Observatoire academic ethics
Menu

Nathalie Heinich, response to Libération

Illustration for the article "Nathalie Heinich, response to Libération"

Nathalie Heinich, response to Libération

Nathalie Heinich

Researcher, sociologist
On May 12, a post by Simon Blin appeared in Libération entitled "Anti-wokism, an inexhaustible editorial vein", devoted to my book Would Wokism be a totalitarianism? recently published by Albin Michel. Here is my response, published in the daily newspaper on May 19 under the title "For a left-wing anti-wokism".

Table of contents

This article has no sections.

Nathalie Heinich, response to Libération

On May 12 , an article by Simon Blin entitled "Anti-'Wokism': An Inexhaustible Publishing Vein" appeared in Libération , devoted to my book , *Would Wokism Be a Totalitarianism ?*, recently published by Albin Michel. Here is my response, published in the newspaper on May 19 under the title "For a Left-Wing Anti-Wokism."

Since wokeness has become a subject of debate in academia, the cultural world and the media, assimilation has become automatic: wokeness would be left-wing, obviously, and anti-wokeness right-wing, necessarily – or even far-right. And certainly, in the United States, where the phenomenon comes from, the Trumpists have resolutely mounted the anti-woke crusade, adding to their usual targets of censorship “gender theory”, “critical race theory” and the “DE & I” protocol (Diversity, Equity and Inclusion). It is difficult, under these conditions, to denounce the excesses of wokeness without risking being excluded from one’s own camp when speaking from the left.

And yet, within the progressive camp, a growing number of voices are daring to assert that one can, and indeed must, denounce "wokism" not simply because one is left-wing, but precisely because one is left-wing. Although still tentative, hampered by intimidation, this left-wing anti-wokism has emerged, even in the United States, through the writings of Mark Lilla, Jonathan Haidt, and Susan Neiman, and in Spain, through Daniel Bernabé. This critique is not that of progressivism, as is the case with the National Rally, which has recently made anti-wokism its new rallying cry, just as it did secularism. For it is not a matter of denying the reality of injustices, inequalities, and discrimination of all kinds, nor the necessity of combating them. The aim is to oppose the excesses of a pseudo-progressivism that is an enemy of those humanist values ​​such as republican universalism, rationality, secularism and freedom of expression.

But Wokism, based on a communitarianism borrowed from Anglo-Saxon political culture, is by definition anti-universalist, indifferent to the common good because it is obsessed with affiliations to victimhood narratives. It prefers ideology to science (or prides itself on conflating the two, which amounts to the same thing). It sees the defense of secularism as an attack on religious minorities. And it practices, without qualms, the rampant form of censorship known as cancel culture , seemingly untroubled by this paradoxical contradiction between an ideological censorship claiming to be progressive and a left-wing tradition that has always defended freedom of expression.

Identitarianism, ideologism, censorship: these are the major components of wokeism in its various forms, from inclusive writing to the activism of knowledge, from the rewriting of texts to the toppling of statues, from identity assignments to semantic prohibitions and the concealment of class relations behind racial and gender obsession. However, each of these components is part of a certain form of totalitarianism.

This word here does not of course refer to a totalitarian regime, as those who pretend not to understand are trying to make me say: the hold of wokeness on a part of the university and the cultural world, its penetration into large companies and its infiltration into the radical left have not yet been transformed, fortunately, into a state power. It is, for the moment, what I have called a "totalitarianism of atmosphere": a totalitarian mentality, more or less prevalent depending on the context, which tends to pass for granted these obligatory assignments, these prohibitions imposed in the name of "wounded sensibilities", these programs of re-education and rewriting of the classics, this perverse game on the alliance of victimization and guilt, which should bristle any progressive worthy of the name.

So this is the essence of my argument: to identify and denounce the potentially totalitarian dimension of wokeness from a left-wing position, which is concerned about the way in which certain excesses open up a boulevard to the RN.

But old sectarian reflexes resurface, dismissing any questioning by stigmatizing it as reactionary or even far-right. "The feeling of déjà vu is immense," asserted a Libération article on May 12th devoted to my book, *Is Wokism a Totalitarianism? * Its author believes he knows its political orientation: "The essay could be written by a National Rally ideologue and no one would notice." But where have they "already read" my analysis? And isn't this viewpoint likely to interest the readers of a left-wing newspaper?

And, as in the days when it was not Wokeism but Stalinism that dominated the progressive camp, those who want to remain faithful to it find themselves forced to betray their own values, while those who want to remain faithful to their values ​​find themselves traitors to their own camp. This is the paradoxical injunction that, in the past, some were able to resist, before the truth of the facts imposed itself and finally proved them right. With Wokeism, it is in the form of a dark farce that this dirty story is repeated.

This is why the defenders of wokeism who equate its protest with reactionary thinking and accuse its detractors of "playing into the hands of the extreme right," just as the Gulag denouncers were once accused of being "CIA agents," unwittingly demonstrate what they strive to deny: namely, that, for want of taking the trouble to think, they fit perfectly into the totalitarian mentality. This is, alas, "the impression of an immense déjà-lu."

Share this article

Facebook X LinkedIn

Right of reply and contributions
Would you like to respond? Submit an opinion piece proposal →

You might also like:

Convergence of struggles

Ms. Panot has succeeded in converging a strange struggle she has waged against public health and anti-Semitism! We expect her to use Israel, and therefore all Jews no doubt, to justify the fight against the high cost of living, against the loss of biodiversity, and who knows what else? 

Timeline of a disaster: how gender entered French higher education policy

At the turn of the 21st century, gender policy in higher education did not yet take the familiar form it would assume fifteen years later in French universities. Feminist research, policies promoting equality between women and men, and debates on the place of women in scientific careers all predated it. But the turn of the century saw the systematization, in several countries, of another approach: it was no longer simply a matter of helping individuals or correcting inequalities on an ad hoc basis, but of transforming the institutions that produced or reproduced them.
What you have left to read
0 %

Maybe you should subscribe?

Otherwise, it's okay! You can close this window and continue reading.

    Register: