Read More With the protests against pension reform, which were accompanied by criticism of institutions, calls for a "democratic renewal" aimed at ensuring greater citizen participation have multiplied. Such calls are not new. Having emerged over the past quarter-century, they have gained legitimacy to the point of becoming almost incantatory. The focus is now on "inventing" new forms of democracy, and this notion of innovation is readily adopted by official discourse, whether in France, Europe, or more generally in the West. For their part, academics have largely embraced this theme, lending it their support and endorsement. Yet, a question arises: what is new? What does it mean to "reinvent" democracy or to establish "new forms" of participation? Can we truly innovate in politics after 2000 years of history, especially in France where every political regime has been tried? The truth is less inspiring: there is nothing new under the sun. No one has invented anything in recent decades. The fundamental mechanisms of democracy were established long ago and have hardly changed: the free election of representatives, the separation of powers, the independence of the judiciary. These mechanisms are certainly not perfect, nor are they entirely fixed, as the parameters can shift according to the times and the countries, but for now, no country has demonstrated that more satisfactory democratic mechanisms exist. From this perspective, Francis Fukuyama, whom we have so often ridiculed, was right. Yet, the idea that it is possible to imagine alternatives to classical democracy has steadily gained momentum. This focus on innovation has had two major effects. The first consequence was the complete indifference shown towards the decline in voter turnout. The rise in abstention was considered a mere consequence of distrust in conventional participation, or even proof of a yearning for democratic renewal. As a result, no one truly sought to engage in serious reflection on the real causes of this democratic malaise. The second consequence was to embolden those who dream of dismantling democratic institutions. Nothing could please them more than proposing to replace the most vital mechanisms of democracy with supposedly more democratic ones that, in reality, contribute to its undermining. In a way, the arguments in favor of "citizens' conferences" reinforce the idea that democracy lies elsewhere. Seemingly without effort, they are reviving the imagery of "workers' councils" and other "committees for the defense of the Revolution," where activists have long since learned to reign supreme. In ordinary times, these proposals for alternative democracy find little resonance among the population. Moreover, the experiments in participatory democracy in recent years have hardly demonstrated their usefulness or effectiveness, especially when the public is openly mocked by claiming to be composed of randomly selected citizens. But conditions have changed. The Observatory of Decolonialism constantly warns of the return of ideologies of rupture, often based on identity politics, and therefore inherently hostile to representative democracy and political compromise. These aggressive ideologies reject, on principle, the electoral process and the alternation of power. The debate on pension reform offers a glimpse of this: for opponents, not only are constitutional mechanisms like Article 49.3 deemed illegitimate (despite their legal nature and being significantly more democratic than citizens' assemblies), but it apparently doesn't occur to them that it's possible to wait until the next election to present a counter-proposal. In these troubled times, where conspiracy theories and political violence are experiencing a resurgence, perhaps it's time to stop playing with fire.* Vincent Tournier is a lecturer at Sciences Po Grenoble and a member of the Observatory of Decolonialism.
With the protests against pension reform , which were accompanied by criticism of institutions, calls for a "democratic renewal" aimed at ensuring greater citizen participation have proliferated. Such appeals are not new. Having emerged over the past quarter-century, they have gained legitimacy to the point of becoming almost incantatory. The focus is now on "inventing" new forms of democracy, and this notion of innovation is readily adopted by official discourse, whether in France , Europe , or the West in general . For their part, academics have extensively engaged with this theme, lending it their support and endorsement.
Yet, a question arises: what is new? What does it mean to "reinvent" democracy or to establish "new forms" of participation? Can we really innovate in politics after 2000 years of history, especially in France where all political regimes have been tested?
The truth is less exciting: there's nothing new under the sun. No one has invented anything in recent decades. The fundamental mechanisms of democracy were established long ago and have hardly changed: the free election of representatives, the separation of powers, and the independence of the judiciary. These mechanisms are certainly not perfect, nor are they entirely fixed, as the parameters can shift depending on the era and the country, but for now, no country has demonstrated the existence of more satisfactory democratic mechanisms. From this perspective, Francis Fukuyama , whom we have so often ridiculed, was right.
Breakthrough ideologies
Yet the idea that it is possible to imagine alternatives to classical democracy has continued to grow in strength. This polarization on innovation has had two major effects. The first is to have left the decline in electoral participation in the greatest indifference. The rise in abstention has been considered as a simple consequence of distrust of conventional participation, or even as proof of an aspiration for a democratic renewal. As a result, no one has really sought to engage in serious reflection on the real causes of democratic malaise.
The second effect is to have comforted those who dream of bringing down democratic institutions. Nothing could indeed please them more than to propose replacing the most vital mechanisms of democracy with supposedly more democratic mechanisms but which in reality contribute to sabotaging it. In a certain way, the pleas in favor of "citizens' conferences" accredit the idea that democracy is elsewhere. Without seeming to, they rehabilitate the imaginary of "workers' councils" and other "committees for the defense of the Revolution" where activists have long learned to reign supreme.
In normal times, these proposals for alternative democracy have little response from the population. Moreover, the experiments in participatory democracy in recent years have hardly proven their usefulness and effectiveness, especially when the public is openly mocked by claiming to have randomly selected citizens sit on them.
But conditions have changed. The Observatory of Decolonialism continues to warn of the return of ideologies of rupture, often based on identity-based logics, and therefore hostile in principle to representative democracy and political compromises.
These aggressive ideologies reject electoral processes and the alternation of power on principle. The debate on pension reform provides a glimpse of this: for opponents, not only are constitutional mechanisms like Article 49.3 deemed illegitimate (despite their legal nature and being clearly more democratic than citizens' conferences), but it apparently doesn't occur to them that it's possible to wait until the next election to present a counter-proposal.
In these troubled times when conspiracy theories and political violence are enjoying a resurgence in popularity, it might be time to stop playing with fire.
*Vincent Tournier is a lecturer at Sciences Po Grenoble and a member of the Observatory of Decolonialism.
"This post is a summary of information from our information monitoring"