends. I feel like I’ve been a part of 39 UCLA graduating classes, interacting with about 600 students each year. As a result, I’ve met people from every part of the world, every race, every religion, and every life experience. And I’m fascinated by that. Some people have hobbies, like sports or art. My greatest joy is interacting with and learning from others.
I hope I can also pass on some knowledge to them.